21 Best American Restaurants near New Milford

“Meatloaf with potato wedges and blackeyed peas 10/10 Steak sandwich with homemade chip 10/10 Very tasty muffins 10/10 Blonde with ice cream, candied nuts, chocolate and caramel Off the charts! Will definitely be back! Nice atmosphere, Amy was the absolute best along with all the other staff. We will definitely be back!“

“Favorite place to go on the weekend with my friends. The food is great and the staff is always awesome. Henry runs a great spot.“

“Great service. Food is very good and nice size portions. Always have leave a ton of food on my plate because its so much food. Prices are very reasonable. Waitstaff is very friendly. Only small complaint I have is the temperature in the restaurant. Its always on the warm side“

“My hubby took me here for a breakfast date this morning, and they did not disappoint. The French toast was made perfectly. It was crisp in all the right places, tasted like butter, vanilla, and cinnamon, all the right things. And the hashbrowns were absolutely delicious! Whatever you are doing, keep that up! The service was awesome, the server was very pleasant and kind. It is nice to see a genuine smile when out and about. I am taking my daughter to lunch in the upcoming weeks. Thank you again!“

“Amazing food, always fresh, large portions and friendly atmosphere.“

“Love the Batman interior!“

“I’ve been to a lot of New Milford’s restaurants but I have to say the service at The Abbey was exceptional and the food was excellent and reasonably priced. Given how many eateries don’t survive over time; they are the model for a sustaining and thriving food service business. My wife had the Chicken Cordon Bleu, and I had the Chicken Caesar salad. Both were excellent and the portion size and portion per price was very good. Even the water tasted excellent. If I had one complaint it would be that the noise level was a little high, but it is a pub style restaurant where you can watch a game.“

“Great food, nice people and lovely atmosphere.“

“Had a great time! the staff and diners all made my daughter's 21st birthday a great one! Thank you!“

“To start with, I love the thick menu! I love that they give the back stories on the local products/farms they use. And the plethora of options make certain that both my husband and I can find something we like no matter what we're in the mood for. It's also nice to go to a restaurant that has more than the same 6 things everybody else has and to know those items are made with locally sourced products. I can end with a cupcake made from scratch which also supports another small business instead of something premade from the same manufacturer everyone sources their desserts from. It's a win for me!“

“A wonderful, cozy restaurant with a nice menu of choices. The staff was welcoming, the atmosphere is warm & inviting, and the food was excellent.

The crab cake app was well prepared, lots of flavor, well balanced, and the salads were fresh with crisp vegetables.

The stuffed trout & fish n' chips were great; delicate, flaky fish and the seasonal vegetables that came with em were garden fresh and full of flavor as well.

The desserts we ordered were the chocolate mousse cake & the bread pudding. Cake was rich and chocolatey; a bit more mousse than cake, but that was great by me. And the bread pudding was perfect in texture, flavor, and size for price.

Great experience start to finish, our server Colleen was amazing, and thank you for a wonderful meal.“

“Great ambience sitting outside near the beautiful waterfall stream! The food is absolutely delectable!“

“Manager very nice. Staff hard workers. Nice atmosphere“

“Good food. Good staff. Cold beer“

“They make a really great breakfast sandwich and they don’t nickel and dime for every added ingredient. Very reasonably priced, and always greeted with friendly service. I go out of my way to drive through Brookfield so I can stop here! Also highly recommend their tuna salad wrap with the potato chips in it.“

“Absolutely wonderful experience at our first time at Rebellion tonight! From the vibe and atmosphere, to the most amazing drinks by Dorian at the bar and the incredible, elevated food (Bronzino & NY Strip to be specific) and just an absolute amazing experience overall. A must visit! 5 🌟 all the way!!“

“Just had a great lunch! Nice people, really good food.“

“Excellent evening at the Bistro! Every bite was delicious and the service was wonderful. We enjoy the atmosphere as well 😊“

“The food is AMAZING. Better than what you’d expect for bar food. The in house ranch is worth a mention by itself. It’s so good you’ll put it on everything. The fries are bomb. Wings great. Kids loved their tenders. Will be coming back again when in the area. We didn’t dine in. Took the food to go.“

“Great burgers! Friendly service“