50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Superior

“Pizza was delicious!!!! We had the Walter White! Even the 4 year old enjoyed it!“

“Adriana and Christian nailed it out of the park! Minute we walked in to order our pizza we were greeted with a smile! Talk about a good stuffed crust pizza and the brownie Adriana convinced us to get. Wow! Delicious all around will be going back“

“I took my grandkids there to have some one on one time with them. My one grandson had just turned 2, he absolutely loved Chuck E. Cheese. My grandson fell in love with him, Chucky spent so much time with him it melted my heart. The staff was absolutely amazing. Sampson really went out of his way for us. I should have bought the monthly pass because we will definitely be back.“

“We had a calzone at Pizza Colore in Boulder, and it was SOOO delicious! 🤩🔥 If you're in the area, you need to try it! 🍕❤️“

“always great Pizza at a great price“

“This place is the TRUTH. True small biz doing things fada PEOPLE 👊🏼✊🏼🫶🏼“

“Best Pizza in Colorado, Hands Down!“

“One of the best pizzas I’ve ever had💚💜“

“We went today for the first time and LOVED the meatballs, caesar salad and the lamb pepperoni pizza with a pumpkin beer taster and glass of cab!!! I will be back and soon! Oh… the dessert was so yummy and unique flavors!“

“Grayson was so helpful and patient! I ordered over the phone and bombarded them with questions. The owner Casey was very kind as well. BEST DEEP DISH PIZZA IN BOULDER! The turbo crust is absolutely banging. Delivery is only $5 and they always have promotions going. I would give 10 gold stars if I could. I would have posted a picture of the pizza but I scarfed it down so heres a picture of the box!

P.S. Grayson needs a raise because he’s got impeccable customer service skills⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“Pizza is delicious and the staff are wonderful“

“I definitely miss pizza from back home and this really hit the spot.Best Tavern pizza I've had since I've been out here since 2010. Maybe a tad on the salty side but I had bacon and pepperoni and I forget what flavor actually is like living out here so that may have just been me. Reheated it today and enjoying it even more. Thanks to FB group where I found y'all. Next time I'll try a deep dish.“

“Love there pizza’s and prices
Just recently started going there
Always heard about it but never tried it till now been twice
I have to try out those salads they look delicious

Parking: Depending on the time of day you go is a factor if you will find a close parking space
All in all the cars move out pretty quickly though“

“The food here cannot be beat- excellent, fresh, delicious, from-scratch-tasting, amazing everything. Don’t let the location (unassuming strip mall by the gas station) run you off- this is damn good Italian food and definitely worth trying.“

“The Papa Murphy's at 64th and Ward has been our go to for Pizza night for years. We have tried other locations with mixed results but this location consistently meets our expectations of quality and service.

Parking: Enough Parking“

“This pizza shop not only has excellent pizza, but spectacular service. I want to give them huge thank you for making a very bad situaton (thanks to Rosati's on Courtesy Road in Louisville) a great one. My 4-year old's birthday took place and I had arranged a delivery with Rosati's. They never came and wouldn't answer their phone. I wasn't too familiar with the area, but found this Cosmo's location only a few minutes away. I explained the situation and they were able to get me three perfectly cooked large pizzas and a few slices in blazing fast time and were incredibly understanding and courteous. It's great pizza, so I'd recommend it to anyone, but the incredible level of service really makes it an all-around great shop. Thanks to all those that were working on Sunday, 12/15! Me, and about 20 toddlers (and their parents), truly appreciate you!“

“Got their lunch combo! A slice of my favorite, the Spicy Pig & a Caesar salad w/sparkling Pelegrino in a glass bottle. The slices are huge. The slice I got was a nice thin crust w/lots of spicy sausage & pepperoni. It had the right level of spice, cheese, & oil. The Caesar has a nice dressing. Convenient location. It’s easy to park. The staff is kind! The bathroom is clean. Open kitchen to see them put the pizzas in. I highly recommend them! There are vegetarian options & thicker crust in some styles available.“

“Best, create your own pie place, in Colorado 😋“

“Great atmosphere, great service and amazing pizza. One of my favorite pizza spots in the Denver area“

“Best pizza! Thanks to you all for still being here for Boulder!“

“I’m going to say these guys went above and beyond to make me and my grandson a pizza. They had five minutes till close. Everything was closed up. There was an issue with the app allowing me to order the food, but they took their time to make me and my grandson our pizza I just wanna say these guys are amazing. Thank you for the amazing service and making the pizza for us.“

“The pizza is pretty good, considering options in Denver. The service leaves much to be desired. The pizza arrived room temperature/cold and not even warm. On the phone manager was very apathetic and refused to make it right. He kept talking over me, even in person, and when I called him out on it he told me literally verbatim that I was a liar. Drove over to the store, returned the cold pizza and got a proper hot pizza with a side of attitude. For a $25 pizza, it should be received hot or replaced.“

“This is the real deal New York Style pizza.“

“I stopped in at the end of the night and was greeted immediately. The owner warned me he was a bit short-staffed but due to being understanding of his young employees being “sick” on Homecoming weekend. My pizza was very good and crispy but I’ll ask for extra sauce next time, I generally expect more garlic flavor. Place is small but inviting. You can tell the family who owns this takes pride in it.“

“My fiancé & I stopped by for a quick bite. Loved the atmosphere & friendliness of the staff. Pizza has that great crunch to the bottom crust & tasted fresh! I'm definitely choosing this place for my go-to pizza cravings!“

“My family and I recently had the pleasure of dining at Basta, and it was a truly wonderful experience. It's not often you find a restaurant that can impress a diverse group including my wife, my mother, and my mother-in-law, but Basta did so with ease.

We started our meal with a selection of appetizers that set a high bar for the rest of the evening. The burrata was incredibly fresh and creamy, a perfect complement to the rich, smoky flavor of the olives. But the real star was the focaccia bread—warm, airy, and with just the right amount of salt, it was impossible to stop at just one piece.

For our main courses, we chose two pizzas and a vegetable dish. The zucchini was a fantastic addition, with the fresh, crisp vegetable elevated by the vibrant basil romanesco and the satisfying crunch of the breadcrumbs. The clam pizza was a delightful surprise, with the briny clams and a hint of lemon perfectly balanced against the smoky, blistered crust from the wood-fired oven. The Daisy pizza was a testament to the restaurant's philosophy of using high-quality ingredients; simple yet perfect, with a wonderfully flavorful tomato sauce and creamy mozzarella.

To finish our meal, we decided to indulge in all of their desserts, and we were not disappointed. Each one was a perfect ending to our dinner. The Campfire vanilla ice cream had a unique, smoky sweetness that was balanced by the vibrant and refreshing orange and beet sorbet. The sweet corn ice cream was an unexpected and delicious highlight, while the rich chocolate budino with pistachio butter was pure decadence. And of course, the donuts were a warm, fluffy, and perfect final touch.

Basta’s combination of a warm, inviting atmosphere and truly incredible food made for a special and memorable night. The staff was attentive and knowledgeable, adding to the overall great experience. We left feeling completely satisfied and already talking about when we could return. I highly recommend Basta for any occasion, whether it's a date night or a special family gathering.

Special thank you to Suzanne and Chef Alex for creating such a special evening.“

“Started with the mac and cheese absolutely delicious. Had the lasagna, AMAZING. His slow cooked ribs the meat fell completely off the bone. The lasagna was to die for definitely had an homemade taste, and as i write this we have a pizza it looks amazing i'm sure it will be just as good.“

“I frequent the Lafayette MOD location and am never disappointed! Frank is one of the best employees there and always does a great job on our pizzas. The entire team is very friendly, the restaurant is kept clean, and our pizza is always delicious!“

“Don't lose your investment in forex trade/bitcoin. Go with a proven legitimate trader that allows your unrestricted access to your account. I recommend Mrs Craig Vanessa for anyone in need of a reliable account manager because she has really helped me and got me restored from previous losses and it's been cool all the way. Invest with her today and enjoy a profitable trading experience. Now I am making profit of $5,500 weekly. Contact her through Facebook: Mrs Craig Vanessa“

“I ordered a large meat lovers with extra cheese. Out... standing. I really like their sauce and with the amount of meat they put on it, getting extra cheese nailed it for me. Great crust, cooked perfectly. Also, the gentleman working behind the counter and the staff were very kind and friendly. I have been here twice and will continue coming here. Very good.“

“everything about this place is awesome. great food great service friendly and fun atmosphere!!“

“Proto's makes the best pizza anywhere in the area! The quality, variety, and flavors are amazing! I highly recommend giving Proto's a try!“

“Proto’s is a hidden gem in Gunbarrel that I honestly don’t want to keep secret… but it’s too good not to rave about. The pizza is next level the crust is perfectly crispy, the toppings are always fresh, and the pineapple pesto pizza? Life-changing!

The vibe is laid-back and cozy, and the staff are all super kind. Whether you’re sitting on the patio with a spritz on a summer night or grabbing a quick lunch, it just hits. I love having this spot in the neighborhood it makes Gunbarrel feel like home.“

“This is always our go to pizza place ! Fresh and delicious food along with great service every time !“

“This is our go-to pizza delivery place and they nail it most of the time. When they don't - hey, life happens - they make it right. The manager Tea took care of us after one order was delivered late, and they absolutely delivered for us on Super Bowl Sunday - pizza was right on time, fresh, and hot. Well done, Domino's!“

“Fantastic everything food vibes atmosphere staff everything 10/10“

“This was one of the best, and most memorable, pizzas I've had in the metro area in quite long time. In particular, I really liked the sauce which is not something I tend to pay much attention to with pizzas. I would definatley come back again!

My only complaint is how the pizza is served, as it is given to customers on the platter it was baked on. I was given a second plater to shield my hands but by the time I was able to get downstairs to find a table (Avanti was packed) it was becoming painful to hold to the point I almost dropped my food. Please find a better way to serve the pizza!“

“The gentlemen at the Erie shop were engaging and happy. They always greet you when you walk in. Great guys! Pizza was wonderful. You can't beat the Friday deals. We hit this location every time we're in town. Great job Management! A company that gets it.“

“We were Visiting from Houston got In kinda late but we walked in 30min before closing but place was still full of guest and we're greeted with all smiles..owners wife was at the door and was extremely pleasant! Food was on point vibe was great we sat outside service was outstanding would definitely come back ....“

“BEST PIZZA EVER! The staff is amazing, the restaurant is beautiful, but the food…delicious!“

“The Best Pizza in the area.. Hands down“

“As a HUGE fan of Protos since 2007, even though I haven't signed in since those OG days, I am absolutely blown away that not only is this location up to the standards of what I demanded back then, it's above and beyond.

My new favorite.
Bravo Protos.
#Arista“

“OMG dont even have the words to tell you how good the food is here personally i love the sizzler pizza fresh garlic and pepperoni yum i would recommend this place to anyone looking for good Italian food. Pizza pics from 9/26/25. The restaurant was busy when we picked up our order tonight and the staff were getting it done! Thank you for the great service. Ps I told the owner I would take pictures while on my New York trip so I figured I would share a couple here as we had a family emergency while in New York and had to come back to Colorado before getting pizza in New York. So with that said thank you for making great New York style pizza in Colorado.“

“This place has not only incredibly delicious pizza and food but absolutely amazing vibes and friendly welcoming staff, the owner David is a killer DJ and good person! Do not miss out on:) will be stopping here every visit to Denver hands down!“

“The most generously topped pizza slices I've ever had! My wife and I both had Mediterranean slices and it was like a salad on thin crust pizza. Absolutely delicious! Seemed pricey at first but once I saw and tasted it, it was worth it!“

“These guys are amazing! They catered our backyard wedding. We had awesome communication the whole time. Melinda made it so I didn’t have to worry about anything. From appetizers, the bar and bartender… She even coordinated with the bakery for our cake and dessert. The pizza is DELICIOUS!! ( and I’m critical-lol). The team was so fun to work with and our guests felt like they were part of the group. Highly recommend them for your event. Find them wherever you can when they are on location.“

“great pizzas and staff willing to answer any questions about things and menu items. will be back again soon.“

“I usually have good pizza but today not so good! The crust was thin and burnt! More like a cracker! Usually the crust is thick and chewy today sucked!“

“Excellent food, service and atmosphere.“