8 Best Sandwich Shops near Old Lyme

“Excellent Experience. Stopped at that Subway to buy myself and 2 workers lunch on the way back from a job. The 2 ladies working were very friendly, polite and attentive. The elder of the 2 who had taken care of me made a great wrap suggestion and the food was great. Besides the friendly staff there are chairs outside to sit in which was great on such a nice day.“

“Totally scrumptious! The sweet potato panini special is incredible!“

“Leaving a positive review about Wheatmarket almost seems pointless as I have never heard a complaint. I love this place so so much. The food is super reasonably priced, consistent, fast, staff is beyond wonderful and the cookies are top tier. So lucky to have it in town 💙“

“⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5/5 The emphasis on quality and freshness is evident in every bite. The ingredients are top-notch, and you can taste the difference. It's clear that they take pride in sourcing the best for their customers. Beyond food, Mystic Market serves as a hub for the local community. The warm and welcoming atmosphere, friendly staff, and communal seating make it a perfect spot to connect with friends or just enjoy a meal in peace. It's our favorite place to stop for lunch in-between clients!“

“I had to make a split decision lunch choice and this subway was closest, so I flew in for a bite to eat. I was pleasantly greeted by John and the other employee, whose name I didn’t catch. I had a lovely conversation with John, and he made my otherwise average day, into a better one with a free chocolate chip cookie and the delicious sub they made! Thank you again, John!“

“I went to have a quick bite with my husband last night and while we sat to eat, a man with no money walked in. The owner immediately walked over to him, greeted him with utmost respect, made him a footlong sandwich and meal, free of charge, and treated him in a way that made us both tear up and realize there are good people in this world who have a heart of gold. The owner is a couple who treats their customers like friends and family, but this action made me respect them 100 times more. God bless you. We come in from out of state once a month to visit our kids and always stop to eat here because of their warm customer service.“

“It would have been good . Web site wouldn't show combo meal so I drove there and entered and customer looked at me , then started asking her 5 kids what they wanted , so you know what happened .
I smiled at the worker and said guess I'll be going else where .
So Family pizza for tuna grinder with black olives , extra lettuce .
Got home no black lives , onions 😢.
Can't believe people are that stupid .
Gee look around and you'll see how people are .“