18 Best Pizza Restaurants in Athens

Emmy Squared Pizza: Athens, Georgia Pizza •
199 Prince Ave, Athens

Customers` Favorites

Detroit Style Deep Dish Pizza
Brussels Sprouts Salad
Chicken Parm Sandwich
Seasoned Waffle Fries
Cheesy Garlic Sticks
Margherita Pizza
Burger and Fries
Chopped Italian
Emily Burger
Caesar Salad

“The food was phenomenal! My only complaint is there were no additional drink options for my toddler other than apple juice, lemonade would be a great option! The staff were amazing and so polite! Our waitress, Shali, was awesome and very patient! Overall, some of the best pizza we have ever had!“

4.4 Superb109 Reviews
Pizza Factory Pizza • $$
122 Alps Rd Unit A, Athens

Customers` Favorites

Western BBQ Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Hawaiian Pizza
Supreme Pizza
Dinner Salad
Cinnastix
Wings
All

“My family stopped here after my daughter's cheer competition with her teammates and we were not disappointed! We ordered the artichoke and garlic pizza that is made with their homemade ranch and it was so good that we ordered an extra large to go before we left! My daughter got an everything pizza, which comes LOADED with every topping. The price is comparable to some of the more well-known pizza chains, but the quality and quantity of food you get here is well above those other places. If you're a local, this NEEDS to be your regular pizza joint. The atmosphere is top-notch and the staff make you feel right at home. The owner, Diane, is not just the owner. She is also a member of the hard-working and friendly staff. The kids enjoyed watching the Georgia game while playing foosball, Jenga, and arcade games. We'll be stopping in every time we're in town from now on!“

4.4 Superb83 Reviews
Fully Loaded Pizza Kitchen Pizza • $$
1255 S Milledge Ave, Athens

Customers` Favorites

Thai One on Pizza Without Chicken
My Big Fat Greek Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Basket of Tots
Specialty Slice
Chicken Wings
Garlic Knots
Sauce
Salad
Pesto

“My husband and I come often for some pizza and drinks, and the star of FLP, the garlic knots!! I never thought of leaving a review before but after doordashing and order for pick-up and it somehow not being processed, I was absolutely pleased with the customer service and how they responded to this phantom order mishap. Love this vibrant, friendly place all the more!“

4.3 Superb65 Reviews
Automatic Pizza Pizza • $
1397 Prince Ave, Athens

Customers` Favorites

Build Your Own Pizza
Meat Lover
Slice

“CALL BEFORE YOU GO! We waited over an hour for our large pizza on a Friday night but it was super delicious (we got the margarita)!!! It’s not a sit down restaurant so you can order ahead and then eat the pizza there-wish we would have done that. It is faster service when ordering single slices.“

4.3 Superb59 Reviews
Cicis Pizza Pizza • $
3190 Atlanta Hwy Ste 22A, Athens

Customers` Favorites

Salad and Various Pizzas from the Bar
Pizza from the Bar and Cinnamon Roll
Macaroni and Cheese Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Assorted Pizza Slices
Create Your Own Pizza
Salad Buffet Pizza
Cheese Pan Pizza
Spinach Alfredo
Cinnamon Rolls

“I LOVE CICIS PIZZA!! I wish I could come here everyday. The young enthusiastic man that greeted me at the door with a warm and welcoming,” Welcome to Cicis!” needs a raise!! (IMMEDIATELY) his customer services skills are unparalleled. when my friend was looking around for her favorite pizza and it wasn’t out yet he shared her concern and offered to make it if it wasn’t being made already (it was because Cicis pizza is always on top of everything). As if his empathy wasn’t enough to fill our hearts, he went above and beyond to personally deliver her four slices of her favorite pizza so our stomach would full too! I am so passionate about the Cicis manager recognizing such an astonishing individual that I am writing this in Cicis Pizzeria while munching on my Mac and cheese pizza (which is the best pizza) GO DAWGS!! ???“

4.4 Superb43 Reviews
Newk's Eatery Pizza • $
1850 Epps Bridge Pkwy #109, Athens

Customers` Favorites

Sandwich
Soups
Salad
Pizza

“Went here on 9-7-23, first time going to Newks for lunch, I had a great experience! The food was great and the service was great and staff was friendly and professional, I will be definitely be coming back! Thank you Newts for a awesome experience and great food,!??Parking: Plenty of parking.“

4.2 Good37 Reviews
Peppino's Pizzeria Pizza • $
950 Whitehall Rd, Athens

Customers` Favorites

Sicilian Pizza Slice with Pepperoni
Peppinos Special Pizza 18
Calzone with Pepperoni
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Pizza by the Slice
Meat Lovers Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Antipasto Salad
Veggie Pizza
Pizza Ever

“Ya'll go there!!! It's a hidden gem in the countryside of Athens, Ga. The veggie pizza I had was so delicious! I will be back with my daughter and Grandson soon. Thank you all for preparing my pizza on Thursday Feb 29th. And thank you Patrick Mercardante for the invite.Peppino's Pizzeria another favorite dine-in or dine-out restaurant of mine, I highly recommend.“

4 Good53 Reviews
Amici at The Falls American • $$
8851 Macon Hwy Suite 501, Athens

Customers` Favorites

Spinach Artichoke Dip
Lunch Special Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Sub
Pepperoni Pizza
Margarita Pizza
Mixed Greens
Blonde Greek
blt Wedge
Calzone
Hummus

“There was barely any wait time for service and I was ordering to go and decided to stay and they quickly helped me do that. Sitting by the falls was my sanity this place should be packed for lunch and dinner because it's the only place where I can feel like I'm experiencing the outdoors while eating since there is a waterfall and the food is good although the portion size is a bit small but I have a big appetite.“

4 Good52 Reviews
Ted's Most Best Pizza • $$
254 W Washington St, Athens

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Cake Pops
Table Service
Baby Calzone
Meatballs
Pizzas

“Ted's is a good option in Athens on game day. Somewhat inconspicuous, we slipped in & ordered while flashier nearby spots had hour-long waits. We were eating within 10 minutes. I'd say it was at about 75% capacity. Good pizza & beer. Meat lovers, get the La Carne. Wife & daughter liked their veggie pizzas. They have eat-outside options if weather is nice, so we did.“

3.9 Good63 Reviews
Athens pizza Pizza • $$
2095 S Milledge Ave, Athens

Customers` Favorites

Meat Lover's Pizza
Mozzarella Sticks
Cheese Bread
The Athenian
Pizza Deluxe
Greek Salad
Baked Ziti
Fries
Wings
Halal

“One star for ambiance - this is definitely a take-out place! However, as our 1st visit, we dined in. Sparse furnishings - we asked for salt and pepper - they had to get them from the kitchen. We ordered onion rings for an appetizer - standard institutional heavy breaded rings. Now, where this place shines is the pizza! We ordered the delux, crust not too thin, not too thick, and great texture. All ingredients tasted fresh. The sauce was delicious and the vegetables and meats were just right! The cheese was fantastic and plenty of it. The next visit will be takeout - some of the best pizza in Athens!“

3.9 Good61 Reviews
Mellow Mushroom Athens Pizza • $$
320 E Clayton St, Athens

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Build Your Own Calzone
Holy Shiitake Pie
Pepperoni Pizza
Pretzel Bites
House Special
Cheese Pizza
Bruschetta
Pretzels
Wings

“This is as my first time at a mellow mushroom but I’ve always heard good things about them. I chose to celebrate my 40th here with family. Aside from parking, I was very pleased with my experience. The food is fairly priced and they even have vegan options. As a new vegan, for health, I picker here because of the miss mushroom pizza on the menu. It was way better than I expected. The bartender was super sweet and attentive while we were waiting for our party. Our server was also beyond sweet, kind and attentive. They didn’t even come at us when we family brought in my birthday cake or my boyfriend gave me his gift which was a small cake when you opened paper butterflies popped out everywhere! And we were a bit much rewinding then up and having the paper butterfly’s fly in the restaurant, sorry about that! Mix a celebration, alcohol and flying toys, you’re asking for trouble. I even thanked our server by giving her one and I feel horrible I don’t remember her name. Thank you for making my 40th memorable. We will be coming out here again.“

3.8 Good86 Reviews
Newk's Eatery Pizza • $$
700 Baxter St Suite 200, Athens

Customers` Favorites

Sandwiches
Half Salad
Newk

“Sandwich (avocado and turkey)was ok, bread could have been toasted more. Mac and cheese was good. Counter service was personable and efficient ( it was honestly the best part). I came around 6:30 on 11-21 and was helped by a pleasant young lady with curly blond hair. Overall it was a good experience punctuated by exemplary customer service.“

4 Good37 Reviews
Little Italy Pizzeria Pizza • $
125 N Lumpkin St, Athens

Customers` Favorites

Calzone Canadian Bacon Sausage and Cheese and Sausage Pizza
Over an Inch Thick Crust on NY Style Pizza
18 Extra Pepperoni and Extra Sauce
Pepperoni Pizza by the Slice
Thin Crust Cheese Pizza
Cheese Pizza Slice
Pitcher of Beer
Meat Stromboli
Italian Sub
Meat Pizza

“food was AMAZINGGGG. I ate it and it was so buss got more a lot of pizza which was so worth it. The service was great, it was our first time here and the nice man who took our order was super attentive and helpful with with how it worked and answered our questions, even joked with us which made the whole experience more enjoyable and the place is super chill, laid back, and authentic, would definitely recommend and come again; wish i lived in athens just to be able to come again !“

3.7 Good88 Reviews
Papa Johns Pizza Pizza • $
3620 Atlanta Hwy Suite 100, Athens

Customers` Favorites

Ultimate Pepperoni Pizza
Cheese Pizza

“Thankful. My daughter and I have a dairy allergy. The only place we go for pizza. Delicious and always prepared correctly for us. I do wish that if you order a second topping, like mushrooms, they minimize your first topping. That's kinda frustrating. Especially since I'm having them not add cheese. But still pay full price.“

3.9 Good33 Reviews
DePalma's Italian Cafe Italian • $$
401 E Broad St, Athens

Customers` Favorites

Bread and Dipping Oil
Cheesey Breadsticks
Goat Cheese Ravioli
Seafood Charmaine
Stuffed Mushrooms
Chicken Parmesan
Chicken Alfredo
Pasta DePalma
Ceasars Salad
Caesar Salad

“I visited DePalma's for a work dinner, and the experience did not disappoint. Service was on point, especially for a slightly large party. At 5 p.m., the restaurant wasn't busy, and we were seated immediately. Our meals came out in a timely fashion. I had the lasagna, which was delicious. My only wish was for a larger portion size. I'd definitely return.“

3.6 Good99 Reviews
Amici Athens Pizza • $$
233 E Clayton St, Athens

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken
Basket of Fries
Pizza
Wings

“Stopped on Amici while in. Athens GA. Good pub food. Tried the BB Black Chocolate Stout which I enjoyed. They have 12 other beers on tap. Had the combo meal of one slice of pizza and 4 wings. Added anchovies to the slice. The loved the texture of the crust which was crispy when folded and the cheese didn't fall off. Wings were also very good.“

3.6 Good67 Reviews
D.P. Dough Pizza • $
180 W Broad St, Athens

Customers` Favorites

Italian Calzone with Marinara Sauce
Make Your Own Calzone
Homemade Cookies
Chocolate Chip
Garlic Butter
Italian Zone
Buffer Zone
Cheesy Tots
Cheese Stix
Combat Zone

“Amazing food! Quick! If you’re in a hurry they have ready now calzones sometimes to where you get one ready ! Amazing side options and desserts, too!They have many great options, late delivery and open until 4am!! Definitely try the buffer calzone sooooo“

3.6 Good67 Reviews
Chuck E. Cheese Pizza • $$$
3654-I Atlanta Hwy, Athens

Customers` Favorites

A Topping to Your Large Pizza for 2
Pizzas & Wings Combo
Giant Cheesy Bread
Large Cheese Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Goodie Bags

“So impressive with the food, service and the awesome games. It was super clean and everyone was so polite and nice. You could tell the employees love their job and the customers. I was shocked at the food because I thought the pizza would just be ok but to my surprise it was wonderful! We will be back!!!“

3.6 Good54 Reviews
Loading...
map Map