22 Best Pizza Restaurants in Wallingford

“Best Italian restaurant in the area I come all the way from Florida to go there Make sure you ask for Francesca for a waitress the best Thank you Francesca for a great experience“

“Had the pastitsio and loved it.“

“We drive from Rocky Hill to Christos Wallingford for their family meal deals during the week or if we are passing through from seeing family on the shore. Family serving of whatever they are offering plus bread and a salad. Feeds us for 3 days. 10/10“

“Good pizza, fast service and got a party of 21 in and out quickly with lots of kids.“

“Excellent pizza. Thin crust, good red sauce, tasty toppings. Great central location too!“

“Great food. Excellent service. Our “go to” for pizza, subs and more! Great wine selection with a full bar!!“

“Love their pizza- tell them how you want it comes out that way! Beautifully cooked (Not soggy wet crust pizza) has all veggies green peps, onions, (Fresh) mushrooms, Garlic z
asked xtra sauce & not TOO Much Cheese (that's for kids lol)
Came out Perfect!
PERFECT! Again & Again!
Tell them - So Accommodating! if you love/ miss pizza the way it used to be - Flavor & delicious!!!!! You will Always Order here 😉😊
Update: Today 9/25/25
Another Perfect Pizza
Xtra sauce, onions, fresh mushrooms, Garlic & Green Peppers 😊🙃“

“Such great food especially for the price. Everytime we order we can not believe our portions and how amazing it all tastes! We try something new almost every order. This is a hidden gem in town and more people need to check it out!“

“I had the opportunity to win a free lunch at my work place! It was as amazing as it looks in the pictures ! I picked the focaccia sandwiches- and caesar salad, and everything was delicious! I will be in to try your other dishes...❤ Thank you so much! Everyone enjoyed the lunch!“

“Hands down the best pizza place in Wallingford!!! Highly recommended. Hopefully @barstoolsports gives them a review one day! My score is a solid 8.6 👍🏻 Also a big thank you to the owner Fabi for always giving the best service“

“A reliable source for yummy fresh pizza or meals!! I love the pizza by the slice, garlic knots and desserts.“

“We've been going to this place for more than 10 years. When ever we want good pizza, this is the place. We always get the plain thin crust (its incredible!!!).
This time we ordered something more adventurous, and got Tri colore pizza. It was really good , but not for the people who dont like spinach. It had too much for my personal taste. Their stake and cheese sandwich is soo awesome.
Do try it once. I guarantee, you'll be back.“

“My husband and I ordered a pizza to go from Carini’s for the first time under their new management. We ordered the Smog pizza. It had sausage, mushrooms, peppers and onions as toppings. The pizza was absolutely delicious! It had just the right amount of mozzarella. The sausage was so tasty and the mushrooms, onions, and peppers were fresh and cooked perfectly. Having grown up in New Haven, I loved that the crust was on the thinner side. I highly recommend Carini’s! We look forward to ordering more pizza or stopping in for dinner some night!“

“Can’t even believe how Abe from this restaurant spoke to me! I ordered a pizza for my kids and it came without sauce and when I called to explain, it was nothing but RUDENESS! He had the audacity to tell me I had to apologize to him and his counter girl before he would replace. He told me he didn’t care if he lost a customer, I had no idea who he was. He hung up on me and when I called back and asked for the owner to explain he started yelling and had his employees in the background yelling he was the boss and I had no idea who I was talkin to and I should find out before talking to him and hung up on me again! I called the Milford location and asked who the owner was, his name is OZ and he sounded like this was certainly not the 1st time he had a complaint. He apologized over and over but honestly I cannot believe the things he said! SMH worst customer service EVER GHETTO!!!!!“

“I’m writing this while eating my pizza. I ordered the shrimp casino pizza. The pizza itself tasted amazing but they forgot the shrimp. I told the worker up front and he offered to make me a whole new pizza while I eat the one I have right now!!! 10/10“

“Stopped by on my way to NY tried a GoodToGo order, I will I was surprised by the quantity of donuts. Unfortunately and I don't want to be harsh as GoodToGo is used to stop food from going to waste, but these donuts were really stale and just barely edible. Which surprised me because the donuts given to me came straight from what was on the shelves for the day, I got there around 3:30 and they closed at 8 according to Google. If you do try them maybe try to get them as they open and are fresh. The donuts with cereal with the easiest to eat for some reason but the rest were just dry, stale to the point that it was hard to try and finish. On positive note if you looking to get 10 donuts for $7~ check this place out on the GoodToGo app.“

“The Mahi Mahi, and Pork Chops specials were so delicious that we literally wiped the plates clean! Fratelli’s has the best bread, great service, absolutely delicious food and a wonderful family atmosphere. What are you waiting for? The best food in town is at Fratelli’s! 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟“

“It was great gathering place. Paul was great he got a little busy but he was super fun waiter“

“We have been on a year long pizza tour. This place is awesome. Best crunch so far.. and the sauce is amazing. My son and I bought 3 large regular pies not knowing that we should've probably ordered the mozzarella..but we ate a pie and a half between us, and then I brought some home and we finished it all .. I could have run 10 miles after it. Very light and enjoyable. We are coming back for the mozzarella!“

“My favorite restaurant of all time“

“Great food, great service, great people!“

“4.5 overall
8.2 on the slice

Really top notch imo. I had a snafu and forgot to add a topping on a gh order. They let me call in and modify and pay cash at pickup. They didn't want to take my money on arrival which was nice of them. Tip your people, everyone!

The slice was great. Big flop because it had toppings, but it held beautifully. Great char on the bottom and that razor thin apizza crust. Toppings up to the edge. Good pie. I don't think it's wood or coal fired, but the got the temp right in that oven for sure. Good fresh ingredients!“