Pizza Restaurants near New Cumberland

“Absolutely, love ice dogs, everything they have. The Pulice's that own it are the greatest people in the world. The girls that work there are funny and smart And always happy to see me. they take great care of me and my Dave. Highly Recommended.“

“Don't tell anyone because I don't want to get anyone in trouble in case they weren't allowed because they really didn't know if they'd get in trouble but they heated up our wings we brought. It was really late & I had seen the safe last time we stayed mistaking it for a microwave, I'm an old lady so don't laugh. Anyway, they were really nice to heat them for us.“

“Best calzones!!!! The fillings were plenty and the dough baked perfectly!“

“This pizza is the Best, Ohio valley style pizza to date... De Carlos is good. Bruno's is good but as far as texture and consistency this pizza takes the Cake.. what I want to know is why do they all taste the same?? It's like they're using the same supplier. Same cheese source, same sauce, same everything... The only thing that changes is the texture.. would it be too much to ask to add some spices to the sauce or maybe use a aged provolone? Anyhow, this pizza is single-handedly the best pizza in Ohio that I found so far.. and West Virginia.. If you like crispy crunchy crust with the Ohio valley style sauce and cheese. This is the pizza for you.. I have three other pizza places in my local area that taste exactly the same but this one seems to do it correctly.. this is the pizza that I will be buying in the Ohio valley region until I find one that is different..“

“Was an awesome place to visit“

“We walked in and was going to get pizza the owner was making pepperoni rolls was full of pepperoni and cheese. The batch he was making was the second batch for the day there were only there are only two left of the first batch and they were still warm. They were as good as they look when he was making them.“

“I like trays of pizza and they make them and they are delicious. I just got a calzone with some sausage and pepperoni, the bomb! And I love the fact that they deliver none of these other places do that I like, except the cardboard pizza places like Domino's, thank you Malta. That was a great meal and you know what I got enough to eat for a week. Thanks for feeding me and that sausage was great on that pepperoni calzone order the sausage it's great.“

“Have LOVED this since I was a kid! Love the crispy crust, the sauce, EVERYTHING about Nick's. The BEST pizza around!!“

“The pizza is really top notch with the over fire and very flavorful. I usually don't eat the crust but it was garnished with flavor and not a crumb was left. Mixed drinks were also pretty good and mixed just right. We also enjoyed having so much room in a large former bank building and got to see the vault.“

“My wife and I were visiting from out of state for brother in laws birthday and retirement celebration. Private dining area in the back of the restaurant was set up for a surprise party. The room was nice for the large number of guest.All the food was very good from the salad to the pasta, meatballs and fried chicken.The entire staff was super freindly and attentive for the entire party throughout the evening. Definitely a do-over when in the area.“

“Theo Yanni's has a very wide selection to choose from on the menu, ranging from steaks & fish, to Gyros and other Greek style dishes. I ended up ordering the Firecracker Fish Sandwich, which is perfectly spicy and generously sized. This was my 2nd trip to Theo Yanni's, and the service was adequate both times-- nothing super memorable or notable, but drinks were refilled on time and wait staff is fairly friendly. It was busy this recent time, so it did get a bit loud, but we were still able to talk and hear each other pretty well. All in all, it's a great choice and it's worth repeating visits to explore the menu.“

“Wonderful calzones!! Recommend the buffalo calzone“

“Wow didn't expect such good food from a pizza shop. Marinara is on the sweet side. But it's so good!! It's just like a homemade Italian restaurant not just a pizza place. Richest french onion soup ever. Big portions. Quiet atmosphere“

“Enjoyed the supreme pizza and it was amazing. However the veggies are prepared for the pizza topping were so flavorful. The mushrooms were absolutely delicious. The staff was very busy and had a good sense of humor. We also had a plan Jane and pepperoni and sausage pizza. We will be back soon!“

“When I call in my order I'm always greeted by friendly staff. The food tastes amazing every time and sooo filling! I order several nights a week. It's a great choice for dinner whatever you're craving. They have really good pizza and wings too!“

“It’s a pizza shop! Call ahead and make your order, so it’s waiting for you. If you order when you get there, you’re gonna wait because, it’s so good everybody goes there. The pizza is delicious! It’s crunchy, chewy and spicy. Great pizza! you have to pay by the, slice.“

“Really Great pizza, my new fav.“

“Excellent pizza!! Dough is fresh, sauce delicious and the perfect amount of toppings were added. So glad we found you, what a hidden gem.“

“I’ve been searching for a restaurant in the surrounding area, stupid Ville, Ohio, and Toronto, Ohio. I found this restaurant, and let me tell you, their hoagie is the best I’ve ever had in Ohio. I had to drive to Pittsburgh, as I’m from South Park Suburbs of Pittsburgh, and that’s the only area that I can have found good Italian hoagies. Now Paul’s Pizza is my go to place from now on. Friendly and great food. I highly recommend this Pizza joint for your enjoyment! Five Stars.“

“Best $5 bucks spent on pizza EVER!! Amazing bargain! I know you're wondering why the cheese isn't melted, but you'll have to trust the pizza magic that is the lightest, crispiest crust you'll ever enjoy! The sauce is bright, and the cheese has a mellow yet flavorful impact on the square slices... in a side note, we had superb service! Our counter employee went above and beyond!! (Our 4 slices were so delicious we ordered a sheet to take home!!!) We're two hours away, but we'll make excuses to come back for this pizza!!“

“Romas Pizza in Chester, WV is hands down the best pizza on the East Coast. Most places go with square slices and try to imitate DiCarlos style of pizza. Their classic round pizza is just how I like it and there's something about their pizza sauce and pizza dough that separates them from everyone else . Their wings are amazing as well.. if you haven't checked them out I definitely suggest doing so. You won't be disappointed.“

“Excellent pizza very friendly staff“

“2 visits - pizza 5 stars - italian hoagies 3 stars AT BEST - house italian dressing 5 stars - salads 4 stars - good serviceParking: it's not street parking but you're close to where you must be careful - either back into your space off the street or you'll be backing onto the when leaving“