4.6
Superb
99 Reviews
338 N Broadway, Pennsville · 9.07 miles
Customers’ favorites
- Vanilla Frozen Custard with Rainbow Jimmies
- Blueberry Vanilla Ice Cream
- Small Strawberry Sundae
- Strawberry Cheesecake
“A Genuine Surprise Stop on Our Way Back From NYC We were on our way home from NYC, planning to wash the car before calling it a day, when we drove past Pennsville Custard Stand. Right before it, we passed what can only be described as a crack den (a rundown motel with a few guys doing the crack dance), and honestly, we didn’t expect much more down the road. Then suddenly, we see this beautiful little hole-in-the-wall shack that completely caught us off guard. Not only were the prices super reasonable, but the service was lightning fast — in and out like that. It was clearly a regular local spot too. We saw a dad just casually enjoying his custard outside his truck, like this was his go-to ritual, while my wife and I enjoyed ours. It had this wholesome, small-town vibe that made the whole stop feel unexpectedly special. If you’re ever passing through, don’t sleep on this place. Absolute gem.”