New American Restaurants near Bay Lake, FL

“We had an amazing dinner at Narcoossee’s! The atmosphere simply cannot be beat; it’s one of the closest restaurants you will get with both a view of the Magic Kingdom and the entire Bay Lake. It’s so peacefully off the beaten path, and almost feels like you’re dining at the ocean itself. Our meal was phenomenal, with the filet mignon on the surf and turf as one of the best filets I’ve ever tried. We added the creamed spinach with blue lump crab and it took this dish over the top. Of course we had to try their signature cheesecake for dessert, and it was the perfect ending to a truly remarkable dinner experience. Cannot wait to go back.“

“Flying Fish is easily one of our favorite restaurants at Disney. We make it a point to eat here every trip. The reason for the deduction of a star is due to the children's menu. My daughter and I both got steak during our last trip. It was delicious and both came with green beans. During our meal, she asked why hers were different from mine. Mine were fresh and she got ones that looked like the ones that come from a can. It made me compare our steaks too and they were obviously different. I think they should consider just making the children's meal a smaller version of the adult but not alter the quality of the meal as they obviously did here. I ended up just sharing mine with her.“

“My husband and I went there for lunch today and not only was the food delicious, our bartender/server Melanie was so friendly, knowledgeable about the food and the beverages and made the experience amazing.“

“Ate here for the first time this weekend and the food was amazing! Our waitress was very helpful and the food was fresh and delicious. Some of the best tortilla chips I’ve had (salsa trio) and the enchiladas were great! Great kids options as well!“

“Food was delicious and something different than the usual chain restaurants“

“Jay is my favorite bartender at Seasons 52! He’s always attentive, and his drinks are consistently on point and perfectly balanced. I love that he gives such great recommendations and makes every visit a wonderful experience. Highly recommend asking for Jay!“

“My boyfriend & I are visiting Orlando for a week and came here twice. Both times the food was amazing. Brett our server was so welcoming and kind we even asked for him our second time around and considering coming back a third! The service is great for how busy this place was. Worth the wait!!“

“I adore Fresh Kitchen - the best restaurant I've found in the area to eat a gluten/dairy/meat free dinner that is also low in salt! That's because two of the managers know my restrictions and automatically put together a delicious bowl that I can safely eat (rice, chickpeas, kale, red pepper, almond slices, etc) - and it's delicious! Yesterday, I took my bowl home, added fresh sliced peaches and avocado, enough then to split into two meals. It was awesome.“

“Just wanted to thank Sierra for her service when I come w my friends. She always makes everything easy, suggest different things, and never makes us feel like a burden with complicated orders. This place is very convenient in location and to watch the game and fights. Thank you again, Sierra!“

“Had a fabulous evening. Service was excellent. But it was a late booking as there were no earlier tables available - which was disappointing. All the staff were friendly & professional. Would recommend family and friends.“

“Love Freddy’s every chance I get to eat here. One of the best Burger Chains out there“

“Nos encantó la combinación de buena atención y un ambiente cálido para compartir momentos especiales con familia y amigos !“

“I was in town for my daughter's 14th birthday and Norman's did not disappoint. From our initial greeting to the final goodbyes, the team at Norman's was flawless. We were promptly sat upon entering. Every team member that stopped by our table made sure to wish my daughter a happy birthday. Service was timed to perfection. Drinks were always kept full. Entrees got to us just as our appetizers were finished. Our service team made sure we had everything we needed to enjoy our visit. As for food we started with the charcuterie board, blue crab beignets, and the pork belly. All 3 appetizers were amazing and perfectly portioned so we could all enjoy some. I had the yellowtail snapper as I've heard that Norman's has the best yellowtail snapper and this could be the best filet of fish I've ever had. Highly recommend trying this fish out if you're a fish lover as I am. We also had the filet mignon and the Mongolian tomahawk pork chop. Both were cooked perfectly and had great flavor. We also enjoyed au gratin potatoes, creamed corn and lobster Mac. The creamed corn was the only item in the entire experience that I didnt care for because it had a pepper taste to it and that's not what I was expecting. Lobster Mac was great as was the au gratin potatoes. For dessert, they brought out a platter as a surprise to all us with my daughter's name written on the plate. That was a super cool touch and made the experience that much better. Not to be outdone they also brought us passionfruit creme brulee, key lime pie, cheesecake and tiramisu. Each of these desserts were delicious. Sadly I was able to taste but not indulge as I have to watch my sugar intake but the rest of my party loved each option given. I can't say enough how great this dining experience was to those that I know so I wanted to share what an outstanding job Norman's did for my family and how special they made my daughter feel. True hospitality is hard to find these days and Norman's did a fine job on this visit.“

“An absolutely incredible experience! Service was exceptional and food was delicious. Thank you to Dakota (our server) and Chef David for taking care of me with my allergies (bell pepper, treenut, Celiac). They both went above and beyond! Chef David came to the table to discuss my options. Even the hostess asked if anyone in our party had allergies right when we walked in. I was very impressed and had a wonderful meal. The artisanal salad was yummy and much larger than I expected. The Saganaki itself is gf and can be served with gf crackers. And of course, the wine list will blow you away. Thank you again--we'll be back!“

“omg... First time here. Laura Corona our server AMAZING!! Sophia our manager AWESOME!“

“A massage for your palate! Wonderful for a celebration“

“A unique and exciting eating experience.“

“Simply outstanding! Great all-around experience!!“

“Victoria was excellent! She was attentive and made great recommendations. Can’t wait to go back again!“

“One of my favorite quick meal restaurants in Disney World! The food was delicious and unique and don’t even get me started on the desserts. Also, great facilities with plenty of seating room and air conditioning. We actually went for both breakfast and lunch!“

“We always have a great time here. Food is great and service always on top of it. Christiana is top notch. Provides great service. Remembers us when we come in.“

“We loved it! So did the little one! We would definitely go again! ✅“

“Worth visiting! Food, atmosphere and service were all great! Donna is amazing and so welcoming and kind. The best chef! We went back multiple times because of her.“

“Super cute bar/restaurant!
First coming in right away you can see they are very clean every thing is super organized and everyone was attentive from the start .
The service was amazing our waiter god bless I can not remember his name but the manger made a joke about cutting his hair again ! (Lol if that helps ) anyways he was great kept up with us frequently and over all super friendly .
The manager was super friendly as well !
As for food it was on par ! Definitely would recommend this for more local’s !“

“Booked a reservation for lunch. Checked in and table was ready within 5 minutes. Waiter was incredibly attentive. We got the onion rings to start. Highly recommend. I got the Stack Burger and wife got the Grilled Chicken Sandwich. We split the sandwiches so we could try both. Chicken was good and topped well, but that Stack burger is next level. She mentioned she should have gotten that too so we both had a whole burger. Place has pictures of the founding of Disney World which is fascinating to look at. Doesnt feel like you are at Disney otherwise but that is okay. Great for couples i think.“

“Excellent service. Delicious food“

“Awesome restaurant Great vegan options.“

“I haven't been to Orlando in awhile but if God is willing the first meal I have when i get back will be here! This place is the real deal.“

“Hands down one of the best restaurant experiences we have ever had at any amusement park! As a family navigating extreme food allergies, dining out in theme parks can usually be incredibly stressful—but Confisco Grille at Islands of Adventure blew us completely away.From the moment we sat down, the service was top-notch, but the manager truly went above and beyond to accommodate our family's safety. They took our allergy needs seriously, walked us through everything, and made sure our entire dining experience felt safe, seamless, and incredibly special.The service was spectacular from start to finish, and the food was absolutely off the chain! Every single dish was fresh, delicious, and perfectly prepared. We cannot thank the team and management enough for making our family dinner unforgettable. We will absolutely be back!“

“Recommended to have a reservations so I sat at the bar. Love that they accommodate food allergies. I really enjoy their steak and the bartenders were very inviting with samples of wine to find the perfect pick. I enjoyed the atmosphere which was fun, elegant and inviting.“

“I'm from TX and know BBQ quite well. If I say this business is the REAL deal, I probably didn't give it enough credit. This place is 🔥. Great service, down home feel, and the food.... WOW. If you get to or are in Orlando Florida, stop by; you won't be disappointed. I'll have to get some dessert next time.“

“A Disney trip isn’t complete without Dole Whip 🍍✨
This time we tried the Dole Whip Rum Floater. That splash of Parrot Bay Coconut Rum definitely helped 😉

That said… the Dole Whip itself wasn’t as creamy as I remembered. It felt more icy than it used to be, even compared to a couple of years ago. Not sure it’s even real ice cream 🤷‍♀️

Still a fun Disney tradition. Curious if anyone else has noticed the change?“

“Manager Aaron & his entire staff was helpful when we had a medical emergency while eating there this past weekend. Everyone moved with urgency and took great care of us. This has always been one of our favorite spots in Disney Springs and this cements our loyalty. Many thanks!“

“Everything was perfect ! Servers are amazing !“

“This dining experience is hands-down, one of the best in all of Disney.
The food is outstanding.
And our server Liliana was absolutely amazing.
Thank you so much for the magical experience.
Thank you again Liliana“

“Manager Aaron & his entire staff was helpful when we had a medical emergency while eating there this past weekend. Everyone moved with urgency and took great care of us. This has always been one of our favorite spots in Disney Springs and this cements our loyalty. Many thanks!“

“Elaine is a wonderful and hard working server. If you ask for her she will always make your experience platinum plus. Good food and beverages“

“We were just looking for a quick bite to eat and this place did not disappoint! The owner is so friendly and works hard to make sure your meal is just as you want! The food is good but the service is really that does it! Located outside of Bass Pro Shop this is a great place for a nice lunch!“

“Good family fun Great service“

“Marvelous happy hour! We actually had dinner there one night and returned for happy hour the next!“

“Our Server (E) Lightskin Gentlemen from the Bronx brought 5 star service. The elaborate details of food presentation immaculate. Attention to details made the night. The Ambience is incredible z the margaritas we had were watermelon and mango well made excellent. Now the Brussel sprouts to die for. The peach and shrimp salad truly a desert. We will recommend coming to anyway looking for a good time and beautiful scenery. E made our night special he’s is truly a top server one the best in the world 1-4-18.

P.S. The Cuban Coffee 🤌 took the night“

“This has been one of the best dining experiences I've had in a long time. Im from Philadelphia, PA visiting for my birthday. They delivered. I had the pleasure of meeting Raj and Chloessa aka Chloe. The best customer service EVER. I cannot wait until we come back. I love being an ICON Select member. This hotel made me feel RICH. I can't wait to share you all with my family. RAJ Even gave me an umbrella upon leaving. They think about everything. Thank you.“

“One of the nicest quick serve restaurants I have been in. As stated real plates and silverware when dining in. Small seating area but food is fantastic. Pasta bolognese was great but small portion for price. The grilled chicken sandwich on Focaccia was fantastic. Probably the best value in my opinion.“

“Experience was vastly superior to standard theme park quick-service food. If you are in Seuss Landing, this is easily the top spot to hit for a heavy, savory meal that delivers on quality.

Item: Cheeseburger Tots
Plate Rank: 4.50 out of 5
The Verdict: Taste was a 5 out of 5, Value was a 4 out of 5, and Gram-ability was a 4 out of 5. Absolute standout execution. The ground beef, pickles, cheese sauce, and mustard combine perfectly over crisp tots. Highly recommend.

Item: Buffalo Chicken Tots
Plate Rank: 4.25 out of 5
The Verdict: Taste was a 5 out of 5, Value was a 4 out of 5, and Gram-ability was a 3 out of 5. Excellent flavor profile with a great kick from the buffalo sauce and blue cheese. They do not skim on the chicken portions here.

Item: Vegan Chorizo Tots
Plate Rank: 4.00 out of 5
The Verdict: Taste was a 4 out of 5, Value was a 4 out of 5, and Gram-ability to a 4 out of 5. A very solid plant-based alternative that holds its own flavor-wise against the meat options, though slightly lower on the overall value proposition.

Ranking these for the official Theme Park Plate June launch at Islands of Adventure. For anyone looking at the full menu data on the site, which tots are winning your vote?“

“Finally, a really lovely meal at Universal! 😂

We visited The Kitchen at the Hard Rock Hotel for dinner and sat outside as it was such a beautiful evening.

We had the Rockin’ Rolls to start, which were really nice and a great way to start the meal.

For our main we had the 7oz Filet Mignon, and this was definitely the highlight. The steak was absolutely delicious and cooked beautifully. The potatoes were equally good and the red wine jus brought everything together perfectly. We thoroughly enjoyed every bit of it!

The cocktails were also excellent and certainly didn’t disappoint.

Jeremy looked after us and was friendly and attentive throughout the evening.

Honestly, no complaints at all.

Would we return? Absolutely!“

“Genuinely the most unbelievable experience ive ever had in my entire 25 years of life. The food was unbelievably exceptional and the service was beyond friendly. 11/10 and I do not say that lightly my standards are beyond high. For disney world I am absolutely blown away. Next level 💯 sat at bar ordered steak medium well“

“We had a really lovely experience at The LakeHouse, both for breakfast and dinner.

Breakfast was excellent — I had the Eggs Benedict and really enjoyed it.

We came back for dinner and started with the French onion fondue, which was absolutely delicious and probably one of the highlights of the meal. I then had the beef short rib, which was also lovely. Honestly, no complaints about the food at all.

The cocktails were great too, and the whole setting is really quiet and calm, which made for a very relaxing evening.

Service was good throughout and overall we really enjoyed both visits.

Would 100% return!“

“I had such a wonderful experience at Fiorenzo during my stay at the Hyatt Regency Orlando. I was in town for a conference and dining alone most evenings, but Gokhan Yilhan, the restaurant manager, and his staff made me feel completely at home.
Gokhan was charming, welcoming, and incredibly attentive. Sasha, who served me most nights, was also wonderful, and one evening the chef even came out to visit.
The steak was excellent, and I especially enjoyed the wine. Gokhan let me taste a few different selections until I found just the right one, which was such a thoughtful touch.
I genuinely looked forward to dinner at Fiorenzo every evening. Great food, wonderful wine, and exceptional hospitality. Gokhan and his team made my stay especially memorable. Highly recommend!“

“Pretty good spot to be fairly honest. Food was good , fries was good , and shrimp was good. I just have two things that’s not so on the positive side. Where in the hell are are the waiters???? Food took quite a while. It’s as if the restaurant was filled with nothing but customers. Furthermore just the long wait for the food which may be due to the lack of people. That’s the only thing I have to say!“

“Tiny little food / drink hut in the Pandora land in Animal Kingdom. I would have missed it all together if I wasn’t looking for something specific - don’t miss it, it’s got great offerings! The drinks are really cool (alcoholic and non alcoholic) and the snacks are lovely too. Queues can be a little long but worth it.“