11 Best Pizza Restaurants in Vestavia Hills

“I have celiac disease and lactose intolerance and seriously cannot recommend this place enough. The staff is very knowledgeable about cross contact. They even have a separate oven for gluten free pizzas! Every pizza on the menu could be made gluten/dairy free. Thank you for such a wonderful experience. I will be coming here regularly!“

“It was alright. Ingredients were fresh and delicious, and the topping quantities were excellent. Sauce was good. Service was even good!

My only qualm was the crust. It appeared to either be over proofed or overstretched and then trimmed.

I will try again, and if it was just a rough day, then I’ll amend this review for later.“

“Slice is by far the best pizza I’ve ever had anywhere! I’ve had pizza in New York, Chicago and anywhere known for good pizza. Nothing else comes close! When I’m around Birmingham I always try to make time to go to one of their locations. Today I went to the one in Vestavia. The pizza was great and so was the service.“

“Went for lunch, got the hot shot pizza, a meatball stromboli, and tiramisu. The portion sizes were huge, the food was loaded with meat and everything absolutely delicious! One of the best textured and flavored pizza crusts I’ve ever had. The tiramisu was fabulous.
I’d absolutely recommend trying them out! I know I’ll be coming back.“

“Great pizza, awesome staff. Family owned for 60+ years.“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“We had a birthday party today for my 4-year-old, and it was absolutely amazing. The staff was friendly, informative, and incredibly helpful—every single one of them greeted us with smiles and made the experience truly enjoyable. Everyone went above and beyond to make the day special. We will definitely be back to this location. Mariah, the manager, was absolutely amazing and helped make everything run smoothly.“

“Friendly service and great food! I was looking for a good restaurant for pizza and found it! We will definitely be back!“

“Pizza is pretty good overall in flavors, but no idea what style pizza we will get. Is it a thin crust, hand tossed, mixed thickness? Who knows until you get it.
Same goes for the slices. Two huge pieces, a couple that might be slices and some in between. Definitely not your regular pie division of six to eight equal slices. Like ever! Never have I... Had regular sliced pizza from this Domino's.
The staff is great and the pizza is usually done quickly.
I do wish Domino's would add a more zesty or spicy marinara.“

“Jonathan made my large supreme pizza today and it was the BEST pizza ever. Even better than other PaPa John locations. They were nice too according to Cory. He picked it up for me. Made my day.“

“Wes and got out of the house today and grabbed lunch at Newks at the Vestavia location. Y’all, it was delicious! My mom has long been a fan and suggested I eat there. I’m sorry it took me so long. We did curbside service and got the black & blue salad and the five cheese pesto pizza. Of course we had to sample a side of their five cheese Mac and cheese. Everything was excellent!!!! Definitely grab and go/curbside at Newks. Let them take care of supper tonight.“