15 Best Sandwich Shops in Gainesville

“We have gone by Big Mill’s for years and said one day we will have to check them out. Well today was that day. We are elderly and while running errands we decided today was the day to check out Big Mill’s. My husband loves trying Cheesesteak sandwiches wherever he sees them on the menu. My go to is a Patty Melt or Reuben so I was happy. We walked in to a room full of people talking & enjoying their food. We were greeted at the order window by a very sweet young lady who was very helpful since we told her it was our first time there. When we questioned a size she made sure to show us what that size was & explain it to us. After we placed our order to go she said we were welcome to have a seat & even gave me a cup for water while we waited since I didn’t order a drink but my husband’s came with one. As we sat there reading their great menu and the incredible list of shakes they offered we noticed if no one was at the counter ordering she was wiping down the tables & clearing baskets when someone was done with their food - she was non-stop and so friendly to everyone. Our first impression of Big Mill’s started with this young lady. Well done Big Mill’s. So only after a short wait we took our order home. My husband got the Big Philly cheesesteak, he eats half and saves the other half for tomorrow’s lunch. I got the Patty Melt and saved my half for tomorrow’s lunch as well. We also got their crinkled fries and cheese curds. Which I love to try wherever I see them on a menu. We just finished our lunch & I just had to write this and share with all. I never ever do this and that’s probably why it’s so long. Sorry about that. Did I mention we are elderly.😁 My husband said this was the BEST Philly Cheesesteak he has ever had, outside of Philly. My Patty melt was great as well and full of flavor, cooked perfectly with the grilled onions and of course on the best grilled/toasted bread. The French fries had a great seasoning sprinkled on them and the cheese curds were the real deal. Soooooo, my final comment, I promise, Big Mill’s is GREAT. The service, the food, the welcoming atmosphere, just the best. Big Mill’s will be our go to place for the Philly Cheesesteak and Patty melt but we are going to have to try some of their other sandwiches since they all sound wonderful. Thank you Big Mill’s. Wishing you continued success. A very happy customer.“

“Heard so many good things about this place and finally getting to go was well worth it! The food is amazing. If you are expecting subway, no no no. These Sammies are packed and so well worth it. They even asked if I wanted half of my foot long wrapped up, I get why now. I finished it, but wow. Super think sandwich and great tasting!!! Go a little further down to the bar and get some beer. Great selection for sure and everything from the Sammies to the beer is inexpensive. Cash only to give you heads up but there is an ATM inside. So worth it!!!!“

“Stopped here tonight after our sons baseball game for a quick dinner! It was super clean and all the food looked fresh! The subs were delicious and the guy and girl working were super sweet! Thanks guys! Wish our subway in lake butler was this good!“

“All im gonna say is ,if you haven't tried the Classic Carol Chicken Salad, TRY IT..YOU WILL BE ADDICTED LIKE MY FAMILY IS..I didn't think much of the restaurant name as I drove pass it many time thinking all chicken salad would be the same until I pulled in one day and when I tell you how Great the 🐔 Salad was oh my, My family cant stop eating it and Now I can honestly say All Chicken Salad isn't the same.. we buys pounds of it at a time
.THANK YOU CHICKEN SALAD CHICK FOR THE GREAT TASTE ILL NEVER BUY ANYWHERE ELSE AGAIN..“

“I’ve been coming here many years , but today I ordered a hamburger and when I drove away and finally was able to unwrap it a few moments later it was freezing cold like it just came out of the fridge it literally felt like I picked up an ice cube when I grabbed into my bag to get it . The only thing that was good and made to order were the onion rings I’m very disappointed in this place service recently“

“My service was excellent. The manager (Christy Oliver) herself brought out my food, she went above and beyond in her customer service. The store was clean, as busy as it was it was not chaos, food was made and served promptly. Although I live out of town I frequent this restaurant frequently and have always had EXCELLENT service.“

“One of the best experiences I’ve ever had.
The team is always friendly and upbeat even when it’s busy. They’re quick to fix any mistake (if there ever is one), and you can tell they genuinely care about what they do. Honestly, even when I’m not really craving Subway, I still choose to come here because it just feels good to be around people who love their job and take it seriously. Great service, every time.“

“Was waiting to order across the street at a certain restaurant named after a board game, after nearly half an hour of waiting with just one person ahead of me in the line, I still hadn't been given a chance to order. So I walked across the street to Subway and was in and out with my food within 10 minutes. Overall, I definitely prefer the quick and speedy service, as well as welcoming staff.“

“the cheese steak are almost like Philly“

“I ordered through Uber eats so I can not rate anything but the food at this time. I got the Philly Cheesesteak and it was delicious. The only thing I wished it had was more cheese. But the flavor was awesome, brought me back to the subs I used to eat when I was young and lived in New York.“

“Stopped by on Sept 8th and returned again this week for my lunch. Thank you for a delicious sandwich April and getting the toppings exactly how I like it. Will return again. It's hard to find a good sandwich artist. Quick efficient and tidy.“

“Had THE BEST Jimmy Johns sub from this location. I went looking for an easy dinner and came out with a sub that was the best I've ever had from Jimmy Johns. Don't know what y'all are doing at this location but it is a step above other locations I've been to. Keep it up! Thanks for a great Italiano!“

“Not gonna lie thought food was gonna be some normal kinda subs good and all , but I put in the comments to make both sandwiches saucy and to add jalapeños and they did it perfect 10/10 sub now I know which spot to order from in gainsville good job guys“

“Good experience,...professional crew. Polite & friendly,..Management, Mr. George stepped in to assist w order. I'll come back to this Subway, some of the others around town just wanna get you in & out. If a customer enjoys the staff then they will return. Good location, good people.“

“Andy and Johnathan are the dream team. I order every weekend and a lot of the time they’re flying solo and they operate together seamlessly. Keeping up with orders and engaging with customers while also keeping the line moving. They’re both impressive and invaluable staff, I hope this makes it to their management team, they deserve recognition for their tireless work and positive personalities in what could quickly become overwhelming lines!“