13 Best Italian Restaurants near Star City

“This is a hidden gem that more people need to be aware of. It is so delicious and so friendly! We can not wait for our next visit!“

“I live in Washington, DC, where Michelin-starred restaurants surround me, but nothing compares to my love for Stefano’s! The atmosphere is unmatched, the staff is incredibly friendly, and the food is outstanding. Their Chilean sea bass, prime NY strip, escargot, and amazing meatballs are impeccable. Plus, they serve the freshest, piping hot bread in West Virginia. I always order the carrot cake for dessert (moist, flavorful & pleasing). Stefano's truly has it all!“

“Always excellent service, but on my visit this evening Phil went above and beyond. Fantastic cauliflower crust pizza, amazing river views from the patio. I love the many skylights dining room during a good storm. One of my favorite spots to treat myself.“

“FANTASTIC! Food was delicious, service was wonderful. Thank you!“

“Typical chain restaurant quality. It was busy since it was right before Christmas I suppose but there was no wait to be seated. It was what you expect from Olive Garden. Food was served warm. No complaints. Server was absolutely adorable and attentive. Service really makes a difference in chain food places like this.“

“wonderful place to play.. Great staff, Great food, Wonderful atmosphere“

“Very good food and awesome service!“

“What a treat to have lunch at Colasante’s. The service was excellent and the Italian Sub was amazing! An extra treat to try the dill pickle pizza, which made me want more! A true local gem with excellent food! Support local, you won’t be disappointed!“

“This restaurant has a fun and friendly atmosphere with tvs, a mural wall and neon signs. There are huge windows and lots of seating. It’s not fancy but the food is good and is a great place for groups of friends to meet or watch sports. The staff were smiling and friendly.“

“it was my first time irdering and it was the best food i have ever ate, the sandwiches are extremely big and full of meat and vegs and cheese, great place to dine in or order out“

“Casa is a staple of Morgantown eatery, whether it’s this location or downtown. Their pizza always leaves me cheesin

Edit: Their pizza is good, slightly greasy but the crust has a nice crunch, the sauce isn’t overpowering and the cheese is nice and flavorful.“

“We had a lovely event that included, a delicious buffet, and optional cocktails. The staff was accommodating and the food was better than I expected.“

“Got in to town later than I wanted. Once I got myself situated I needed something to eat and they were open when I went there at 11:30pm. Mountaineer zone was delish and zoni rolls were huge! Definitely a good place for late night eats!“