13 Best Pizza Restaurants near Mill Bay

“Love the Mill Bay Panago! We have dietary restrictions and they've never made a mistake in all the years we've been going. We've ordered specialty pizza 5pm on a long weekend Friday night and it's still ready in 15-20min for pick-up! Delivery estimates are way longer though. Friendly staff and clean location. It's our go-to for pizza nights.“

“The pizza is AMAZING!!! It is absolutely the best pizza we have had in the last 20 years! Great job!!!!“

“Whatever you order, you can't go wrong. Our family go-to is the Garden Veggie, and their weekend specials are always interesting and delicious!“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Closest to dining in Italy as we can get for now haha 🇮🇹 So much love to this amazing restaurant and family, thank you for helping my lil family celebrate the best birthday ever. Grateful for this amazing place with amazing staff and comfort food, and the best fuzeball memories being made🔥“

“Moo’s pizza is the best in the Valley. Moo’s also supports multiple Community groups to help with their causes. There is no other Organization that offers exceptional pizza in our area. We also thank Moo’s for supporting our Legion’s CMS Food Bank fundraisers. We could not have raised so much needed funds without Moo’s support. Support Local!!!“

“Wow—what truly exceptional customer service from Timothy! We were blown away by the surprise of a delicious pizza, crafted with such care, love, and passion. It wasn’t just food; it was a gesture that made our day. Thank you from the bottom of our hearts, Domino's Pizza Duncan. You went above and beyond, and it didn’t go unnoticed. With dedicated, thoughtful leaders like Tim, your team is destined for great things. Keep shining, Domino's Pizza Duncan—you’ve earned every bit of this praise! 😊🍕 #VeggieLoversDelight#Ash :)“

“Great pizza, just wish I could order extra sauce a little dry. Tried to find it on the web order site seems it doesn’t exist, too bad!“

“I've eaten Peninsula Pizza and Keating many times. Those are good pizzas, especially Keating. But Villages is truly better. Every few months I go back to the other two, just thinking I may have been wrong, but every time I do, I'm reminded that Villages is better!“

“This pizza is amazing probably one of the best deep pan pizzas ive ever had! Seriously scrummy! Brilliantly done fries/chips and pizza extremely juicy and satisfying! and the crew working were very efficient and friendly. Will be returning! Definitely fills the spot 👌“

“The best pizza you can find on the island for sure, and trust me I’m not a bot saying this, I’m a real human with real emotions and the pizzas from this heavenly place has made me real emotional. The owner also saved me from an active volcano once and I owe him my life. I also met my soulmate when I bought my first pizza and also won the lottery. It’s just that good, try it. Trust me your life won’t be the same afterwards. Their crust is also so so good that even with my gluten allergy I can’t stop eating, even here in the after life, where I’m writing this majestic review.“

“What makes a good pizza joint? So much more than pizza. Energy. Good vibes. Community. And a desire to make the world a better place. THANK YOU Ali baba pizza Duncan for making our day 🙏🙏🙏 we will be back!!!“

“Fast delivery of hot pizza. Super friendly delivery driver. Hanover, ON“

“Had a great evening at this locally owned restaurant. Got to meet one of the co-owners and she shared her inspirational story. My sister and I used to frequent Romeo’s in Victoria on Blanchard back in the early 90’s. had the fettuccine chicken Alfredo and it was absolutely amazing. Big portion so we took home leftovers and enjoyed them 4 hrs later and it tasted even more amazing!! Love that this is an indigenous owned business.“