24 Best Pizza Restaurants near North Windham

“I just moved to the area and being from New York I'm a bit particular about pizza. I tried 5 different places and Illiano's is far superior to the others! Plus I ordered a greek salad with grilled chicken and it was excellent! They are my go to restaurant.“

“Excellent pizza. A bit loud. [Original] Excellent pizza. A bit loud.“

“Very friendly atmosphere!! My favorite place to go with my family and friends ♥️“

“First time trying and everything was FABULOUS! The White Garlic Pizza is an absolute fave and we’ve never EVER got such huge meatball grinders! I am going to get really, really fat. � AWESOME place!“

“Excellent! Delivery was fast, all items hot and well prepared!“

“nice place, friendly staff. the food was good and plentiful. the made my Cold roast beef sandwich just the way I asked. very nice!“

“I’ve consistently ordered delivery from Tony’s, their pizza is awesome and quick delivery. The best part is the delivery driver brings my dog a milk bone so she loves Tony’s too. Thank you!“

“I came to CT for a visit recently to see the old home town of Lebanon CT. My girlfriend and I used visit Mama's Pizza regularly back about 35 years ago when we were in our late teens. I just love coming to a restaurant that has stood the test and has not changed it's values or it's awesome flavorful menu. The staff very pleasant and always ready to help at anytime. Thank you all for helping to relive a part of our lives that is very near and dear to both our hearts.“

“The best pizza for the soul.“

“Ordered gluten free pizzas from Pleasant about 2 weeks ago and they were the absolute best GF pizzas I’ve had in 11 years of being gluten free. No issues with cross contamination either. Order from them!!!“

“The best pizza for the soul.“

“Me and my husband got married on Lake Chaffee Sept 14, 2024. The owners of the lake house suggested we use Midway Pizza for a fun wedding food idea!
Midway was FANTASTIC!! Not only was the pizza and salad great they were so accommodating delivering it to us. The price was right and everyone enjoyed their pizza!!!
Thank you so much Midway Pizza for the great food and great service!!“

“Have ordered from here several times and each time the food has arrived hot, and prepared perfectly! Great job!“

“if you live near UCONN, then you need to check out gansett wraps on storrs roadthe owner khal is originally from lebanon and when he moved to the states, he knew he wanted to share his love for food with the community around himhe originally opened his first wrap shop in narragansett rhode island and now gansett wraps is in a few towns across connecticut and rhode islandfirst timers have to try the gyro falafelits a beef gyro, with housemade falafel, lettuce, tomatoes, onions and tzatziki sauce. the sauce is so savory and falafel which is a blend of chickpeas and spices added so much flavorother wraps can be stuffed with chicken, bacon, veggies and even french frieshome to where the husky womens basketball team gets their lunch, gansett wraps has to be added to your connecticut foodie bucket list❤️“

“Timothy, Shelby and Tony have countlessly made me some of the greatest pizzas i have ever tasted in my entire life, i mean perfect cheese to sauce ratio every single time, no bubbles in the dough, cut perfectly, this spot most definitely has the magic touch! 😎“

“Great pizza and service every time I have ordered, also really great Buffalo wings too! Definitely worth a try if you haven’t had it yet and bonus that they deliver !!“

“Thank you for your excellent service and pizza ! We are frequent flyers here as it's our daughter's favorite pizza in town ! No matter what pizza we offer her she chooses your location Everytime ! Thank you for taking good care of us and the pizza is amazing! Pizza was hot and fantastic!“

“Best Pizza in the area. Everything from here is always great“

“I went with a large group, and the service was wonderful. Everyone enjoyed their meals, and we had plenty of leftovers. If you need a place to eat after the Renaissance Fair, this is a perfect location to enjoy a meal. We will definitely be back again.

Kid-friendliness: The kid's menu is awesome!“

“Make your own personal pizza with whatever toppings you want, or choose from their specials. I chose the bbq pizza and it was so delicious. There are a ton of toppings to choose from, and I want to go back to get creative and make my own! Also got the blood orange lemonade and it was very tasty!“

“great food and friendly service! love the taco pizza!“

“I love your Calzones. Really good.

Parking: It's like a plaza. So they Share parking's. I always get parking and there is Spaces left over.

Kid-friendliness: Yes they will definitely get your kids Smiling with there Choices.

Wheelchair accessibility: No wheelchair due to the Steps and where it's located.“

“Loved it! Ya gotta go! The food was great. We had hotdogs with tater tots and meatball grinder with French fries. Very fresh, hot and tasty. No greasy bar-food here! Reasonably priced. Place was clean, clean and tables spaced per CDC guidelines for social distancing. Lots of choices for beer on tap!“

“I can not speak for their other locations, but the Storrs location is great! All the staff, from the bartenders (shout to Zeke and Ethan!) to the servers to the kitchen chefs, are all great people that bring amazing energy. The food, in my humble opinion, is delicious. And the gelato is some of the best I've ever had (I grew up 30 minutes from Philly, so I know good gelato when I taste it). I won't say the "bad" reviews have no merit, but my personal experience, after coming here for a little over a year, had been nothing if not great. If you're in the area as a student, visiting family, etc., do yourself a favor and check it out. Square Peg Storrs is one of THE BEST spots for food, drinks, and fun in the area.“