23 Best Pizza Restaurants near Arcata

“Its not a place you go to eat. The pizza is absolutely fire though. Reasonable wait time for a great pizza thats well cooked and delicious. Happy to say not disappointed. Cookies were good too! Add for chocolate chips to your recipe! Lol just saying....eat here!“

“APD has probably the best pizza in the Arcata/Eureka area, but check your pizza. I come and get a pizza here probably twice a month. I always order the same thing, half just cheese, half pepperoni and jalapeño, and more than half the time it comes out half pepperoni, half jalapeño. Then I have to wait for them to remake it. Not sure why that happens so often. But great pizza. Just be sure to check it.“

“🔥🔥bomb pizza & bomb donuts recommend 💯“

“Paul’s Live From New York Pizza serves some truly incredible pizza. The crust has that classic New York-style bite, the toppings are fresh, and every slice is packed with flavor. It’s definitely the reason to come here.

The staff was friendly and welcoming, making for a pleasant dining experience. The atmosphere, however, is just so-so—it’s functional but not somewhere you’d linger for the ambiance.

If you’re looking for outstanding pizza and great service, this place is absolutely worth a visit. The food easily earns 5 stars!“

“Great food.. Hoopa come on out and eat pizza and boneless chicken wings“

“I had an issue with paying for my order American Express which they did not take. This was a company credit card and I had no other way to pay. Your staff was nice enough to give me my order anyways so I had something to eat that night. I very much appreciate what they did to make it right. Your staff are very good people and deserve a great review. Thank you.“

“Hands down the best pizza in the county. The owners and staff are wonderful. Not only the best pizza but try there sandwiches. The meatball sandwich is my favorite and there pesto raviolis my favorite pasta. They also support/sponsor local sports and our community. Thanks, Babes D.Wheeler“

“Please do yourself a flavor and go here 😋 This place needs to be talked about more!! The eureka location was sooo good, I only wish I tried it sooner! They have regular pizza too for your normie-doesn’t like new things friend. But the Indian pizzas are top teir creative and flavorful. The crust is really good, people are really nice and accommodating. They have a good little game section for the kids too.“

“MOD Pizza is my absolute go-to for a fast, reliable takeout night.
Tucked right into the Broadway plaza, it is completely optimized for running in, grabbing your food, and hitting the road without any hassle.
The Takeout Experience Zero Waiting: If you order on the app, your pizza goes straight to the designated pickup shelf by the door. You can walk in, grab your box, and walk out in 20 seconds flat.
Actually Stays Crisp: They use vented boxes, so your pizza doesn't sweat and turn into a soggy mess on the drive home.
Fast and Precise: The app's timer is incredibly accurate. Food is almost always ready in exactly 10 to 15 minutes.
Easy Parking: The massive shared lot makes it seamless to park right up front, grab your food, and easily jump back onto Broadway.“

“I manage a pizza place in New York and this is the closest thing I found in California to actual New York Pizza and of course the owners are from New Jersey, thin crust. Sweet sauce, light cheese... They knew what a garlic knot is. Pinwheels calzones... This is a New York pizza place. In Northern California.“

“Very good service and the pizza is still as good as when I was a manager at this store 29 years ago, great job Round Table Pizza!��“

“So glad we tried this local pizza place while visiting Eureka. We accidentally picked up the wrong order but they were super cool about it and let us just keep the other pizzas without having to go back. Although we didn’t get what we ordered, let me tell you, this pizza is SO GOOD. The dough was amazing, quality cheese and toppings, and HUGE 16” pies! I wish I could take this place back home with me.“

“Overall, everything was really good. Service has been getting better and food is consistently good. Ordering by app works well and orders are usually on time. The only complaint I have is the cost seems high for take and bake; close to same price as cooked pizza. We can only afford it with a 30% off coupon.“

“If you're looking for a pizza experience that truly stands out, *Mountain Mike's Pizza* is the place to be. The moment you walk in, the welcoming atmosphere and the mouthwatering aroma of fresh-baked pizza instantly grab your attention. Known for their legendary Mountain-sized pizzas, piled high with premium toppings and perfectly cooked to a golden, crispy finish, it's no wonder this place has become a local favorite. The dough is always just right—chewy with a slight crunch—and the variety of toppings ensures there's something for everyone. Whether you're in the mood for a classic pepperoni or something more adventurous, Mountain Mike's delivers with every slice. And don't miss their Garlic Sticks and robust salad bar, which perfectly round out the meal. The staff is friendly, service is quick, and the experience is always satisfying. Whether you're dining in, taking out, or having it delivered, Mountain Mike's Pizza in Eureka is a must-try for any pizza lover.

Vegetarian options: vegetarians will find plenty of delicious options to satisfy their cravings. Their signature Veggie Pizza is a standout, loaded with fresh toppings like mushrooms, bell peppers, onions, olives, and ripe tomatoes on a bed of perfectly melted cheese. For something different, try the Garlic Sticks with cheese—crispy, garlicky, and downright addictive. You can also build your own pizza, choosing from a variety of fresh vegetables and cheese options to create the perfect pie tailored to your taste.

Dietary restrictions: They offer a range of options for those with dietary restrictions. For vegetarians, their Veggie Pizza and customizable options allow for a delicious, meat-free meal. They also provide gluten-free crusts for those with gluten sensitivities, ensuring that everyone can enjoy their pizza experience. If you’re looking to cut back on carbs, you can opt for a crustless pizza bowl, which offers all the delicious toppings without the crust. With these choices, Mountain Mike’s caters to various dietary needs while maintaining their commitment to great taste.

Parking: with plenty of space available for customers. Whether you're dining in, picking up an order, or just stopping by for a quick takeout, you won’t have to worry about finding a spot. The ample parking makes it easy to enjoy your meal without any hassle.

Kid-friendliness: definitely kid-friendly and features an arcade area. It’s a great spot for families, offering a fun environment where kids can enjoy playing games while waiting for their pizza. The arcade adds an extra layer of entertainment, making it a perfect choice for family outings or birthday parties. So, you can enjoy a delicious meal while the kids have a blast with the games!

Wheelchair accessibility: fully accessible for guests with wheelchairs. The restaurant is thoughtfully designed to ensure that everyone, regardless of mobility needs, can easily enter and enjoy their meal in a comfortable setting.“

“Walked in at 7:05pm and was greeted with a smile. 2 adults and one 5 year old wild child. Our waiter was amazingly kind and attentive. The atmosphere was calm and happy. It was our first time eating there and the food was phenomenal from our burgers to my son's kid pizza....which was giant and flavorful! We had a really good experience and the cost was perfect for the amount of food received. We will be coming back again.“

“The pizza was ready to be picked up and the staff is friendly. We never had ordered a stuffed pizza before, we wanted to try something different. The price and quality of the pizza was great! It would be good to take for a party! We grilled our pizza!“

“A magical, relaxed environment. The wine is superb and the food tantalizing. A lovely afternoon outing in bucolic Humboldt.“

“We love the pizza at this Smug's location. This place has the nicest staff, the best pizza crust and toppings, and pretty good deals. Even stopping in for a quick slice is the way to go. The Spicy Luau pizza is our favorite with the jalapeño and pineapple toppings. Enough spiciness that hits the spot!
We have eaten at the other locations, but the Mckinleyville location is by far the best.“

“Pizzas were made perfectly delicious. Definitely recommend this spot.“

“fast service...easy to read menu... 6 dollars a pizza ...“

“Great Crew. Great Buffet . We eat there 3-4 X’s a month“