18 Best American Restaurants in Marco Island

“Excellent meal and drinks. Service was top notch too. Highly recommend!“

“It was a beautiful night. The service and food were very good. I couldn’t finish my large meal which is unusual. The Key Lime pie topped off the night - delicious. Overall, it’s a great value. We met some nice people. It’s a must do.“

“Gutes Frühstück in schöner Location. Abends Live Musik und leckere Cocktails.“

“We had a nice time here, though our appetizer of blistered shishito peppers was neither blistered or shishito peppers. We got small red and yellow peppers basically raw with goat cheese sauce. Server did remove it from the check. The rest of our meal was very good Salmon with purple rice and quinoa bowl. Both were very good and nicely prepared Music at the pool was loud but good“

“Everything about this place is just over the top, food, drinks and the staff. Vernell Symonette was amazing!“

“Sea bass out of this world entertainment on a Wednesday out standing“

“Nice sports bar, extensive menu, reasonable prices.“

“Friendly atmosphere and great food“

“Amazing breakfast place! We ate here every day of our vacation. YUMMMMMMM!!!“

“The best place ever great service the best raisin bread in Marco Island 5 stars ⭐️“

“Im not from Florida, just Illinois. Everytime I fly in Ft Myers, we go straight to Michelbob's. My family ordered pulled pork but I tried roast beef. My mind blown. Roast beef/BBQ sauce was out of world. I was having hard time to convince others to order roast beef but they love pulled pork and ribs better. Give a roast beef a try. Its NOT like crummy processed (Arby's) beef at all.“

“We came here for the first time and it was a very good experience. This restaurant was built in the Collier's House. The design is modern and welcoming, the staff very nice and courteous. The food was delicious. Marissa was our bartender. She was great too. I suggest live music, piano or piano ensemble would be great for the ambience since there isn't any like that in the island. We're coming back next week. Congratulations!“

“An awesome spot for breakfast after a morning walk on the beach. Cheery counter staff. Meticulously clean dining area for a beach cafe. Chairs and tables are ample with plenty of shade from the morning sun. Breakfast is fun to have here, but stay away from the scrambled eggs (not sure they are eggs). Others had fried eggs in our group and they were reported to be great. Pancakes are the go to meal here.“

“Every time my family and I visit Maia on Marco Island, it feels like coming home, and that’s entirely thanks to two incredible people: Dolly and Vishal.

Dolly has been our waitress on many visits, and I honestly can’t say enough good things about her. She’s warm, kind, attentive, and always makes us feel like we’re more than just guests, it’s like we’re part of the Maia family. She remembers the little things, checks in at just the right moments, and always greets us with a genuine smile. You can tell she truly cares about making every meal special. It’s rare to find someone who makes service feel so effortless, and Dolly does it every single time.

And then there’s Vishal, the manager, who leads by example and sets the tone for the entire restaurant. He always goes out of his way to stop by our table, ask how we’re doing, and make sure everything is just right. You can tell how much pride he takes in the restaurant and in making sure every guest feels welcomed and well taken care of. It’s that kind of hands-on, heartfelt management that really makes a difference.

The two of them together, Dolly with her incredible warmth and service, and Vishal with his leadership and care. This is a significant reason why we keep coming back. They make every visit memorable, and it’s clear they both go above and beyond not because they have to, but because they genuinely want to.

Please thank Dolly and Vishal for always taking such great care of us!“

“Food was amazing, clean place and people friendly“

“The shrimp BLT was a fabulous sandwich! Enjoyed our lunch! Service was excellent! Thanks“

“Relaxing, delicious food, calming and cooking breeze! Water view eating perfection!“

“Delicious, great service, and good prices!! Highly recommend“