50 Best Ice Cream Shops near Sheridan

“More fun than a barrel of monkeys! And different choices of the finest quality!“

“Went last night for a cookie casanova jack hammer + pecans. Got a jackhammer with only pecans👎🏼 complete disappointment. Wasn't gonna waste our time going back to have it fixed.“

“Such a cool place with great ice cream!“

“Best ice cream I ever had and I live in California if I get a chance, I definitely want to come back in town for the Broncos game?“

“I could never imagine not recommending this place! Delicious and such a super cool experience! He kept our toddler, 9 year old, middle schoolers and high schoolers entertained! This is a must do!!“

“My kids love this place. Great amount of selections so that you don’t feel like you don’t have enough flavors to choose from. Great mix-ins, atmosphere and family vibe. 5 stars and then some.“

“Jonathan was so amazing and patient, and he even put these gold flakes on top of my ice cream, he really went above and beyond.I'm so thankful for his service.Even the people before me, he was so patient with even though they didn't know what they wanted, so I must try it.Not only was the customer service amazing, but the ice cream is to die for“

“The ice cream and hot fudge are amazing!“

“The food is amazing! Hicky recommend the Miami burger!“

“Delicious gelato, unique flavors (passion fruit is divine), great ambiance and friendly service every time! I love how the chocolate pudding isn't too sweet. Drinking chocolates are incredible, good for a cold winter's day. Highly recommend! We'll done John & Keith!“

“First time trying their ice cream. Both flavors we got were very delicious.“

“Sure as the sun rises every day, this place is likely to have a line out the door. It’s nice to see some familiar faces working behind the counter nowadays and they seem to have things dialed in a little better than in the past. The flavor selection is interesting and their rotational flavors change often enough you will find something new to love every time you go in. Parking can be a nightmare on pearl but you can park in the neighborhood and hike over.

My only gripe (and warranting a 1 star penalty) is the absence of their best flavor from their core menu. In a savage and deeply personal attack against me, the chief cow decided some years back to discontinue PB&J due to “slow sales”. Apparently eating a double scoop every day for three years for lunch wasn’t enough to maintain the product mix numbers system wide so they broke my heart and tanked it. I’m only half joking but management if you’re reading this know that wound still hurts. Bad.“

“Great ice cream, made on site, with lots of toppings and cones. A must-see stop if you're in this area of Denver.“

“So delicious!! Can’t wait to go back!!“

“As an Ice Cream shop owner myself (Muddy Puddles, Indianola Iowa) I wanted to let you know how absolutely incredible your staff was last Friday! Devin and Jay were beyond awesome in every facit of their interaction with us! We enjoyed your ice cream very much, it was very creamy, superb taste development, and no ice crystals! I had a scoop of chai tea latte and honey lavender, both were superb! Thank you again for a fun atmosphere and exceptional employees and product!“

“So good every time! I’ve tried their breakfast sammy- 10/10. And their smash burger and fries are easily the best I’ve ever had. And their ice cream.. just wow. Great ice cream combinations, great place, and great customer service. Highly recommend!“

“Bo knows…looking for the inside scoop of the best ice cream in the Denver metro area, or dare I say, state? Bo’s got your back. Bo is the scoop GOD that sets liks above any rival ice cream shop in town. Bo knows ice cream. Bo knows business. Bo knows who to hire. Bo knows“

“We ordered a holiday cake for Christmas. It was out of this world!! I would recommend Sweet Izzy's if you can or can't eat dairy! It is simply delicious and the staff are all so "SWEET" as well!“

“amazing gelato and friendly staff“

“Great Savory breakfast pastries, always hot and fresh. They are definitely worth the price and size.Would recommend to anybody.“

“Honestly such an amazing place for real Mexican ice cream! But the customer service it’s top notch, the ladies are patient educated and very well trained! They are super friendly with kids and they can let you try many flavors with such a positive actitud ! I highly recommended this place, we came on Monday was kind slow and perfect for enjoy because I can be very sure weekend here are packed because they are really good!
The place it’s super clean and super organized! Not matter where you look you can tell the staff are focusing to keep very clean and presentable! Who’s ever it’s the owner or manager they are doing fantastic job!“

“Friendly staff, and delicious ice cream.“

“Golden lodge assisted living and memory care recently had you for an event for residents staff and families and we have heard nothing but great things! Thank you so much for being part of the community and we can't wait for the next event!“

“Amazing gelato! So tasty and fresh, you immediately feel the difference from all other places! Hazelnut Gelato is FANTASTIC! Out of this world. Insane. Just go and try it, period.“

“Such a cool place with great ice cream!“

“So good! I’m visiting from out of town and decided to stop by today because I had never heard of New Zealand style ice cream. Glad I did!“

“Awesome hole-in-the wall! Came from Texas for a concert & meanwhile scoping the area we stumbled across this cool place & received a warm and friendly welcome even though it was late. Definitely worth the stop & will recommend to others who plan on visiting! The guy told us about the struggles his family business has had, really nice guy, I hope his business gets more foot traffic!!“

“My friends & I had time to kill before our flight and saw this place on google maps so we set off on a walk to find this place. We got there just at the right time because a line started to form.

Worth the wait and it looked like they were using ceremonial grade matcha! (which is why the drink may take a while - it requires precise steps, for those that don’t know). There was also only one person working when we got there - we probably waited a total of 10 mins for 5 drinks (which makes sense since whisking probably takes about a min or so & the other min is probably for preparing the drink).

Each of us got a flavored matcha (I got strawberry) & my husband got regular matcha. After tasting both, I much prefer the regular matcha!

Overall, glad we made the 15 min trek in the cold for this place - the matcha made us happy!“

“The cookies and cream ice cream would be my death-row last meal request. I think about it all the time. Literally no other cookies and cream I’ve ever tried stands up to it. Seriously. It’s made with vanilla base but looks like chocolate because the cookie-to-ice-cream ratio is so high. Never change. 🙏“

“Such a cool place with great ice cream!“

“Delicious and REAL ingredients that tastes fresh and made with love! Came in yesterday and was helped by a young gentleman who was kind and let me try basically all the flavors!

Favorites were the JOY which is an almond joy with plenty of coconut and chocolate! If you’re someone who doesn’t like texture or things getting stuck in your teeth, this is not it! But the flavor was amazing!! Blackberry had blackberry chunks and tasted so good, nothing artificial. Honey lavender was deliciously lavender. Roasted banana was unique but if you love banana, you’d love that!

Scoops are $5.55 for a single, but you get a heaping single scoop that’s totally worth it!! Definitely will be returning! Street parking available!“

“I’ve been a loyal customer of Pinkberry for over 10 years, starting back in Palo Alto, California. When I moved to Colorado, one of the things I missed the most was my favorite frozen yogurt. So I was really excited to find out there’s a location here.

In my opinion, Pinkberry still stands out as one of the freshest and most delicious frozen yogurt spots. The quality is always consistent, the flavors are amazing, and it doesn’t feel overpriced compared to other places.

I even drive from Colorado Springs just to get it and it’s absolutely worth it every time.

Definitely a go-to spot whenever I’m craving frozen yogurt.“

“amazing Icecream concept, a must to go if you are in Denver!“

“This place makes amazing ice cream I recommend it“

“We love God Save the Cream for our events as they have such a great variety of ice cream, they set up fast, have fun toppings, and also cater to our DF/GF friends that have dietary restrictions!“

“We tried the Peanut Butter and Dark Chocolate Fudge Brownie flavors, and both were very enjoyable. The ice cream was rich and flavorful without being overly sweet, which made it easy to enjoy. Overall, it was a tasty treat that felt well-balanced and not too heavy or sugary.“

“Cory was the greatest when I ordered from California for a delivery to a Littleton hospital. She was more than polite, businesslike, friendly and a pleasure to do business with. Her delivery was made, as ordered, as promised. Cudos“

“The best dairy free and gluten free ice cream I’ve ever had! Absolutely the best!!“

“The best dairy free and gluten free ice cream I’ve ever had! Absolutely the best!!“

“Get a flight! Tincup and caramel sauce are a must.“

“Cbd root beer float. Nuff said.“

“We visit pretty much weekly and we're always greeted with a smile. They even know our favorite! Such a beautiful set up. Interior decos change seasonally- last Christmas was beautiful! Very fun, very friendly, welcoming, family/youthful vibes. Happy colors. The ice cream is delicious but they have other food/treats there too. Come see!!“

“We can't wait to go back! The food and drinks are delicious. The staff are friendly, respectful, and attentive. Great price on everything, you get a lot for what you pay and it's good quality. This is my new favorite spot for sure. Love it here!“

“The best dairy free and gluten free ice cream I’ve ever had! Absolutely the best!!“

“Had some very yummy dessert at Kilwins 😋😋😋 It tastes the same here in Denver, Colorado as it does in Blowing Rock, North Carolina 😊 The ”Columbian Crew” were fantastic, helpful & friendly Staff 🌟 Bravo on your great team!! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 Even gave us a complimentary Sea Salt Caramel milkshake for our Anniversary 💕“

“Whenever I’m craving something sweet, ice cream is my go-to. I’ve visited Gelato Boy twice recently because their dairy-free, vegan, and gluten-free selection is top-tier.

💰The Price:
- Small Cone (2 scoops): $6.95
- Affogato: $8.50
- They also have last batch pints in the back freezer to take home!

🍨 The Gelato:
The Island Coconut is a must-try! It tastes like real coconut not fake and has actual shredded bits. I loved it in an Affogato last week and in a Sugar Cone today. If coconut isn’t your thing, the Lemon Poppy dairy-free is another favorite of mine.

🙂 Customer Service:
The staff is always kind and full of great recommendations. They even pointed out the back freezer, where I spotted a Dairy-Free Irish Cream I’m eyeing for next time.

🚘 Parking:
You can find free street parking if you're lucky, or use the garage across from Cava (just double-check if it's free!).

✅ Overall Experience:
I keep coming back for a reason. Whether you need a dairy-free fix or a caffeine-gelato combo, you can't go wrong here.“

“The best dairy free and gluten free ice cream I’ve ever had! Absolutely the best!!“

“Cbd root beer float. Nuff said.“

“me and my boss just had a couple of milkshakes from your establishment and the were the best I've had in a long time so happy i found this hidden gem look forward to a lot more business from me“

“💪😎🔥🔥🔥🔥 bomb place to go good ice cream and food and drinks“