18 Best Italian Restaurants in Tallahassee

Black Radish Bar and Restaurant Bar
1304 N Monroe St Unit B, Tallahassee

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Peanut Butter Icebox Pie
Bubble Potatoes and Grit Cake
Kung Pao Brussel Sprouts
Fried Tofu Lettuce Wraps
Cheese Plate Vegetarian
Orange Olive Oil Cake
Spinach Tortelloni
Vegan Carrot Cake
Bubble Potatoes
Miso Grit Cake

“Highly recommend Black Radish. My husband and I are in town for our anniversary and were lucky enough to find this vegetarian-friendly place. The atmosphere is welcoming and bright, the kitchen is open, and the staff are nice.We ordered the tofu lettuce wraps, bubble potatoes, and sweet potato flautas. Bubble potatoes are light and fluffy with a bang bang (spicy-ish) sauce, flautas were filled with roasted sweet potatoes, and the main dish - the lettuce wraps - were build your own with sides of jalapeno, peanuts, kim chi, mint, cilantro, and sauces. All were delicious!One of the owners, Matthew, stopped by our table to make sure we were having a good experience. Upon finding out it was our anniversary dinner he gave us a dessert of our choice! We had the peanut butter ice box pie - and it was light, airy, chocolatey, and the peanut was present but subtle.We plan to return for dinner tonight to try a few more dishes...and the carrot cake!“

4.7 Superb97 Reviews
IL Lusso Italian • $$$
201 E Park Ave #100, Tallahassee

Customers` Favorites

Truffle Mashed Potatoes
Chocolate Mousse Cake
Roasted Potatoes
Brussels Sprouts
Charred Octopus
Grilled Octopus
Baked Alaska
Crostini
Meatball
Ravioli

“We came for a delayed Valentines dinner. Booked a reservation for 5pm and there was a line at the door waiting for them to open at 4:50pm. A leisurely 2 hour dinner awaited us.They started us off with rosemary foccacia and assorted olives. We were recommended a wine that we ended up loving! So of course we bought a bottle.We basically ordered something from every section of the menu. I started with the Caesar salad (pitiful, skip this) and hubby got the meatball. I should have got the meatball! Man, it was good!We both ordered the prime Delmonico ribeye. Meat quality and temp was perfect. Only thing that could have made it out of this world would have been a little more salt.We both ordered half pastas: the Lobster mezzaluna and the carbonara. Both good, but lackluster compared to the rest of the meal.I finished dinner with a Moscow Mule and he had a sweet tea. Both were Lovely.We shared the crispy Brussel sprouts. ORDER THE DAMN SPROUTS! You're welcome.We ended our meals with dessert. They were no longer serving the crostada which bummed us out, but we were happily surprised with the baked Alaska . That meringue?! Golllly! I opted for the tiramisu. It was exactly how it should be.Service was impeccable“

4.5 Superb90 Reviews
Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza Pizza •
101 N Blair Stone Rd, Tallahassee

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Broc Cappellini
Chicken Parmesan
Pasta Arrabiatta
Pepperoni Pizza
Piesanos Supreme
Chicken Alfredo
Quad Pepperoni
Fried Calamari
Scampi Ravioli
Stuffed Shells

“I've had the opportunity to be at Paisano's a couple of times, and the level of quality is unmatched. I've tried a couple things on the menu and I've never been disappointed with my decisions. It's always a relaxing atmosphere; never too loud or sounding like a library. Even when they were first open, the service itself seemed as if they had been open for a dozen years. I have yet to be disappointed and look forward to the next opportunity I get to return.“

4.5 Superb149 Reviews
Bagigio's Pizza • $$
8954 Woodville Hwy, Tallahassee

Customers` Favorites

Large Pizza Americana
Kids Pepperoni Pizza
Pizza Americana Large
Small Side Salad
Banana Peppers
Marinara Sauce
Lasagna Large
Diavola Pizza
Supreme Pizza
Cheesy Bread

“I’ve lived In Woodville all of my 53yrs and can honestly say that I can’t remember ever enjoying a restaurant in my little town as much as I do here. The atmosphere is warm and friendly every time, the food is amazing every time, the staff and service is top notch every time! ??“

4.5 Superb99 Reviews
Z Bardhi's Italian Cuisine Italian • $$
3596 Kinhega Dr, Tallahassee

Customers` Favorites

Chicken or Veal Parmesan
Baked Lasagne Bolognese
Pan Seared King Salmon
Eggplant Florentine
Cool Banana Pepper
Chicken Parmesan
Stuffed Grouper
Calamari Fritta
Chicken Piccata
Chicken Marsala

“I saw this place one day as I passed by, I asked my husband if we could try it for a different date night. We drove the hour away to eat. Service was great, very prompt. The waiter was very informed in the specialties. Food came out quickly, drinks were amazing, atmosphere was perfect. We will be going back.Parking: Small parking lot and narrow spaces.“

4.4 Superb58 Reviews
Mimi's Table Italian • $$$
1311 Miccosukee Rd, Tallahassee

Customers` Favorites

Cabernet Sauvignon
Vegetarian Lasagna
Pasta Bolognese
Mashed Potatoes
Tuscan Chicken
Seafood Grill
Creme Brulee
Fritto Misto
Apple Tart
Potato Soup

“A Comforting First Visit: Chicken, Green Beans, and Mashed PotatoesOn my first visit to the restaurant, I was drawn to a classic comfort meal: tender chicken seasoned with herbs, crisp green beans, and creamy mashed potatoes. Each dish brought a sense of home to the table, simple yet satisfying.The chicken was juicy and flavorful, the green beans were fresh and perfectly seasoned, and the mashed potatoes were smooth and comforting. This trio wasn’t just food; it felt like a warm welcome, reminiscent of childhood meals.During this visit, I learned about the staff’s kindness through a special story. My wife, during a hospital stay, was offered a taste of the restaurant’s Ratatouille, a gesture that brought her comfort and joy in a tough time. This act of kindness highlighted the restaurant’s commitment to not just great food but also to making a difference in people’s lives.This experience, my first time dining here, reminded me of the simple pleasures of a well-cooked meal and the power of food to bring comfort. I look forward to returning and exploring more of what the restaurant has to offer.“

4.3 Superb65 Reviews
Bella Bella Italian • $$
123 E 5th Ave, Tallahassee

Customers` Favorites

Spinach and Roasted Garlic Ravioli
Grouper with Spinach Risotto
Fettuccine Alfredo
Eggplant Rollatini
Eggplant Parmesan
French Onion Soup
Stuffed Mushrooms
Chicken Parmesan
Sicilian Lasagna
Coconut Shrimp

“I love this small family run Italian restaurant. The Bubble Bread alone is reason to come! The rest of the food will keep you coming back. They always have fresh ingredients and the specials are always intriguing and delicious! My fave is the Braised Short Rib Ravioli. It's so good!“

4.2 Good94 Reviews
Solle's Pizza Pizza • $
4019 Fred George Rd, Tallahassee

Customers` Favorites

Cheese Calzone with Pepperoni and Italian Sausage
Garlic Cheese Bread
Mozzarella Sticks
Pepperoni Pizza
Antipasta Salad
Margherita Pizza
Small White Pie
Fried Mozzarella
Classic Pizza
Meatball Sub

“Pizza like no other the ingredients made the difference the hamburger was incredible the sausage the mushrooms, every ingredient you could taste the difference and this pizza weighs about three times more than a standard pizza. definitely incredible pizza eating experience. I think you’ll be definitely happy with the pizza from here. Thanks Limomike..“

4.2 Good87 Reviews
Tour of Italy Italian • $
3813 N Monroe St Suite 21, Tallahassee

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Bread Dine in: Yes Outdoor seating: Yes Takeout: Yes
Chicken Parmesan Sub
Chicken Parmigiana
Eggplant Parmigiana
Fettuccine Alfredo
Eggplant Lasagna
Chicken Alfredo
Pepperoni Pizza
Fried Calamari
Tour of Italy

“My husband and I dined here while visiting the area for his work. The food was really tasty, the portions were enormous, we had lots of leftovers! The cheesecake was amazing! The servers are super attentive and friendly. Only slight criticism is there is a ton of sauce with every dish, so next time we'll ask for light sauce. But overall, a great dining experience!“

4.1 Good97 Reviews
PrimoHoagies Sandwich Shop • $
1600 W Call St, Tallahassee

Customers` Favorites

Italian Hoagie

“My husband and I shared a medium sharp italian sub and it was perfect. When we left he was wishing we had gotten the 2ft sub to take home. Since we aren't in Tallahassee very often, I'm sure that's what we'll be doing next time.“

4.1 Good44 Reviews
Pizza Hut Pizza • $
1706 Capital Cir NE Ste 103, Tallahassee

Customers` Favorites

Pizza Slice

“I had it delivery and the young woman she was polite cuz I told her that I was going to give her a tip and I did give her a text but I asked her she if she had change for a $10 bill but she didn't have it.Next time I'll get change for the big bills next time.“

4.3 Superb16 Reviews
Carrabba's Italian Grill Italian • $$
2779 Capital Cir NE, Tallahassee

Customers` Favorites

Tuscan Grilled Sirloin with Garlic Aioli
Mama Mandola's Sicilian Chicken Soup
Garlic Mashed Potatoes
Cannoli Cake for Two
Fettuccine Carrabba
Shrimp and Scallops
Sausage Lentil Soup
Fettuccine Alfredo
Chicken Parmigiana
Grilled Asparagus

“Sangria Event was awesome. The food, the service and management was stellar. Michelle impressed us with her smile and service. The young lady was taking 6, 8 and 10 wine ? glasses on a tray at one time. She loves her job. Also, David, the manager, Kevin, Alec, and Dakota are too sweet and always taking care of the customers. Great service.“

4 Good135 Reviews
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant Italian • $
1103 Apalachee Pkwy, Tallahassee

Customers` Favorites

Shrimp Alfredo Fettuccine Alfredo Tossed with Saut
Spaghetti & Meatballs
Salad and Breadsticks
Strawberry Cheesecake
Spinach-Artichoke Dip
Eggplant Parmesan
Mozzarella Sticks
Chicken Parmesan
Seafood Alfredo
With Meat Sauce

“Nice atmosphere food was great!!! Went 4.5 and had a great time. Had eggplant parm replaced pasta with brocolli. My son and daughter picked one of the stuff she'll entréesVegetarian options: Very good options far as soup and you can always request sauces etc in the side“

4 Good114 Reviews
Little Italy Italian • $
111 S Magnolia Dr #17, Tallahassee

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Cutlet Alla Parmigiana
Spaghetti with Meatballs
Linguine with Clam Sauce
Linguine Alla Carbonara
Spaghetti Meatballs
Fettuccine Alfredo
Zuppa Del Giorno
Meatball Sandwich
Chicken Marsala
Country Chicken

“How have I never been here? It's so cute and the food was surprisingly good. Perfectly cooked, lightly breaded calamari and the coffee flavor in the tirimasu was a chefs kiss. The main dishes were delicious but you can only mess up pasta so badly, the other things you can ruin and they blew them out if the park.“

4 Good99 Reviews
Riccardo's Restaurant Italian • $
1950 Thomasville Rd # G, Tallahassee

Customers` Favorites

Eggplant Parmigiana with Spaghetti
Bruschetta Appetizer Small
Penne with Meatballs
Chicken Parmigiana
Meat Tortellini
Baked Spaghetti
Pepperoni Pizza
Antipasto Salad
Veal Parmigiana
Garlic Butter

“Super yummy casual place for very reasonably priced classic Italian food. A Tallahassee staple with a long history of reliably good inexpensive carb fixes. Everything is tasty. Don't miss the bread! And come early or make a reservation because the place fills up fast!“

4 Good83 Reviews
Village Pizza & Pasta Italian • $
1400 Village Square Blvd #33, Tallahassee

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Rolls with Garlic Butter & Parmigiana
Garlic Cheese Bread
Mozzarella Sticks
Chicken Diablo
Supreme Pizza
Meatball Sub
Garlic Knots
Caesar Salad
Greek Salad
Baked Ziti

“We were visiting Tallahassee and had dinner there with our friends. Excellent food. I had the meat ravioli. They were tasty, firm, and not watery. Ravioli can be hard to cook. Most other places were I've had this dish over cook them. Anyways, this is a great place.“

4 Good66 Reviews
Isabella's Pizzeria Napoletana Pizza • $
799 W Gaines St #101, Tallahassee

Customers` Favorites

Prosciutto E Arugula
Large Cheese Pizza
Margherita Pizza

“I can't express just how remarkable Isabella's truly is. It's not merely a restaurant; it's a sanctuary where every dish is crafted with care, every interaction is steeped in warmth, and every moment feels like a genuine connection. Recently, we held an intimate going-away gathering for a cherished family member, and Isabella's played a pivotal role in making it unforgettable. Drawing from our deep-rooted love for food cultivated during our years in Pordenone, Italy, we placed our trust in Isabella's to deliver an experience worthy of our heartfelt celebration. And they exceeded our expectations in every way. Despite the logistical challenge of delivery through a third-party service, Isabella's didn't just deliver pizzas; they delivered an abundance of love and thoughtfulness. After leaving a special note via the delivery app, I called to convey the significance of the occasion and to ask if they could make it extra special. What happened next touched our hearts in ways we never expected. Isabella's took the time to infuse each pizza box with personalized messages, each one a testament to the deep connection they forge with their patrons. These heartfelt gestures not only moved our family member to tears but also served as a source of comfort and strength as they embarked on a new chapter in life. For that moment of pure kindness and the profound sense of love, appreciation, and community they foster, my family and I will be forever grateful to Isabella's. In all my years, I've never encountered a restaurant that embodies such unwavering dedication to its patrons and the community it serves. Amore Mio, S.“

4 Good62 Reviews
Marco's Pizza Pizza • $
209 N Magnolia Dr, Tallahassee

Customers` Favorites

Build Your Own Large Pizza
Its a Half and Half Pizza
Old World Pepperoni
Supreme Pizza
White Cheezy
Cheezybread

“Got, delicious pizza and fast service.Vegetarian options: You can make anything vegetarian with meat toppings here. Great food selectionsParking: Parking in front and accessible parking all around freeKid-friendliness: Not large inside but has a few tables n chairs n large booth. Was great for my familyWheelchair accessibility: Yes“

4 Good37 Reviews
Loading...
map Map