31 Best Pizza Restaurants near Berthoud

“Best pizza and salads hands down! From the freshest of ingredients, to the best staff around… we love Berthoud Pizza Co! Your pizza is always made from scratch and made perfectly to your liking. Fantastic job, Always!“

“First time patrons and we thought the place was cozy. 🏠 Not for large groups, but perfect for 1-4 ppl grabbing some food and hanging out.

The food was delicious, I mean fantastic. Bite after bite was just pizza heaven. We ordered a supreme deluxe and all of the toppings looked and definitely tasted fresh. 🍕🍕🍕

The staff was kind and patient. They answered all our questions. This has that mom and pop feel to it that will bring us back time and again.

The location is easy to get to and their is parking on both sides of the street. They have bottle beverages in a fridge + tap water.

If you are looking for quality over the same old chain pizza restaurants, then give Brick Oven Pizza a chance. We think you will NOT be disappointed.

Go on, schedule a pizza night. It is Friday somewhere. Enjoy!“

“Manager is one of a kind. She really is exceptional. When busy and under pressure, she is the absolute best. Just absolute professionalism. #1: ask anyone that works there, they agree! Love it, you have my business, thank you for upholding a tough spot in a small town!“

“The pizza is excellent and the cheesy garlic bread is a must-try. The staff are friendly and attentive, which makes the whole experience easy and enjoyable. The dine-in area is relaxed and comfortable, so it’s a nice place to sit down for a meal instead of just grabbing takeout. Highly recommend!“

“Order a pizza from Arte Pizza this evening for my 30th anniversary. I asked if they could make it in the shape of a heart. They did a fabulous job!! Thank you for making this dinner memorable.“

“Excellent pizza and great service. We will definitely be back again.“

“I moved to Longmont in mid-July and have eaten here three times. The little mozzarella kisses and fresh ingredients send me into a tizzy every time. Yum yum yum!“

“I moved here from PA/NJ 17 years ago, this was the first time I've had pizza as good as or better than home! He killed it, lost for words here. The only pie in Colorado worth the price. The owner is awesome too 👍“

“Stopped in on our way through the area and grabbed a couple slices and some cheesy bread to go. Food came out quickly and was fresh and delicious! The slices were large and foldable NY-style with lots of gooey cheese and that cheesy bread was nothing but gooey cheese and wonderfully crispy outside/fluffy inside crust. Highly recommend this place and wish I had gotten to try more!“

“I have celiac and have a hard time finding really good GF pizza. My family and I got pizza to take home and I had to call to make sure they made it with GF dough because it was THAT GOOD! I’m so used to GF pizza tasting like card board but this place is AMAZING! My husband couldn’t even tell the difference! I HIGHLY HIGHLY RECOMMEND MAMA MEADS!❤️“

“Amazing food! Best Italian in loveland“

“Wonderful experience at MOD Pizza! Great service and food was amazing!!!“

“Best pizza EVER! Crust was amazing on the thin & crispy, done just the way I like it❤️“

“Great family vibe, amazing service, great cocktails and beer selection!!“

“Great pizza but insanely overpriced. There is no magic ingredient in pizza that should make it more expensive. Pizza of higher quality in the North shore of Boston (Faucis, Super Seven, Peter's) absolutely wipes the floor with Tony's, at less than half the price.“

“We were out of their delivery range, but they very kindly delivered pizza to us anyway, and it was amazing. Highly recommend the garlic knots.“

“The pizza is pretty good, but their website and online customer service is terrible. I've emailed them three times now to alert them that their ordering website is not working properly, and I have yet to hear back. Good luck if you're trying to order online.
Edit 10/2/25: updated service and overall to 4 stars. The website still has some significant issues. Contact is difficult.“

“delicious and big spicy veggie sandwiches. great macaroni salad too. the woman with the mowhawk was so nice and helpful! we will be back a lot this summer“

“Disappointed with this first time order. Pizza was just barely cooked through. Huge crust with very thin dough base. Hardly any sauce (dry) Toppings were so so. Not much flavor, probably due to lack of sauce and cheese. Sticker shock like always these days. Sticker shock is worse when prices go up and product is skimpy. It's like two price hikes.“

“Atmosphere rated low because this is not a restaurant. Take out only. Salads and sodas are ready to eat, however the lack of tables and chairs would make that a moot point.
The main thrust here is to sell you a pizza pie made from fresh-daily dough, with toppings that suit you. The pizzas are not cooked. You must bake the pizzas in your own oven. Certain combinations such as cheese or pepperoni are ready already to grab and go (especially during dinner hour)
I personally like the pizza because i l8ke their crust. Very middle ground, nothing avant-garde. The tomato sauce is medium-sweet. The toppings all seem top quality... The meats tasty. No soysage here.
Ever-changing high-schoolish staff. Ample free parking, wheelchair accessible entrance ( sidewalk ramp on the East side)
Get there before 9pm and the service is likely to be chipper and earnest.
Since the food is not served hot and ready to eat, you can use SNAP. (Food Stamps )
Recommended.
Maramao. Meow“

“Let me tell you. It was quite the experience. Although there were some mistakes done (the original delivery person got lost and they had to send out someone new) but it was still really pleasant lol it’s refreshing to see people keep their positive attitude even when mistakes happen. Will definitely be ordering again. Thank you for the laughs and the yummy food (and the free soda) (:“

“Real nice people and real nice pizzas. I'm very non-committal about most things. But this blackjack pizza location would be my bride if that sort of concept was available to Americans. Currently I will remain single just hoping and praying for the day.“

“Dudes were Awesome Ty!! That’s it“

“Came in on a Thursday night, Employees Caleb and Berlyn were super friendly and had phenomenal customer service! It was my first coming in and they were incredibly helpful and patient helping me choose the perfect pizza! Received it super fast, and the pizza was very tasty, 10/10 experience will be returning“

“They have a $5.00 large thin crust cheese, pepperoni or sausage on Fridays. This is a given for us every Friday. We cook it on a pizza stone on or grill. We add fresh shredded Vermont cheddar and thin sliced onions at home. Plenty to feed my wife and I.“

“The vibe and the staff are fun and welcoming. We visited on a chilly night so the vegan chili grabbed my attention immediately. It was thick, spicy and filling, exactly what I hoped it would be. The server told me there were other vegan options but I was already hooked. Updated from previous review on 2025-12-09“

“Huge shout out to Domino’s. Saturday night my niece got married. The catering was beyond messed up. Barely enough food for 20 people when there were over 100 in attendance. One call to Domino’s, and an explanation of the situation, and we had around 40 pizzas delivered and all at an amazing price. Thank you Domino’s, you guys saved the day!“

“Hoping the owners are planning on doing something about the ac unit that hasn't been working in there. Hoping they realize that their employees are not only having to wear masks but also enduring the heat of at least two open pizza ovens with hardly any ventilation. I ordered food tonight and as I stood in the front of the store (by the door) the heat was overwhelming. I can only imagine how the kitchen felt! Hearing this has been an issue for weeks now, makes me question where there priorities are at.. Do better.“

“Awesome food and great selection of beer“

“Hats off and a big thanks to Papa John's Pizza for Helping Longmont get the message out to complete your #2020Census Forms. If you have NOT, respond today online at www.2020census.gov. An accurate count means Longmont will get millions of dollars in federal funding every year for schools, hospitals, fire protection, emergency services, healthcare, and vital community assistance programs. Everyone Counts in Longmont!“

“we called to get 2 grinders on the deal of the week. The gal told us 50-60 minutes. My husband got there and it was over 90 minutes until he got the food. No apology, nothing. Then they forgot the Italian dressing. Nobody seems to care. Find a good management team and turn this ship around! I told him to leave and go to Noodles but he had already paid. They didn't hesitate to take his money right away.“