5 Best Seafood Restaurants near Sebring

“WCFR rode out from Sarasota 11-1-25 to The Gator Shack, had called early to let them know we were coming. They were beyond ready for us. Great service, amble seating and most of all amazing food. Thank you.“

“If you get Genesis as your server, just know you've already peaked. She didn't just serve our table—she orchestrated a five-star experience like she was conducting a Michelin-star symphony. She somehow knew what we needed before we did, kept us laughing the whole time, and made us feel like the only table in the restaurant.

I'm convinced Genesis could solve world peace between refilling drinks. She deserves Employee of the Century, a parade, and at least three pay raises. If Red Lobster ever lets her go, they'll need to put the restaurant on the endangered species list.

10/10 service. Ask for Genesis if you want your meal to come with a side of elite customer service and good vibes.“

“Ice friendly place to grab a bite to eat, something to wash it down with.“

“My daughter and I were short on time and I didn't want to eat anything too bad for myself so I figured I'd grab a piece of fish from Captain D's in Sebring, a place I hadn’t visited in years.
When I placed my order, I asked for ketchup. They no longer had a self-serve pump and were offering individual packets instead. I casually asked if they had bulk ketchup in the back, and the manager, Kelsey (apologies if I misspelled her name), politely offered to open the packets for me to make it easier. She was sincere and professional, explaining that she aims to keep customers happy because that’s what keeps the business running.
I declined her offer to open the packets, but I appreciated the level of customer service she demonstrated. The interaction was both courteous and memorable.
Overall, the fish was well-cooked, satisfying, and reasonably priced. For anyone looking for a quick, affordable seafood option in Sebring, Captain D’s is worth considering.“

“We had dinner here for the first time last night, and both the food and service were excellent.“