11 Best Sandwich Shops in Pueblo

Browse menus, reviews and photos of Sandwich Shops in Pueblo.

Showing 11 of 15 restaurants

  • Pass Key Northern | Sandwiches • Burgers 3416 West Northern Avenue, Pueblo Italian · $

    1 Pass Key Northern | Sandwiches • Burgers

    4.3 Superb 206 Reviews

    3416 West Northern Avenue, Pueblo

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery
    • Drive-Through

    Customers’ favorites

    • Half Pass Key Special with Cheese and Fries
    • A Super and Fried with Pueblo Green Chilli
    • Parmesan Garlic Bread w Dipping Sauce
    • Super Sausage Sandwich & Fries

    “Pass keys it the heart of Pueblo. I heard for many years how great it was. Last year tried it the first time and man was it amazing. So amazing every time we leave the lake it’s a must have. 2 locations both great food. Last two weeks March 29th and April 4th 2025 we visited again. Thank you for serving great food and having great respect for your customers and the hospitality is on point. Till next time. Honestly once you’ve tried it you can’t even think on the place or you’ll be wanting it.”

  • Magpies 229 South Union Avenue, Pueblo Sandwich Shop · $

    2 Magpies

    4.5 Superb 92 Reviews

    229 South Union Avenue, Pueblo

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Garden Salad w House Vinaigrette Dressing Grilled Salmon
    • Salmon Salad Glazed with Honey Garlic Sauce
    • Quiche and Salad Served on Wednesdays
    • Scream Cheeseburger

    “Love Lucinda! And I got in trouble for eating the bottom of the cream puff:)”

  • Subway 3216 West Northern Avenue, Pueblo Sandwich Shop · $

    3 Subway

    3.9 Good 119 Reviews

    3216 West Northern Avenue, Pueblo

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Sweet Onion Chicken Teriyaki
    • All-Pro Sweet Onion Teriyaki
    • Black Forest Ham for Kids
    • Sunchips Harvest Cheddar

    “Josie, Mercedes, and Julie were very welcoming making my order with a glad heart. Thank you ladies and I plan on returning soon! Yall go see them. Best subway I've been to in a very long time. I stopped going to subways cause the service was crazy. These ladies renewed my hope!”

  • McAlister's Deli 1425 US-50, Pueblo Sandwich Shop · $

    4 McAlister's Deli

    3.5 Good 406 Reviews

    1425 US-50, Pueblo

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Mashed Potatoes and Gravy
    • Savannah Chopped Salad
    • Grilled Chicken Club
    • Colossal Carrot Cake

    “So good 😊 soup and sandwiches. Love the bread still soft, but a little crispy the perfect bread.”

  • Subway 1271 West Pueblo Boulevard, Pueblo Sandwich Shop · $

    5 Subway

    3.5 Good 118 Reviews

    1271 West Pueblo Boulevard, Pueblo

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Sunchips Harvest Cheddar
    • Baked Lay's Original
    • Doritos Nacho Cheese
    • Meatball Marinara

    “We stopped in on our way back to Texas. Lauren took care of our order, and she couldn't have been nicer! Efficient, very pleasant, service with a smile and genuine. The grey haired lady assisted with our order towards the end as well, but I didn't catch her name. The customer service alone from these 2 ladies would bring me back here on our return trips back to Colorado. These ladies need to be recognized for their hospitality, which is still valued in our book.”

  • Subway 1722 Santa Fe Drive, Pueblo Sandwich Shop · $

    6 Subway

    3.5 Good 82 Reviews

    1722 Santa Fe Drive, Pueblo

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Auntie Anne's Footlong Pretzel
    • Cold Cut Combo
    • Subway Club
    • Sandwich

    “Yes I went to the Walmart Subway on Northern and Pueblo boulevard. I ordered the tuna sandwich it was the worst sandwich I've ever had. I could barely find any tuna fish on the sandwich and barely any vegetables it was like eating an empty sandwich roll with mayonnaise”

  • Jersey Mike's Subs 2009 South Pueblo Boulevard Unit B, Pueblo Sandwich Shop · $

    7 Jersey Mike's Subs

    3.3 Good 249 Reviews

    2009 South Pueblo Boulevard Unit B, Pueblo

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Buffalo Chicken Cheese Steak
    • Roast Beef Sandwich Chips &
    • Jersey Mike's Famous Philly
    • Roast Beef and Provolone

    “Food is good and people are usually friendly. But I have never been to the Pueblo Jersey Mike's and seen one clean table. I'm the only person in the store right now. And every single table is dirty.”

  • Jimmy John's 4016 West Northern Avenue, Pueblo Sandwich Shop · $

    8 Jimmy John's

    3.2 Average 133 Reviews

    4016 West Northern Avenue, Pueblo

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery
    • Drive-Through

    Customers’ favorites

    • Italian Night Club
    • Avocado Spread
    • Beach Club
    • Turkey Tom

    “Too funny. I always do funny names when ordering, but this time was the best. Props to the artist.”

  • Subway 6470 North Elizabeth Street, Pueblo Sandwich Shop · $

    9 Subway

    3.1 Average 76 Reviews

    6470 North Elizabeth Street, Pueblo

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Cookies

    ““Derrick provided amazing customer service today at Subway. He was very friendly, patient, and made my order perfectly. He kept a positive attitude even during busy time and made the experience really pleasant. Employees like Derrick are the reason customers come back. Great job!””

  • Subway 2145 Jerry Murphy Road, Pueblo Sandwich Shop · $

    10 Subway

    3.1 Average 110 Reviews

    2145 Jerry Murphy Road, Pueblo

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Cinnabon Footlong Churro
    • The Boss
    • Cookies
    • Steak

    “Our usual Subway closed over by Sam's, so we ended up here. Parking area is tight with a small truck, can't imagine what it would be like for a full sized truck. Service was prompt, and sandwich was properly made. Store itself could have been a little cleaner (wipe the tops of the wainscoting by the windows near the high top tables, it was gross).”

  • Subway 965 West U.S. Hwy 50 Suite 140, Pueblo Sandwich Shop · $

    11 Subway

    3.1 Average 177 Reviews

    965 West U.S. Hwy 50 Suite 140, Pueblo

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Black Forest Ham Sandwich
    • Meatball Marinara
    • Italian Sandwich
    • Roast Beef

    “I came in hoping for a quick lunch during busy lunch hours with my sleeping baby. I ordered a classic footlong oven-roasted turkey w/ chips + drink, and two macadamia cookies, which ended up costing $16. The manager offered to take my order to the table since I had a car seat, I appreciated that a lot as a mom who always has her hands full. The sandwich was amazing. The bread was so fresh! I decided after eating half that I needed more mayo and the employee added it to my second half no problem. I asked if the cookies were fresh and the manager said everything is fresh every day, and honestly I could tell. The cookies were soft and delicious. I will be back to this location whenever I am craving a sub! Great experience!!”

Sandwich Shops Nearby

You May Also Like

  • Buffalo Wild Wings Go and Jimmy John's Now Share a Roof in Florida

    Buffalo Wild Wings Go and Jimmy John's Now Share a Roof in Florida

    Floridians north of Sarasota can order chicken wings and a sub sandwich at the same counter. Quality Foods Restaurant Group opened the first co-branded Buffalo Wild Wings Go and Jimmy John's on Aug. 18 at 5241 69th St. E in Palmetto. The franchisee runs three other Buffalo Wild Wings in Florida and chose fast-growing Manatee County for its game-day calendar, from high school football to Pirates spring training.