“My wife and I went here in the first week of January 2024. We're from Fort Lauderdale and I'm working on Sanibel Island. We ordered the Shrimp White Pizza, the Chicken Wings, the Meatloaf, and the NE Clam Chowder to go. The service was excellent and the food was delicious. We got chicken wings from two other places and didn't like either. The wings at Sanibel Grill were awesome.“
“Great dining experience right on the water - great menu selection - great drinks, great view, amazing service!! Everything was great! Our waitress was super!! She had just gotten back from a vacation in Costa Rica.Kid-friendliness: Great kids menu!“
“Food was good but pretty ordinary and pricey for what it was. Didn't have pizza but someone else did and it looked a bit light on cheese. Great spot to hang out and listen to music in the square although the rowdy crowd at the bar were a little loud and made it a challenge to hear the live music.“
Bar & Grill • $$
“Their oysters are consistently fresh, shucked correctly, and quite delicious. Not cheap but totally worth it if you want great raw oysters.4 stars due to the older waitress we’ve had multiple times now; I live close by and used to go quite often. She huffs and puffs, seems irritated by our presence, and has never had any knowledge about the daily raw oysters whatsoever despite it being a straight up oyster bar. Last time we were there was a little over a month ago, and it was only three of us in our party; she literally told us that she was irritated that we ordered cocktails because she had to make them. It was super uncomfortable and awkward.“
“Amazing staff!! The following people made our stay wonderful: FrontDesk people you Rock!! Sasha, Wendy, Michael, Sanna, Kerry (John). In the restaurant we loved the greek yogurt bowl that John would make every day, and the dinner service from Amy and Dominic were spot on. Thanks Michael for your feedback on the little liquor bottles that are for sale, the old fashioned one was definitely the better pick :-) Everybody was so nice and friendly. We would definitely stay here again.“
Bar & Grill • $$
“FAITH AND TITO was amazing tonight the service the food I can tell you the food doesn't come any better than what I had tonight! The man loves his country please visit this place and let him know how much you appreciate him coming to Florida how much you appreciate him being a true American Patriot! See you guys again real soon.“
“Great Place to hangout after the beach. The wings are excellent, atmosphere is exactly what you are looking for in a tropical resort area. The service is amazing especially Skyler she's got it going on definitely knows her stuff they are lucky to have her. Great place for food and drinks highly recommend!“
“First time here, set at the bar I believe the bartender's name was Diane she was very friendly and helpful, we had chicken wings and potato curds, both were excellent and highly recommended we all had beer since it was St Patty's Day. Would definitely come back again.“
“We were there on a Wednesday - “locals night” so there were specials. Food was good. Crab bisque was not as good as the lobster bisque at Ike’s in Minnetonka Mn. (!)- too much thickener (flour?) and that was true of my scallops as well - butter sauce over thickened.We enjoyed the atmosphere and service was great.“
“After trying two different restaurants the day before and being disappointed by both, we decided to keep it safe by getting wings for dinner. It was late and they would be closing soon, but they greeted us and took our order.Our server was really nice and had a big group on the other side of the restaurant, but that didn’t slow down her service. My son and I shared a bucket of wings and fries. Both were crispy the way I like them, and we were not disappointed. We ordered Hot and they were hotter than we’re used to, but still good!We had good wings & fries, great service, and even a mini concert (the group of guys serenaded our server while we were there). It’s a fun place to watch sports with all of the TVs. We will definitely go back when we’re in town.“
“Superb menu of very creative menu items that include fresh fish, shrimp, steak, or chicken. The setting is absolutely beautiful, next to the ocean and the resort pool. Service was friendly and attentive and prompt. Prices are reasonable. This was a very enjoyable sunset dinner. Excellent choice for a great dining experience.“
“I have been coming here for 4 years. The staff and managers are incredible. I feel at home. Jassen and Kylie are fun, engaging, and really make sure we are taken care of! That is why we will keep coming! Every. Single. Week. I am shocked by some of these lower reviews. Some of you should check “
“I really like McGregor Grill! There is a wide variety of very good food, and the interior is cozy and pretty clean. The tables are a bit sticky, and the service is slow only because there are few employees. But if they hire a couple waiters it would be perfect. Try the beef tips quesadilla!“
“Ordered take-out. Got the blackened shrimp platter with seasonal vegetables and chicken sausage jambalaya. It was delicious. The dozen shrimp were cooked perfectly! The seasonal vegetables were good with just the right amount of seasoning. The jambalaya had lots of chicken and andouille sausage. Yum, I will certainly be back before my vacation is over. Service was quick and courteous. Highly recommended!“