37 Best Pizza Restaurants near New Cumberland

“Don't tell anyone because I don't want to get anyone in trouble in case they weren't allowed because they really didn't know if they'd get in trouble but they heated up our wings we brought. It was really late & I had seen the safe last time we stayed mistaking it for a microwave, I'm an old lady so don't laugh. Anyway, they were really nice to heat them for us.“

“THE BEST CALZONES EVER AND FRIENDLY SERVICE.“

“Their food is fantastic!! love the daily deals and the prices are reasonable!!“

“Since the fall of Gianomores, Dicarlos is the best left in town. My only complaint is they don't have soda pop anymore to sell we walked across the street for some which is fine but heck anyone who's anyone eats Ohio valley style pizza right there in the parking lot it's how it's meant to be eaten.“

“Wonderful calzones!! Recommend the buffalo calzone“

“another GREAT pizza! best in the valley, if you ask me. thank you!“

“Absolutely love Paul's pizza and hoagies! I've had the Italian and the buffalo chicken hoagies and they were both great! Also had the 12" round pizza and man ohh man was it great! Keep making all the delicious food Paul!“

“Amazing tonight yes!!! 🍕 🍕 🍕“

“The pizza was exactly what I was looking for the classic Ohio valley style! Square cuts on a crunchy but airy crust and finished with fixins’. The staff were very friendly and getting bombarded with calls, so be patient. It’s worth the wait.“

“Their new hoagie pizza is SO GOOD 10/10😩😍“

“I’ve been here a few times over the last couple years and have always had a fantastic experience! The entire staff is friendly and the food is great! Definitely recommend and will be back!“

“Gianni's staff are fantastic! Their pizza is addictive and I love the prices. I hope they add more items to the menu“

“Just walked in, while looking at the nutcracker displays. Had a top notch calzone, wife had a meatball sub, it was huge. Food tasted great, tried Italian lemon soda pop. Price was very reasonable. If you are in area, it’s worth the visit.“

“Fast delivery, best pizza place around !“

“Best around!“

“Best pizza in WV.. I always get the reg with pepperoni“

“Tried Brunos for the first time, ordered two trays for a birthday party and it was sooo good! Sauce is tasty, added extra cheese and they put the right amount on, which wasn't skimpy! I definitely recommend and will be back to order again soon!“

“I've ordered here a few times for lunch and I have to say the make really good pizza and calzones. Friendly people and good service. I highly recommend this place.“

“Always great food and service“

“Always great food and the staff is super friendly“

“A Really great peaceful place and a friendly style and lots of great fun“

“Excellent! Perfect as always!“

“Absolutely delicious food. The chef is incredible. We’ve had appetizers, pizza, and entrees - all absolutely delicious, zero complaints. This place is a gem in our area. Waiters are so friendly and chill (while clearly working hard - please be patient!) I’d be here weekly if we lived closer!“

“Had heard very good things about Bella C's Pizza, so decided to go there tonite. Sadly to discover that they're only open on Friday and Saturday nights.“

“We reached out to Angel a week before a business luncheon and asked for her assistance. While they are an Italian restaurant we wanted to make sure we had a mixture of vegetarian and low carb options. Wow! It was so impressive. They had the most gorgeous salad, fresh fruit and vegetables, sandwiches, a ginormous charcuterie spread, buffalo dip, chicken skewers and so much more. The presentation was fabulous too. They obviously take pride in their work and it showed because the set up looked like an artist’s palette of delicious food. I highly recommend Belmonte’s for catering.“

“Belmonte's catered a big event for us yesterday in the Millsop Community Center. The food was wonderful, the presentation was fabulous, and they did what they promised, on time and despite the giant piles of snow and the intense cold. Well done! Everyone loved it. THANK YOU“

“we got taco pizza and spinach pizza delivered..it was sooo hot and amazing! Great job Defelice!“

“I had almost given up on Brunos until this week when I tried the Chester Brunos. It's what Calcutta Brunos used to be. Great pizza.“

“I don't live in ELO anymore, but I try to stop at Bosco's when I'm in town. Sat Nov 9th, 2024 I stopped & had the best pizza I've had in a long time. I bought a tray & was so glad I did. I ate way more than I should have. Since I knew it would be a while before I'd have a chance to stop again. Thank you Bosco's Pizza!!“

“The food we had was good. Menu is a little disappointing. Visited on Sunday and Calzone is only available Monday through Thursday. Would also rather know the red sauce pizza is made to order with desired toppings rather than by-the-slice.“

“BEST pizza and calzones in town! The marinara is amazing, my favorite is the Spicy Italian calzone. They have the best service, friendly employees and hands down best food in town! Highly Recommended ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“Hostess explained that the restaurant just re opened uo to the public. The restaurant is clean and inviting. The employees are so nice. One stated locals haven't really been taking advantage of the re opening yet but in my opinion they are missing out! If we weren't just passing through I'm sure we would be back.“

“Is Ohio Valley Pizza Company also deCarlo’s Pizza or did somebody else buy DiCarlo? I grew up in Newell, West Virginia. My mother and father are both back there. My father is a trainer at the race track and my mother was a jockey for 35yrs. When I go back east this is my favorite place to get pizza. I love that it’s cut in squares. There’s just something about it that reminds me of home. The taste is like no other. Maybe it’s just because it reminds me of Home. Every time I visit from California, I always go to the hotdog shop over the Ohio Bridge and I go to DiCarlo’s‘s Pizza.“

“I just ordered pizza there for the first time for delivery this afternoon. The service was friendly and professional. The person delivering the pizza was friendly. Most importantly the pizza was excellent. Would definitely order again and maybe try some other items from the menu. Great job!“

“I love my domino's this is the place if you want pizza , pasta , oven baked sandwiches“

“Got the Spicy Lover's Pizza today and whoever cut it clearly does not have the slightest clue what they are doing! I mean seriously, who cuts a pizza like this? Is there a competition between employees on who can cut it the worst? How is it even to be shared?“

“Shout out to this Domino’s Pizza for helping our classroom get their pizza party on short notice today. In just a little over an hour, we had 18+ pizzas delivered at a great price. Thank you so much!“