28 Best Bakeries near Middletown

“Ordered my daughter’s 4th bday cake from palmieris and it was delicious and beautiful. She exceeded my expectations and will for sure be ordering all my kids cakes from here from now on!“

“Lucy’s Luncheonette is a super cozy spot serving all sorts of sourdough goodies and delicious drinks! The owners are wonderful people, the atmosphere is warm and welcoming, and the food is incredible 😍 Not only that, but they offer a "Roll It Forward" program where you can buy loaves that will help feed the community. Lucy's donates leftover food to local soup kitchens weekly as is, so you can feel extra good about supporting them! Still not convinced? They also offer apothecary staples like Elderberry Syrup, handcrafted by Cherokee herself! From Michael's charisma and culinary expertise to Cherokee's herbalism and baking skills? You'll be nourished mind, body, and soul. Go check them out ❤️“

“Maria is amazing she is professional, kind and caring! All of my cakes, cookies and food for my parties are made by Mazzota's Bakery! Her attention to detail and always willing to go above and beyond to make the perfect cake for all of my events! I refer her to everyone bc she bakes with all her heart! María is always willing to complete an order even if it's last minute! Mazzotta's Bakery is the place to order for any event -just order and you will see how great her cakes, cookies and food is for yourself .🩷thank you“

“I ordered 10 dozen of the mini cupcakes in 10 different flavors for a graduation. The cupcakes were ridiculously delicious. Everyone loved them. Every single flavor was excellent. (And yes I tried all 10😂) The delivery was perfect. They even got here a little bit early. They answered all my questions before and were great to deal with. I will definitely be using them for my next party.“

“I ordered a lemon-flavored birthday cake with buttercream frosting. The cake was made with the freshest of ingredients, was moist, and was absolutely DELICIOUS!!! Everyone commented on how flavorful the cake was, but the artistic talent of the baker/decorator took centerstage!!! The cake was so beautiful, we didn’t want to cut into it!!! If you decide to order a cake from Sweet Harmony you will not be disappointed!!!“

“This was the best creme filled donut I have ever had. Goodbye dunkin!“

“Mozzicato Bakery in Middletown never disappoints! We stopped in to pick up a cannoli cake and an assortment of cookies for my husband's birthday, and everything was absolutely amazing.
The cannoli cake was incredible, with rich, creamy cannoli filling layered perfectly into a light, delicious cake. It was the perfect centerpiece for the celebration and disappeared quickly! We also grabbed a stack of assorted Italian cookies, and every single one was fresh, flavorful, and beautifully made.
Mozzicato has mastered the art of traditional Italian baking. From the moment you walk through the door, the cases are filled with gorgeous pastries, cookies, cakes, and desserts that make it nearly impossible to choose just one thing. The quality is consistently outstanding, and you can taste the generations of craftsmanship behind every bite.
If you're celebrating a birthday, holiday, or simply have a sweet tooth, Mozzicato is one of Connecticut's finest bakeries. We can't wait to come back for our next special occasion... or maybe just because it's Tuesday.“

“It was our First time going there today with My husband and Everything we got was Delicious! I highly recommend going there! It was Wonderful, and I can't wait to go back there again!“

“Just stopped in here today for the first time and the food is delicious!“

“We had a wonderful experience with Chimirri’s for my daughter’s birthday cake! Lorena was outstanding—her communication was clear, warm, and helpful throughout the process. This was my first time ordering a custom cake, and she was so patient and informative, guiding me every step of the way and making me feel completely at ease. I had created an inspiration image using ChatGPT and asked if she could make a cake that looked similar. Not only did she recreate it perfectly, but the final cake looked even better than the image I shared! It was truly stunning and exceeded all expectations. On top of being absolutely beautiful, the cake was delicious! I will definitely be using Chimirri’s again for future special events and would highly recommend them to anyone looking for exceptional quality, artistry, and service.“

“Delicious desserts and warm food, wonderful selection. Yes you may pay $9 for a large bottle of pickles, but they are hand packed tightly and you get your money’s worth! The Kraukas Polish Dills are simply irresistible! Love the atmosphere and staff is anxious to help.“

“I had my first Amazing Ackee experience years ago at the Ellington Farmer’s Market, and I’m still enjoying alllll their offerings today. What can I say about all the great food?? Well, I’ve never not liked anything, and I thoroughly enjoy anything I’ve eaten. I love to stock up on the patties especially. As a busy vegetarian, they’re a great way to have a satisfying, healthy, quick meal any day. Beautiful people, beautiful food! In fact, I’m going to stock up again soon. Highly recommend you try them out!“

“Wow! I will definitely be coming back here and be sure to bring my friends and family along. I got the veggie omelette and it was amazing! I also got a vanilla latte with almond milk not pictured and the barista made it perfectly. Service was excellent and attentive, food is amazing, and the atmosphere is cozy with a variety of seating options. Definitely stop by and support local!“

“Really enjoyed the donuts here! The cinnamon sugar donuts were fresh, soft, and perfectly sweet. The prices are very reasonable, and the staff at the counter were friendly and welcoming. Definitely worth stopping by, especially if you can get there early before they sell out!“

“I ordered a pull apart bridal cupcake dress and cookies for my daughter’s bridal shower. The cupcakes were made in 4 different flavors that were moist, a good size, and delicious! Some cupcakes were decorated as blue flowers to surround the dress. It was a beautiful presentation. The cookies shaped and decorated as a bridal dress, an engagement ring and a Miss to Mrs plaque were the best! I recommend this bakery for any of your sweet desires. The staff was very easy to work with.“

“its fresh it's so French and it's not starbucks. I love it God bless them“

“I have nothing but good things to say about Confections by Betsy. Professional and great service & you get exactly what you order! I will be ordering from her again! ❤️“

“Ordered a very last minute sheet cake for a class reunion last weekend and The Kakery provided a beautiful and delicious cake. Everyone loved it!! Thank you so very much for taking my order with such short notice. Kudos to you!!!“

“I just purchased cannoli for my son ! I had to call and thank to nice young lady who filled with delicious creamy ricotta cheese very generously and beautifully . Thank you so much“

“me and Melba will be back, it's great“

“Not only were these cake pops delicious, but so beautifully and professionally decorated! They were the perfect dessert to bring to one of my holiday parties. I would recommend them for kids or adults. Everyone loved them! The owner even went out of her way to deliver my cake pops when I was unable to pick them up. Definitely snag some for your upcoming event. I’ll be ordering again soon!“

“Our favorite coffee place in the area!“

“Great food authentic and the service is even better my wife and I go there for some of the things that remind her of home Mexico that is so if you're looking for great food stop in and check out there selections also great breads all different kinds great with that morning coffee“

“Always a great day when I stop in for coffee and soft buttered bread before work. Only place packed at 6am Best bakery by far in town“

“Jenn was super responsive and accommodating for ordering, packaging, and delivering! Everything we ordered was fresh, delicious, and very reasonably priced! The Cinnamon star bread is not only my new favorite treat but it was beautiful! We will definitely be ordering again and again!“

“I live in NJ and recently used Patty Cakes for a specialty cake and cookie order for a local party. They were recommended by another customer who lives in CT, and I’m so grateful for the recommendation!

I worked with Deb, who was absolutely wonderful throughout the entire process. Not only is she incredibly talented and created a beautiful (and delicious!) cake and assisted with matching cookies, but she was also so pleasant, accommodating, patient, helpful, and a pleasure to work with.

Deb went above and beyond — she called me before and after hours, offered to help source a custom topper when I wasn’t sure I could get one shipped in time, and even offered to stay late for pickup. She truly made the entire experience easy and enjoyable.

I would highly recommend working with Deb and using Patty Cakes for any party or special event needs. Thank you so much, Deb!“

“My family and I just picked up a loaf of the Italian bread to go with our shrimp fra diavolo and wow it was beyond amazing! So fresh and was so good dipped in our homemade garlic and sun dried tomato olive oil. We can’t wait to try more breads and deserts from these guys! Keep up the great work we love what you make 😁“

“We love it here at Stews been coming here for years ❤️The food is always freshly made and tastes amazing! We also like watching the animatronics 🥰They make shopping more fun :) Highly recommend coming here“