36 Best Pizza Restaurants near New Cumberland

CountryBoys Pizza Meal Delivery • $$
2463 Race Track Rd, New Cumberland

“THE BEST CALZONES EVER AND FRIENDLY SERVICE.“

4.9 Superb8 Reviews
Big Al's Sandwich Shop • $
1420 Mountaineer Cir, New Cumberland

“Don't tell anyone because I don't want to get anyone in trouble in case they weren't allowed because they really didn't know if they'd get in trouble but they heated up our wings we brought. It was really late & I had seen the safe last time we stayed mistaking it for a microwave, I'm an old lady so don't laugh. Anyway, they were really nice to heat them for us.“

4 Good4 Reviews
DiCarlo's Pizza - Sunset Blvd Steubenville Pizza • $
4531 Sunset Blvd, Steubenville - 9.57 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza
Pizzaaaaaaaaaa

“First timer for me. Took my mother in law who us 81 and back in Ohio for the 1st time in 30 years ...its the ONE place she HAD to go too. Said it was EXACTLY how she remembered it from her high-school days 🥰 our hearts and bellies are FULL. 5 ⭐️“

4.7 Superb54 Reviews
Bells Pizza and Calzones Pizza • $
41 Reichart Ave, Wintersville - 10.4 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni & Cheese Pizza Tray-28 Slices
Meat Lovers Calzone
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Add Ricotta Cheese
Cheesy Breadsticks
Cheesecake Cones
Pepperoni Rolls
Stuffed Pizza
White Pizza
Meatlover

“Wonderful calzones!! Recommend the buffalo calzone“

4.6 Superb62 Reviews
Mrs C's Pizza LLC Pizza Delivery • $
628 Dresden Ave Suite #4, East Liverpool - 8.71 miles

Customers` Favorites

16 Inch 12 Cut Cheese Pizza
Kids Spaghetti & Meatball
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Cheesesticks
Calzone

“I got a chicken salad last night and it was good. I've also had the pulled pork hoagie a few times and it was good also, plus I've had the stuffed shells the delicious also!!“

4.8 Superb28 Reviews
Gianni's Weirton Pizza • $
1508 Pennsylvania Ave, Weirton - 5.6 miles

Customers` Favorites

Bacon Turkey Club
Italian Stromboli
Meatball Calzone
White Pizza
Italian Sub
Gyro Salad
Other

“Gianni's staff are fantastic! Their pizza is addictive and I love the prices. I hope they add more items to the menu“

4.9 Superb22 Reviews
Gem City Pizza Pizza • $
901 Franklin St, Toronto - 2.68 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sweet & Spicy Pizza
Individual Square
Pepperoni Pizza
Stix with Roni
Meatball Zone
Italian Zone
Garden Salad
C B R Pizza
Roni Rolls

“Good food always on time and correct sometimes I would like a little more cheese in my calzone but regardless it’s still amazingly good 😊“

4.7 Superb28 Reviews
Paul's Pizza Pizza • $
224 N 4th St, Toronto - 2.14 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni and Cheese Pizza with Half Sausage
Dicarlos Original Pizza with Three Toppings
Regular Calzone with Cheese & Pepperoni
Cheese Pizza Tray with Three Toppings
Cheese Pizza Tray with One Topping
Square Cheese Pizza Tray
Ham & Provolone Hoagie
Garlic Sauce Side
Antipasto Salad
Italian Hoagie

“Great pizza! Always crispy crust and always consistent. Can’t beat the prices!“

4.6 Superb36 Reviews
Martoni's Fire Baked Pizza Pizza • $
104 N 4th St, Steubenville - 9.44 miles

Customers` Favorites

Hot Capicola Hoagie with Cheese
Plane Jane 10 Inch Pizza
Pepperoni Sausage Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Martonironi Calzone
Martonironi Pizza
Topping - Meatball
Pepperoni Calzone
6 Meatball Sand
Fresh Cut Fries

“Just walked in, while looking at the nutcracker displays. Had a top notch calzone, wife had a meatball sub, it was huge. Food tasted great, tried Italian lemon soda pop. Price was very reasonable. If you are in area, it’s worth the visit.“

4.5 Superb49 Reviews
Pittera Pizza Pizza • $
132 Hollywood Blvd, Steubenville - 8.96 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sausage w Peppers and Onions Catering Pan
Wedding Soup
White Pizza
Sicilian
Cannoli
Italian
Sauce

“another GREAT pizza! best in the valley, if you ask me. thank you!“

4.7 Superb20 Reviews
Nick's Pizza Pizza • $
349 Main St, Wellsville - 8.04 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza
Hot Sausage

“Amazing tonight yes!!! 🍕 🍕 🍕“

4.9 Superb13 Reviews
Marko's Pizza Pizza Takeaway • $
1577 Pennsylvania Ave, East Liverpool - 10.35 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni & Cheese
Pepperoni Rolls
Meatball Sub
Mild Sausage
Cod Sandwich
Hot Sausage
Tray Pizza

“The pizza was exactly what I was looking for the classic Ohio valley style! Square cuts on a crunchy but airy crust and finished with fixins’. The staff were very friendly and getting bombarded with calls, so be patient. It’s worth the wait.“

4.4 Superb47 Reviews
Iggy's Pizza Pizza • $
1332 Franklin St, Toronto - 3 miles

Customers` Favorites

Bacon Cheese Burger N Fries
Basil Pesto Chicken Pizza
Twice Babed Potato Pizza
Roasted Vegetable Salad
Chicken & Broccoli
Fettuccine Alfredo
Roast Beef Hoagie
Chicken Parmesan
Chicken Fontina
Ham and Cheese

“Iggy's has amazing food at great prices. We are happy to deliver it to you or you can come dine in with your family and enjoy a great experience. I love Iggy's.“

4.4 Superb31 Reviews
Mikey's Subs & Stuff Pizza • $
1240 PA-168, Georgetown - 9.13 miles

Customers` Favorites

Crispy Chicken Salad
Roasted Chicken Sub
Pizza Logs
Steak Salad
Wings
Fries
Club
Chef

“Awesome customer service with great, affordable food! I will definitely be a regular customer here.“

4.8 Superb11 Reviews
Mario DiCarlo’s Pizza Pizza • $
203 Three Springs Dr, Weirton - 7.14 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sicilian Pizza X-Cheese

“Best pizza in WV.. I always get the reg with pepperoni“

4.3 Superb50 Reviews
MattiAnna's Pizza Pizza • $
525 Main St, Wellsville - 7.91 miles

Customers` Favorites

Large Pepperoni Pizza
Cheese Bread Sticks
BBQ Chicken Hawaiian
Pepperoni & Cheese
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Buffalo Chicken
Pepperoni Roll
Aunnie Bowl
Pickle

“Pizza was delicious! I’m so glad we decided to give the pizza a try! My husband even liked the calzone. Pictures in comments“

4.4 Superb22 Reviews
Bruno's Pizza Pizza • $
2605 Sunset Blvd, Steubenville - 8.77 miles

Customers` Favorites

Twelve Pizza Slices
Cheese & Pepperoni
Pepperoni Pizza
White Pizza
Pizza Tray
Steak

“I’ve only had the pizza and it’s delicious. I would recommend it to all my friends.“

4.3 Superb36 Reviews
Ray's Pizza Pizza • $
754 Main St, Wintersville - 9.74 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cheese & Pepperoni
Bread Stix
Pizza

“Best around!“

4.3 Superb34 Reviews
Roma's Pizza Pizza • $$
559 Carolina Ave, Chester - 8.48 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cheese Pizza Pie
Pepperoni Pizza

“Always great food and service“

4.5 Superb12 Reviews
Malta's Pizza Pizza • $
414 Market St, Steubenville - 9.45 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cheese Stuffed Breadsticks with Sauce
Pepperoni Blast Pizza
Philly Cheese Steak
Zucchini Strips
Pineapple Pizza
Antipasto Salad
Pepperoni Roll
Pepperoni Pizza
Monster Burger
Garlic Bread

“I've ordered here a few times for lunch and I have to say the make really good pizza and calzones. Friendly people and good service. I highly recommend this place.“

4.3 Superb24 Reviews
Rubi's Pizza & Grill Pizza • $
225 Franciscan Square, Steubenville - 8.54 miles

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Meat Lovers Pizza
Pepperoni Sticks
Pepperoni Pizza
Pepperoni Roll
White Pizza
Greek Pizza
Taco Pizza
2 Liter
Tiramisu

“Excellent! Perfect as always!“

4.1 Good57 Reviews
Roma's Pizza Pizza Takeaway •
1822 Pennsylvania Ave, Weirton - 5.63 miles

“We reached out to Angel a week before a business luncheon and asked for her assistance. While they are an Italian restaurant we wanted to make sure we had a mixture of vegetarian and low carb options. Wow! It was so impressive. They had the most gorgeous salad, fresh fruit and vegetables, sandwiches, a ginormous charcuterie spread, buffalo dip, chicken skewers and so much more. The presentation was fabulous too. They obviously take pride in their work and it showed because the set up looked like an artist’s palette of delicious food. I highly recommend Belmonte’s for catering.“

5 Superb1 Reviews
Bella C's Pizza Pizza • $
841 Main St, Wellsville - 7.72 miles

“Had heard very good things about Bella C's Pizza, so decided to go there tonite. Sadly to discover that they're only open on Friday and Saturday nights.“

5 Superb1 Reviews
Theo Yianni's Greek • $
322 American Way, Weirton - 7.94 miles

Customers` Favorites

Gyro Platter with Regular Fries
Dolmathes Grape Leaves
Grilled Chicken Salad
Gyro and Greek Fries
Greek Village Salad
Lollipop Lamb Chops
Baklava Cheesecake
Flaming Saganaki
Greek Side Salad
Chicken Sandwich

“First time eating here. Amazing food and amazing service. 5⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ all the way. every restaurant should should be this way.“

4.5 Superb134 Reviews
DeFelice Bros Pizza - Wintersville Pizza • $
497 Cadiz Rd, Wintersville - 10.14 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cheese Breadsticks
Ham and Cheese Sub
Meatball Calzone
Taco Pizza

“we got taco pizza and spinach pizza delivered..it was sooo hot and amazing! Great job Defelice!“

4 Good27 Reviews
Belmonte's Pizza Pizza • $
243 Three Springs Dr Suite #15, Weirton - 7.45 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pizza

“I can’t eat any other local pizza without suffering consequences. I can eat their pizza with no problem. The crust is like a piece of heaven I like the buffalo chicken. My husband prefers the pepperoni pizza. This has become our weekly pizza stop today. I have their spinach and artichoke dip with some of their chips. Absolutely the best I’ve ever had.“

4 Good11 Reviews
Bruno's Pizza Pizza • $
525 W Carolina Ave, Chester - 8.43 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza

“I had almost given up on Brunos until this week when I tried the Chester Brunos. It's what Calcutta Brunos used to be. Great pizza.“

3.9 Good32 Reviews
Giovanni's Restaurant Italian • $
3013 Pennsylvania Ave, Weirton - 6.48 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cheese Ravioli Gnocchi
Beer Battered Fish
Chicken Alfredo
Large Gnocchi
Caprese Salad
Garlic Bread

“Always great food and the staff is super friendly“

4.5 Superb53 Reviews
Cadence Vault Gastropub Chicken Wings • $
200 E 5th St, East Liverpool - 8.55 miles

Customers` Favorites

Crispy Chicken Sandwich
Woodfired Seasonal Crisp
Fiesta Wood Fire Pizza
Pulled Pork Nachos
Wood Grilled Pizza
Pizza Margherita
Pepperoni Pizza
Margarita Pizza
Polenta Sliders
Caesar Salad

“Absolutely delicious food. The chef is incredible. We’ve had appetizers, pizza, and entrees - all absolutely delicious, zero complaints. This place is a gem in our area. Waiters are so friendly and chill (while clearly working hard - please be patient!) I’d be here weekly if we lived closer!“

4.4 Superb56 Reviews
Bosco's Pizza Pizza • $
1835 St Clair Ave, East Liverpool - 9.69 miles

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Steak Salad with Fries Provolone Cheese
Pepperoni Pizza with Hot Sausage
Battered Cod Fish Sandwich
Pepperoni Cheese Pizza
Loaf Garlic Bread
Cheese & Pepperoni
Onion Rings
Heated Ham

“I don't live in ELO anymore, but I try to stop at Bosco's when I'm in town. Sat Nov 9th, 2024 I stopped & had the best pizza I've had in a long time. I bought a tray & was so glad I did. I ate way more than I should have. Since I knew it would be a while before I'd have a chance to stop again. Thank you Bosco's Pizza!!“

3.5 Good15 Reviews
Green Acres Cafe American • $
412 Harmon Creek Rd, Colliers - 8.52 miles

“A Really great peaceful place and a friendly style and lots of great fun“

4.9 Superb12 Reviews
Mario's Restaurant & Lounge Italian • $
3810 Main St, Weirton - 7 miles

Customers` Favorites

Wedding Soup Hot Pepper Soup House Salad
2 Squares Regular Pizza Slice
Veal Parmigiana with Gnocchi
Chicken Parmigiana
Eggplant Parmesan
Chicken Parmesan
Homemade Pasta
Fish Sandwich
Chicken Salad
Baked Ziti

“The atmosphere isn't anything special, and the space isn't great for large groups. The prices to change anything, including noodle or sauce type, is absolutely absurd. I expected a little bit of cheese on the chicken Parm, but there was a solid slab of cheese on the chicken that slides right off if you aren't careful.“

4.4 Superb43 Reviews
Domino's Pizza Pizza Delivery • $
1377 Franklin St, Toronto - 3.05 miles

Customers` Favorites

Medium Two-Topping Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Alfredo
Hawaiian Pizza
Buffalo Wings
Deluxe Pizza
Tater Tots
Lava Cake

“I love my domino's this is the place if you want pizza , pasta , oven baked sandwiches“

3.6 Good25 Reviews
Roma's Pizza Pizza Takeaway •
310 Elizabeth Dr, Weirton - 6.04 miles
3.6 Good33 Reviews
Vocelli Pizza Pizza • $
1925 Pennsylvania Ave, Weirton - 5.69 miles

Customers` Favorites

Build Your Own 12 Medium Pizza
Pepperoni Stromboli
Marinara Sauce
Slice of Pizza
Deluxe Pizza

“BEST pizza and calzones in town! The marinara is amazing, my favorite is the Spicy Italian calzone. They have the best service, friendly employees and hands down best food in town! Highly Recommended ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

3.4 Good26 Reviews
Pizza Hut Pizza Delivery • $
160 Main St #22, Wintersville - 9.66 miles

Customers` Favorites

Traditional Garlic Parmesan Wings
Ultimate Chocolate Chip Cookie
Honey Barbeque Boneless Wings
24 Breaded Bone-Out Wings
Triple Chocolate Brownie
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Cinnabon Mini Rolls
Personal Pan Pizza
Pizza Dinner Box
Cinnamon Sticks

“Got the Spicy Lover's Pizza today and whoever cut it clearly does not have the slightest clue what they are doing! I mean seriously, who cuts a pizza like this? Is there a competition between employees on who can cut it the worst? How is it even to be shared?“

3.5 Good59 Reviews

You May Also Like