50 Best Italian Restaurants near Youngtown

1 Father Sarducci's Pizza, Pasta & More

4.1 Good 156 Reviews

11127 West Arizona Avenue, Youngtown

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I have lost track of how many times we have been here since it opened. We have eaten the pizza, meatball appetizer with garlic bread, fish and chips, Caesar salad, garlic knots with marinara, plus a couple of the sandwiches. Everything has been delicious. Love this place.”

2 The Sicilian Butcher

4.6 Superb 1,219 Reviews

9780 West Northern Avenue Ste 1100, Peoria · 3.46 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The food was amazing. I was taken aback by a $15 price tag for the garlic bread, but it was worth the price. Our table was still talking about it even after the rest of the amazing food. The entree prices were very reasonable, most of them $21-$29 each. I ordered the baked canneloni and it was so good. Someone ordered a pizza and loved it, too. I know it's conceited to say--but many times I eat at a restaurant thinking my own cooking is just as good. Not at The Sicilian Butcher--I couldn't begin to replicate the delicious food we ate.”

3 Twisted Italian

4.7 Superb 458 Reviews

9940 West Happy Valley Parkway Suite 1080, Peoria · 8.32 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We just moved out to the area and the name caught us. The take out was quick. Zero hassles. Food was incredible. Will be a staple when we eat out. It was incredible. Chicken Masala was very good, although it had more of a sweet base than tasting the wine. Chicken Parm was great. Spaghetti and meatballs were very good. My daughter even loved the chicken tenders. Fries were VERY good. Bread was amazingly fresh. HIGH PRAISE TWISTED ITALIAN.”

4 Dolce Vino Wine Bar

4.6 Superb 277 Reviews

4935 West Glendale Avenue Suite 8, Glendale · 8.76 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Like I told Ernesto today. It was a Complete pleasure eating at this establishment!”

5 Times Square Neighborhood Italian Restaurant

4.5 Superb 413 Reviews

5775 West Bell Road Suite 15, Glendale · 7.48 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The food is delish and fresh. Friendly staff and quick service.”

6 Buca di Beppo Italian Restaurant

4.4 Superb 1,233 Reviews

16091 North Arrowhead Fountains Center Drive, Peoria · 4.64 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We went to eat there last Saturday. Very good food, nice environment, friendly peoples and our server, Laura, over the top!!! Five stars!!. I can't wait to go again!!!”

7 Dazzo's Dog House

4.5 Superb 301 Reviews

6143 West Glendale Avenue, Glendale · 7.42 miles

• Take-Out
• Drive-Through

“A quarter pounder hamburger $36.50 that can't be right must be a misprint for one hamburger and 1950 for a hamburger that's got to be another misprint”

8 Fabio On Fire | Pizzeria Italiana

4.4 Superb 448 Reviews

8275 West Lake Pleasant Parkway Suite 101, Peoria · 6.39 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Our first visit...won't be our last, for sure! The best mussels this side of the Mississippi!!! Amazing, authentic bolognese...and the texture of the pasta, WOW!! Our waitress, Courtney, was outstanding...from carefully explaining specials to the attention she gave our party of 6 throughout dinner!💜”

9 Fabio On Fire | Panini & Gelateria

4.5 Superb 163 Reviews

24775 North Lake Pleasant Parkway, Peoria · 8.12 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Our first visit...won't be our last, for sure! The best mussels this side of the Mississippi!!! Amazing, authentic bolognese...and the texture of the pasta, WOW!! Our waitress, Courtney, was outstanding...from carefully explaining specials to the attention she gave our party of 6 throughout dinner!💜”

10 Roma23

4.4 Superb 274 Reviews

9118 West Van Buren Street, Tolleson · 10.26 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery
• Drive-Through

“Food was alright. The chicken for the Chicken Parmesan was a little too overcooked for me, and I had allergic reaction to something that was in the Penna sauce, but I love the Espresso Martini 🍸 Service it's self was a little lacking. I will definitely try it again to experience it fully instead of having to leave early because I'm having an allergic reaction to the food.”

11 Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

4.3 Superb 589 Reviews

15411 West McDowell Road, Goodyear · 10.29 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Went there October 25 and I had a issue with our order where our kids food was not given to them but the manager and server both handled it well and server came and apologized and took responsibility for the mistake will definitely be going back !”

12 Pizzicata Glendale

4.4 Superb 178 Reviews

19420 North 59th Avenue, Glendale · 8.14 miles

• Delivery

“Create a little time. Place has a unique octopus dish. Grilled octopus was excellent. Soft and succulent, very surprising, quite unlike. Squid, which can be rubbery. This wasn't rubbery at all, had a very good texture. Maybe Akin to a swordfish or even alligator tail only softer.”

13 Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

4.3 Superb 495 Reviews

6970 North 95th Avenue, Glendale · 4.52 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“My husband & I have been to Olive Garden Glendale many times in the past and always enjoyed the food, the ambiance, and the employees. This time we came to celebrate our 23rd anniversary and we were greeted by our server, Kiah. Best server ever! She was so attentive, very friendly, very professional, and really added to our experience. We laughed together - but she was also respectful of our celebration, and gave my husband & I space to enjoy the food and each other. Next time we come, we will certainly ask to be seated in her area. At the end of our meal, DJ, the General Manager, came by our table to make sure that we enjoyed the food. We sure did - but we also raved about Kiah. DJ was wonderful!, very friendly and appreciative. Thank you Kiah and DJ - you made us feel like royalty. Highly recommend Olive Garden Glendale. When you arrive, ask for Kiah! She will make certain that your experience is awesome.”

14 Lou's Tivoli Gardens

4.3 Superb 418 Reviews

12555 West Bell Road, Surprise · 3.45 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I go to your restaurant quiet frequently. Yesterday and again today, our server was Tree. She was and is always a delightful wait person. She goes out of her way to make certain that our requests are met. In addition, she is friendly and always knows our names.”

15 Cucina Tagliani Pasta, Pizza & Vino

4.3 Superb 297 Reviews

17045 North 59th Avenue Suite 101, Glendale · 7.45 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Assolutamente fantastico!! Never has there been an Italian restaurant that offered so many wonderful choices for just about any diet. Are you kidding me? Zoodles? Spaghetti Squash? This is also one of the few places left that still have angel hair pasta and they use deliciously perfect Roma tomatoes. No sugar added tomato sauce AND everything made in-house? Wow...that's about all I can say about this wonderful gem in the desert. Everything had taste bud pleasing flavor, portion sizes are perfect and at a very decent price. Not to mention service was perfect, immediate and very accommodating. Whether this was a lucky night for us, or the usual for this wonderful place, they have new fans that will back for more. There is a ton of variety to the menu which requires more visits to experience. Don't pass this place up! The only suggestion is the artichoke leaves could be a little more tender using the baby leaves only, however, they are delicious and worth a try.”

16 La Bona Pasta

4.3 Superb 242 Reviews

13321 West Indian School Road, Litchfield Park · 7.69 miles

• Delivery

“tried it for the first time tonight, very nice staff with good recommendations. the good was great, will certainly be back to try more!”

17 Portofino West Ristorante

4.3 Superb 190 Reviews

12851 West Bell Road Suite 124, Surprise · 3.61 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Beautiful atmosphere. The food is absolutely AMAZING. The lady that took my pickup order over the phone was very nice & I can’t believe how happy my family is over our meals. We got spaghetti with salad, bread (which is my favorite by the way), meatballs(10/10), and French onion soup! My kids don’t even like onions - yet loved the soup! Seriously give this place a 10/10. Thank you for a wonderful meal with my family.”

18 Osteria Mia - Surprise

4.4 Superb 72 Reviews

16853 North 145th Avenue Ste 155, Surprise · 4.98 miles

“My wife Yolanda and I ate here last Friday and she wasn’t sure what to expect, but she was really happy once we got inside. It’s a very nice restaurant — roomy, nice atmosphere, and the wait staff was attentive and on point the whole time. The manager even checked in to make sure everyone was okay. We had the Brussels sprouts, El Capo pizza, Caesar salad, and lasagna alla bolognese — all really delicious. The prices weren’t expensive compared to places like Cooper’s Hawk or Luminati’s. Honestly this place is a lot better. We’ll be back.”

19 Into The Fire Pizza & Catering

5.0 Superb 16 Reviews

8275 W Lake Pleasant Pkwy #105, Peoria · 6.4 miles

“Wendy and her crew catered our wedding at the end of March and it was truly incredible! From the amazing appetizers they served during our cocktail hour, to the phenomenal pizza they served during dinner, we were blown away! Wendy responds so quickly and answered all of our questions! We loved getting to meet her before the wedding for a taste test and we were obsessed with her pizzas! We can’t wait to have it again! Can’t recommend Wendy enough! She’s awesome and her pizza is next level!”

20 Dino's Greek & Italian Grill

4.6 Superb 401 Reviews

1550 North Dysart Rd B-8, Goodyear · 9.27 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I LOVE Dino’s!! If you’re in the Goodyear / Avondale area you have to eat here! Delicious food ! Never a wait even during peak hours. Good pizza , wings , calzones. Athenian club - amazing meal for two! If you’re looking for a new restaurant to try or if you just haven’t been in a while; get in!! Support our lovely local small businesses!”

21 Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

4.2 Good 614 Reviews

7889 West Bell Road, Peoria · 5.27 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We had such a wonderful experience at Olive Garden, and Bre was a big part of making it so special! She was incredibly friendly, attentive, and made us feel so well taken care of from the moment we sat down. Our drinks were always full, she checked to make sure everything was good, and she genuinely went above and beyond to make sure we enjoyed our meal. You can tell Bre really cares about her customers and takes pride in what she does. She is truly an exceptional server, and we hope to have her again the next time we visit! Thank you, Bre, for making our dinner such a great experience! ❤”

22 Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

4.2 Good 556 Reviews

13379 West Grand Avenue, Surprise · 4.1 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Server was definitely new... but wasn't exactly bad in a rough way, just needs some attention to the dress code. While I was amused with our server he did frustrate me a bit. All in all its the best olive garden experience I've had for awhile.”

23 Oregano's

4.2 Good 427 Reviews

6738 West Bell Road, Glendale · 6.47 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“short waiting line, great service , super food variety & delicious food....💥”

24 Carrabba's Italian Grill

4.2 Good 365 Reviews

5646 West Bell Road, Glendale · 7.69 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“My wife and I went to this Carrabba's after not having been to one for several years. The food and service were excellent!!! We had the Calabrian Wings, Calamari, and the Buratta Mozarella and Tomato Caprese for appetizers. Our entrees were Beef Short Rib Marsala, and Shrimp and Scallops ala Vodka, with sides of Sausage and Lentil soup, and a Caesar salad. Desert was Tiramisu and an Espresso Martini. Everything was fresh and delicious!!!”

25 Times Square Litchfield Park

4.2 Good 364 Reviews

13760 West Camelback Road Suite 70, Litchfield Park · 6.58 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We had Times Square cater for my parents 70th bday celebration, for 55 people. from inquiring info, placing order, and pick up was flawless. and the food was a hit, DELICIOUS!! Thank you Time Square and staff for a great flawless experience!!”

26 Little Sicily Pizza

4.6 Superb 262 Reviews

18795 North Reems Road, Surprise · 5.89 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Awesome job on the meatball sandwich! Great, friendly fast service!”

27 Paulie's Little Bite of Italy

4.1 Good 342 Reviews

15456 North 99th Avenue, Sun City · 2.74 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Paulie’s is amazing the food, family, and fun! I will say the front desk hostess area is confusing and disorganized. My brother and mother love the food!”

28 Babbo Italian Eatery

4.1 Good 409 Reviews

20211 North 67th Ave B3, Glendale · 7.89 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Their salads are to die for! Love their food!”

29 Picazzo's Healthy Italian Kitchen

4.5 Superb 358 Reviews

8280 West Union Hills Drive, Glendale · 5.62 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Professional, clean and good tasting food. Great for a quick lunch or nice dinner, definitely recommend.”

30 Lucky's Pizza

4.6 Superb 217 Reviews

6630 West Cactus Rd b108, Glendale · 5.88 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Great option in the Central Valley! Just moved to Glendale from N Phoenix and wanted a closer option. This definitely hit the spot! Quick delivery via third party delivery service and the pizza was awesome! Thanks Lucky’s!”

31 Bella Luna Ristorante

4.1 Good 496 Reviews

14175 West Indian School Rd A4, Goodyear · 8.34 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Great food & friendly service.”

32 North Italia

4.1 Good 544 Reviews

8163 West Paradise Lane, Peoria · 4.83 miles

“In the area for work and was recommended to come here from a client, I decided to come before the dinner rush (around 5pm) since I'm just a single seat. I was greeted and seated quickly, they had my choice bourbon from the bar, and I ordered the spicy rigatoni vodka, a half Ceaser salad, and the tiramisu. Food was honestly delicious. The salad was wonderful, nice and creamy with hints of anchovies and homemade croutons; however, I did find it odd that they would sprinkle parsley on this salad. The main dish, the spicy rigatoni vodka, was very tasty, perfect amount of spice, the pancetta was nice and crispy with solid chunks. A couple shortfalls: I felt it was a bit sparse on the sausage. I feel like bigger and more chunks of sausage would make this dish perfect. I would also prefer table side garnishing for my parmigiano, so I can control how much or how little I prefer. The tiramisu was delicous, I love that they put these crunchy little balls of chocolate on top. The shortfall here was that I feel it was too afraid of having that espresso taste. Overall I very much enjoyed my meal, my waitress was attentive and helpful. I think I'd definitely come back if I'm in the area again!”

33 Stevie's Pizza

4.6 Superb 189 Reviews

20210 North 59th Avenue Ste 102, Glendale · 8.46 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Fantastic pizza and awesome staff. Highly recommend.”

34 Papa Paul's Brick Oven Pizza & Pasta

4.4 Superb 396 Reviews

118 North Old Litchfield Road, Litchfield Park · 7.57 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Stayed at the Wigman and wanted a pizza. It was awesome! I would highly recommend”

35 Carrabba's Italian Grill

4.0 Good 373 Reviews

14043 West Bell Road, Surprise · 4.6 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Food is delicious! Service fast! Great server!”

36 Dominic's Bistro Italiano

4.4 Superb 259 Reviews

10001 West Bell Road, Sun City · 3.4 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Just celebrated my wife’s 80th Birthday. Great atmosphere, great food, friendly staff, Not the first time here, would have to consider myself a regular for sure. Dominick and his wife Debbi are very accommodating. By the end of the night we were friends with other customers. They all sang Happy Birthday to Marcia. And let’s not forget the singing and dancing. Could not have asked for a more memorable night”

37 Babbo Italian Eatery

3.9 Good 259 Reviews

15705 West McDowell Road, Goodyear · 10.46 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Babbos has become my favorite go to place for yummy food, great atmosphere, abundant parking and the most wonderful welcoming people welcoming you EVERY TIME. Ally has been my waiter who remembers what I order and how I like! How they remember with so many customers is because they genuinely care and it shows. I'm at Babbos on McDowell in Goodyear, AZ! The best! Come and see!”

38 Oregano's

4.3 Superb 464 Reviews

15280 West McDowell Road, Goodyear · 10.17 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Great service! David was our server and he was fabulous! Thanks!!!!👍”

39 Richi's Diner

4.3 Superb 441 Reviews

15609 West Bell Road Suite 100, Surprise · 5.67 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We go to Rich'i every Monday morning for breakfast...have for years. We love the food, their service is excellent, and atmosphere is 100% comfortable. Suzi, our server, is particularly delightful.”

40 Rosati’s Pizza

4.3 Superb 394 Reviews

13856 West Waddell Road Suite 104, Surprise · 3.38 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Disappointed that at 6 o’clock on a Friday night you were already out of meat sauce. Don’t understand how a restaurant which offers different pasta dishes can run out of sauce. Mostaccioli just wasn’t the same with marinara and 2 small meatballs. Deep dish was “ok””

41 NY Pizza Department

4.3 Superb 292 Reviews

7650 West Bell Road, Glendale · 5.52 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“This is not commentary on the food itself, but an issue that customers need to be aware of when ordering delivery. Many restaurants are doing this, and this is yet another...do NOT try to tip the delivery driver through them. They subcontract the services of people like Door Dash, and when a tip is added to the order the delivery driver will never see a dime. The restaurant KEEPS those tips. I always tip in cash myself, because multiple restaurant chains are doing this to drivers that end up making as low as $2.50 in TOTAL for bringing even a large entire catering order to someone. This exact scenario occurred with an order from this location.”

42 Barro's Pizza

4.3 Superb 287 Reviews

9140 West Glendale Avenue Suite 100, Glendale · 4.66 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“They served my husband and I are food and it was about another 30 minutes before we got our granddaughter's Pizza and of course she was irritable for a 3-year-old not to be able to eat and she didn't want anything else but her pizza that she picked out so it was not a good experience”

43 NY Pizza Department

4.3 Superb 284 Reviews

1619 North Dysart Road Suite 103, Avondale · 9.12 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Food and service was on point, the gentleman help us was very helpful and polite. Pizza and garlic cheese bread was delicious. 😋😋😋”

44 Brother's Pizza

4.3 Superb 265 Reviews

10720 West Indian School Road Ste 13, Phoenix · 6.85 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Brothers Pizza has been a favorite in our family for years, and there’s a reason we keep coming back! My brother has even ordered well over 100 pizzas from them for a family wedding, and they handled it wonderfully. This time there were five of us, and everything was fantastic. We ordered a large pizza split half cheese and half deluxe so everyone could have exactly what they wanted. The pizza was HUGE, hot, fresh, and absolutely delicious. We also had salads, which were fresh and really good, and the wings were incredible. Honestly, some of the best wings I’ve had in a very long time! I wish I had pictures to share, but we were apparently far too hungry because we completely demolished everything before I even thought about taking any. 😂 That probably says more about the food than a picture could anyway! The atmosphere is also great. There is plenty of seating, including large tables and benches that make it especially convenient for families, groups of friends, sports teams, celebrations, or anyone trying to feed a larger group. Great food, generous portions, comfortable atmosphere, and a place our family has enjoyed for years. If you’re hungry for really good pizza and wings, Brothers Pizza is absolutely worth the stop! 🍕❤️ ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐”

45 Vinnys Italian Sports Grill

4.3 Superb 209 Reviews

8267 West Lake Pleasant Parkway, Peoria · 6.37 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“great waitress, food and neighborhood atmosphere”

46 Carrabba's Italian Grill

3.9 Good 472 Reviews

9920 West McDowell Road, Avondale · 9.05 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Delicioso ❤️❤️❤️ Excelente atención”

47 Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

3.9 Good 484 Reviews

2626 North 75th Avenue, Phoenix · 9.3 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Shout out to Kim!! I’ve been served by her twice now and I have to say, probably one of the best servers I’ve ever had ANYWHERE. Most recently, I went yesterday and it was Sunday so they were busy! Regardless of that she was extremely attentive. Despite seeming like a small gesture it meant a lot; she remembered that my boyfriend likes water with no ice after each refill. On top of that I think she’s also the bartender so it’s just even more impressive of how attentive she was. Kitchen was a little slow that day but I didn’t mind too much! Honestly gave us time for the food to settle down after the first plate! All in all Kim was extremely professional, funny, and attentive. Thank you Kim!”

48 Barro's Pizza

4.2 Good 321 Reviews

16750 North 51st Avenue Suite 1, Glendale · 8.26 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Great team!! Excellent service”

49 Barro's Pizza

4.2 Good 292 Reviews

5135 North Dysart Road, Litchfield Park · 6.15 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Kenny and the other staff at this location are wonderful! I placed a large order and Kenny was super helpful in making sure I had the right amount of food and variety for the event. My order was ready exactly when they opened and everything was correct! Great job!”

50 CHAR Pizzeria Napoletana

4.2 Good 268 Reviews

25101 North Lake Pleasant Parkway Suite 1325, Peoria · 8.32 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Love this place! I take friends and family here when they come to town and want an amazing experience and great pizza 🙌”