9 Best Sandwich Shops in Pueblo

“This place has been a local staple for years, and for good reason. If you’re craving a great Italian sausage sandwich, this is the spot. The flavor is always on point, the portions are generous, and the quality is incredibly consistent every time you stop in.

It’s clear this restaurant takes pride in what they do. Being locally owned and operated, you can feel the authenticity and care that goes into the food and the service. No matter how many times I’ve been here, the sandwiches always hit the mark—fresh, flavorful, and exactly what you’re hoping for.

If you live in the area or you’re just passing through, this place should absolutely be on your list of food options. A true local favorite that never disappoints. Highly recommend! 🍽️👏“

“Love Lucinda! And I got in trouble for eating the bottom of the cream puff:)“

“Food is good and people are usually friendly. But I have never been to the Pueblo Jersey Mike's and seen one clean table. I'm the only person in the store right now. And every single table is dirty.“

“Good food, the gut helping make the sandwiches was definitely new.

Parking: Free parking area not very big though maybe 4-5 parking spots

Kid-friendliness: Definitely kid friendly for the most part, has music playing in the lobby“

“So good 😊 soup and sandwiches. Love the bread still soft, but a little crispy the perfect bread.“

“We stopped in on our way back to Texas. Lauren took care of our order, and she couldn't have been nicer! Efficient, very pleasant, service with a smile and genuine. The grey haired lady assisted with our order towards the end as well, but I didn't catch her name. The customer service alone from these 2 ladies would bring me back here on our return trips back to Colorado. These ladies need to be recognized for their hospitality, which is still valued in our book.“

“Yes I went to the Walmart Subway on Northern and Pueblo boulevard. I ordered the tuna sandwich it was the worst sandwich I've ever had. I could barely find any tuna fish on the sandwich and barely any vegetables it was like eating an empty sandwich roll with mayonnaise“

“Guys, give a raise to the wonderful Payton!!! Today she made me the neatest, best-looking, and most importantly, the most delicious sandwich I’ve ever had — a true masterpiece in the world of sandwiches. Her communication was excellent — she asked and took into account all my preferences. I can say with full confidence that this was my best Subway experience ever, without any exaggeration. Thank you!!!!“

“Too funny. I always do funny names when ordering, but this time was the best. Props to the artist.“