15 Best Pizza Restaurants in Orange Park

“I was walking into hair salon, (around1130am) when i noticed a very young man get out of a grey nissian, he had a CiCi uniforn on, and bottle water in hand. There was trash on ground in front of store. He stopped, picked it up, walked it to trash can and proceeded into restaurant. You don't see this now a days with these younger generations or older folks. Your facility should be proud and thankful to have such a hard working young man, kid who goes way above and beyond. Too think he did this and hadn't even started his shift yet. (From what i gathered, looked like parent dropping him off) This boy should be noticed.“

“100% My favorite pizza in the area!!I live by Doctors Lake & 17 so have to do pick up.Stopped by Friday 12/27 to pick up a few to take home for lunch.Staff was kicking butt and on top of everything!Everyone was really happy to see me come home with the best pizza for lunch!!“

“The food is top quality! Start with the garlic knots & you will be SO satisfied. The Greek pizza is 10/10 and we truly have never had a bad food or service experience in almost a decade of eating here!“

“My 1st time here and it won't be my last ill probably order once a week, I'm from Detroit and miss the food bad but Jets makes up for a lot of it, the deep dish is crispy and absolutely awesome, great job and keep up the good work, We as customers appreciate it.“

“Ordered a pizza with mushroom, pepperoni and cheese, when they realized they were out of mushroom, not only did they deeply apologize, they compensated by replacing the missing mushrooms with whatever topping I wanted, on top of that, gave me and my sister a cookie that was one of the best I've ever had, the two men who handled our situation were nothing but sweethearts, respectful, kind, and fast, as we're walking out we run into the new owner of the joint, he offers to give us a good amount of mushrooms for the pizza and also apologizes for the inconvenience, and even throws in two free cans of soda, I wasn't upset at all since things happen, we can only do so much as humans, this place is absolutely amazing and you should 1000% go and get you some food from them, you will NOT regret it, I didn't, the pizza is top tier, not soggy or greasy or anything you don't want on a pizza, I WILL be coming back for more incredible food and even better customer service, anyone who says anything bad about this place is just outright lying. thank you and your boys Benjamin!!! 🙏🏻🖤 -10/30/25“

“Awesome food!! Best pizza in the area! Love the thin crispy crust!! Will definitely be going back in the near future. Highly recommend. 5 star!“

“I wanted Pizza the other night for dinner, and I realized that we had a pizza food truck at our complex that night. Customer service was 100%, the food tasted spectacular, 10 out of 10! I would highly recommend!“

“We hadn’t had Pizza Hut in a while, so we decided to give it a try again and I’m so glad we did! Both pizzas came out fresh, hot, and absolutely delicious. Honestly, these were probably the best pizzas we’ve had in over two years in the Orange Park area. Everything hit the spot and reminded us why we enjoy coming here. We’ll definitely be back again soon!“

“I just love this place! It reminds me of places I went as a kid except high tech. My kids LOVE it here. It’s a great family outing!“

“Great service.“

“Thank you for going above and beyond to correct a delivery error - and put a smile on your customer's face. Service with a Smile ☺️ and Hot Pizza for the Golden Girls. ❤️🍕

Thanks again!
- Nurse Eunice“

“Angel is an amazing worker genuinely made me feel so taken care of and loved at this store. Honestly he’s an amazing man and is so genuine and friendly and deserves such good things. You all should definitely come and experience how amazing Angel is and how kind his heart is. He will make your day and experience that much better.“

“They have great service and their pizza is our absolute favorite. Unfortunately we will have to stop eating here for now. It has now run through our family faster than taco bell ever could. That's the nicest way I could think to put it. I am unsure of why this is but I only can suspect the use of no gloves when preparing the food and someone forgetting to wash their hands.

I'm still giving a high rating because this place is absolutely awesome. As I said I can only suspect the above reasoning I can not confirm that is the cause. Either way we have to Unfortunately part ways. Hope nothing but the best for this place“

“try it for yourself!!!!💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤“

“My wife and I eat here regularly because the food is great. Our go-to’s are the egg plant Parmesan and the Luca’s special calzone. Can’t forget the always hot and fresh garlic knots. Yummy!“