15 Best American Restaurants in Bay Lake

“We visited on 9 Jan 2026…the service was slow, food mediocre. Going here is more for atmosphere, but not much else.“

“My husband and I went there for lunch today and not only was the food delicious, our bartender/server Melanie was so friendly, knowledgeable about the food and the beverages and made the experience amazing.“

“What an unreal experience. The food was fantastic. Service was great. We had a great view from our table and something that doesn’t always work at the Disney restaurants, the timing of the meal was impeccable. A little over an hour and a half was so nice to relax and enjoy our dinner. Our first but certainly not our last.“

“Absolutely awesome restaurant! Any time we are in town we go! The kids love it! Great food options, great atmosphere, the staff is the best! Very affordable and large portions especially for the area! This is a hidden gem for sure! We’ve been there many times and every time it has been awesome! It has been consistently good every visit!“

“Absolutely amazing!!!! The Italian night is spectacular ! I had Chicken parmesan! The espresso Martini ! The views are beautiful & sunset on the patio. They all have a small bar and what great great service! Must try ! Inside Orangelake vacation club. Love it. Also toptracer is there. Fun ! ⛳“

“Let’s talk about my favorite breakfast hack at Disney’s Polynesian Village! I am completely obsessed with their Tonga Toast, and the portion is huge—my 19-year-old son and I split one order, and our entire bill was under $26 plus tip. The best bonus? That breakfast reservation got us free parking, giving us three relaxing hours to soak up the resort vibes and stroll the grounds. It kept us satisfied for the morning, though we were definitely ready for lunch a few hours later. The service wasn't quite as warm or attentive as my previous visits, and honestly, if it had been my first time going, I might have felt a little hesitant to return. But overall? The savings and the setting still make it totally worth it..“

“Awesome time along with good craft beer by local breweries!“

“We ended up eating at Centertown Market most evenings during our stay at Disney's Caribbean Beach Resort, and it turned out to be the perfect balance of price, quality, speed, and variety for our family.

After long days in the parks, it was nice to have a quick-service restaurant where everyone could find something they wanted. The food was consistently good, the service was fast, and the Cast Members were friendly and helpful, just like we experienced throughout the rest of Disney.

For a family of four, I'd plan on spending somewhere between $50 and $80 for dinner, depending on what everyone orders. We found it to be a fair value considering the quality and convenience.

One tip I'd recommend: if you're planning on ordering pizza, buy the whole pizza instead of the Super Slice. The Super Slice is roughly equivalent to three regular slices, but purchasing the whole pie essentially gives you two additional slices for about the same value. It's a much better deal, especially for families.

Overall, Centertown Market became our go-to dinner spot because it consistently delivered exactly what we needed after a full day of Disney—good food, reasonable prices, quick service, and something everyone in the family enjoyed.“

“Ate here for the first time this weekend and the food was amazing! Our waitress was very helpful and the food was fresh and delicious. Some of the best tortilla chips I’ve had (salsa trio) and the enchiladas were great! Great kids options as well!“

“The quick bite pool bar with alcoholic drinks.

Has a TV playing whatever ask.

People are very friendly and great service. The bar thunder gave my little grandson a Mickey ice cream bar. Amazing gesture out of the blue!

Food is a unique take on an African theme.“

“Fun atmosphere with great drinks for the pool.“

“We stopped to get ice cream, and Jaylen was incredibly helpful, kind and just a great server. The technology was failing in multiple locations but he was patient and still managed to make the experience easy and pleasant. Definitely look forward to coming back again.“

“Buffalo chicken chef salad. Just wow! This has to be the best kept secret in disney food. Very very tasty, well presented and big enough for two people to share. Best of all it's just a quick service credit if you are on a dining plan.“

“The food is great. We had the smoked chicken meal a couple of times and added these sides - mashed potatoes and gravy, macaroni and cheese, and cowboy beans. The hamburger was just okay. The pizza was very good, but not great. The crust was nice.“

“I really loved the plant-based rice bowl, which was the only vegan entree. I was expecting something way more bland. I thought meatballs were an odd choice to include, but they were great! Saucy and really flavorful, didn't have to rely on the hot sauce I grabbed just in case. I don't like Chipotle or Qdoba, but this was good. Updated from previous review on 2026-07-04“