50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Lincolnshire

“Great, authentic Italian cuisine. Never disappoints.“

“I've driven by the place for a year and kept thinking I should drop in. Finally stopped for a slice last month, and went back to try their smash burger just recently.

Love the place. They have excellent food and a kicky little interior, but I loved chatting with the owner as he made my food. One of the owners, at least. Anyway, curious to try their other offerings, and happy to meet a local small business owner and find them to be just good people. To me, that has more impact than the menu. But the menu is worth the trip, all the same!

I know the owner reads these reviews, so I say thank you for your excellent efforts. It's not a small thing to feed strangers food made with care and love, and it matters to some of us when we see it. Nothing but the best to you, my friend.“

“Modern Italian Restaurant with great service and food.“

“This was the best calzone I have ever had, it was a good size for large, they were very generous with the toppings, and the tiramisu was to die for. The staff was very kind, overall if I could give them more than 5 stars I would, it was EXTREMELY DELICIOUS!!!!! Would highly recommend.“

“Best pizza in town hands down“

“We had a great time at Old City Pizzeria & Sports Bar! Everything we ordered was fresh and really delicious. The pizza was excellent, the appetizers were great, and the portions were very generous. The atmosphere is comfortable and welcoming, and the service was friendly and attentive. We really enjoyed our evening here. Thank you guys for the great food and hospitality! We’ll definitely be back. Highly recommend! 🍕👏“

“PaliPali Pizza never disappoints! The pizza is always hot, cheesy, and loaded with flavor. 🍕🔥 I also love how generous they are with toppings, and the portions are perfect for sharing. Their customer service is excellent, and the whole experience feels smooth from order to delivery. Definitely my go-to spot whenever I’m craving pizza!“

“Delicious Mexican food and creative cuisine.“

“Jet’s Pizza isn’t just pizza for me — it’s a love story. ❤🍕

I love it so much I could eat it three times a day, 365 days a year and still never get tired of it! The pizza is always fresh, cheesy, crispy, and full of flavor. Every bite feels like comfort and happiness.

The staff are always friendly, welcoming, and make you feel at home. The ambiance is warm and relaxing, making the whole experience even better.

Some people fall in love with a person… I think I fell in love with Jet’s Pizza“

“Not only is the food delicious but the owners, employees are super friendly. You are welcome to dine in or if you are in a hurry, you can always pick up a large slice of pizza with a drink. All super tasty 😋“

“Have been going to Pavia for about a yr. Started going to Tuesday night trivia & had a blast! The owner & his staff are so nice. The food is awesome, especially the meatballs! Great upper level for a party!“

“We dined in tonight. The staff was friendly and helpful and the food was amazing. Will definitely stop in again next time we are in town.“

“Pizza was delicious and was delivered hot!“

“Good thin crust and good ingredients, cooked perfect“

“Fausto’s always has amazing food! Had dinner with family there tonight! Everything was fantastic! The food is homemade and is delicious!“

“Our pizza arrived quickly and cooked perfectly. We love Maciano’s! They used the best ingredients-quality cheese, great crust and the Italian sausage is wonderful!!“

“I ordered a square pizza consisting of four pieces. It was a deep-dish pizza and the appearance is debatable. But the taste convinced me, because the pizza with extra jalapenos was really delicious! You even could refine the preparation of the crust in terms of flavor, so I decided to have garlic in the dough, which was very good. I made my order through a third-party app that had a promo, which means pay one, get two. All in all, I was very satisfied with the value for money of my order.“

“We sort of fell upon Joanie's when we went to the Strawberry Festival in Long Grove and it was the star attraction for all of us!!! My husband and I had the most delicious salad that we completely devoured in record time along with that mouthwatering cheesy pizza that we ordered along with it!!! My Mom and Aunt ordered the chicken and Mom commented...."Now that's the way chicken is supposed to be made!!!" They were served a large tray with 4 LARGE pieces of chicken, potatoes, and long buns!!! They took half of it home and had it for dinner tonight!!! But the piece de resistance was the hot homemade strawberry rhubarb pie with vanilla ice cream that seriously 4 of us shared!!!! Wow!!! What a treat!!! Oh... and....Our meals were served Hot....not cold....HOT...out of the oven.....again, the way a meal should be served! HOT!!! ha ha ha...The ambience was fun and the view of the water from our vantage point was just breathtaking!!! Our server Derrick was such a nice young man! He was professional, made certain that we were ok, and went back and forth many times for those extra things that we needed for our meal!!! I'm certain that it was very hectic for all of the servers during the fest, but they handled the crowds so well!!! Again, we were just thrilled to have stumbled on Joanie's!!! It's worth going back for seconds, thirds, fourths....etc....ha ha ha“

“This place has best beefs and chicken parmigiana in area. Sauce very good worth every dollar.“

“Always consistent quality pizza!“

“Delivery was fast and hot. I got the pan pizza and the crust was perfect.“

“We order from here 1-3 times a week for lunch at my shop and dinner at home. The food is always fantastic, delivery is fast and the staff are very friendly and helpful. We've also gotten catering before too and that service was fantastic. Night driver Scott is awesome too!“

“Pizza 🍕 great!!!! My kids love this pizza“

“There’s nothing better than Lou’s! So accommodating for large groups and excellent service! We came for a college send off and the food, like always, is outstanding! Perfect send-off until they return Thanksgiving! ❤️“

“Absolutely love this restaurant. We had brought a tray of lasagna to a party years ago and had nothing but rave reviews. We moved down to FL 7 years ago so it’s been awhile since we have been able to eat here. We bought another tray of lasagna this weekend for a party. Let me tell you…it was so delicious! We are still hearing people rave about it and hope it brings new customers your way. Your GF ravioli was awesome as well. Great food, wonderful customer service, cute restaurant. Now we just need a location opened in SWFL! We will be back and we will always highly recommend this place. Thank you!“

“Excellent food and friendly staff with great prices!“

“We were in town for a convention and staying at a hotel. We decided to order a pizza our last night there. We chose Joe's at random, and we were not disappointed. Our order was delivered promptly by a very nice, and courteous person. The pizza we ordered was delicious. We loved everything about it -the thin crust, delicious sauce (not too much), and generous amount of cheese. I especially liked that the toppings were under the cheese, and there were herbs!! Kuddos to Joe's for great food and friendly service!!“

“Not only was this location able to time a delivery to accommodate a train’s brief stop at the Metra station, the pizza seemed to have come right out of the oven. Fantastic food and service to match!“

“Excellent Chicago-style deep-dish pizza. The crust was perfectly baked, the sauce had great flavor, and the pizza was loaded with cheese and toppings exactly as a good deep dish should be. Everything tasted fresh, and it was exactly what we were hoping for when looking for authentic Chicago pizza. Definitely one of the highlights of our trip.“

“This restaurant is beautiful inside with chandeliers and nice tables and chairs I really enjoyed the fried calamari we had as a appetizer. The Lasagna is wonderful! The cannolis are so delicious too! Antonio our server was outstanding and goes out of his way to make it a enjoyable experience. Thank you Salvatore for your kindness! I highly recommend them for a delicious dinner!“

“The atmosphere was great, and the staff is great. Although the pizza was tasty it was over cooked/done. This was our first time at this Barnaby's location, but we'll give it another try in a couple of weeks. Next Barnaby's in Arlington Heights.“

“. Good Food The Italian sub was delicios Good Food The Italian sub was delic They are too expen though“

“Wonderful friendly staff and great pizza, the wings were also excellent. Great draft beer choices too!“

“The pizza is so delicious. The right amount of sauce and cheese. My boys love the pasta and meatballs. Keep up all the great work Little Joey's.“

“Pizza is amazing here! I just had an issue with Door dash and had to call in. You can hear they are obviously gearing up for lunch and just opened but the lady took the time to make sure the order was perfect. Didn’t rush nobody and turned an issue into a positive. The staff is always awesome here. Great pizza and people“

“Jetz Pizza never disappoints! The pizza was fresh, hot, and full of flavor. Everything was made just right, and the service was friendly and fast. You can tell they care about making good food. Definitely worth trying if you haven’t been here yet! 🍕🔥“

“Just tried magys pizza and let me tell you guys it was so so good I had the ribs and they are one of the best that’s I have ever tried pizza was really good and they have amazing desserts we will definitely come back oh yes by the way hubby had carne asada fries not sure if they are I. The menu but just ask for them they are the best thanks Juan’s and rocio best of luck to both of you“

“We held a family funeral lunch at Lino’s. The staff was welcoming, attentive and very friendly as they took care of our party, which filled their banquet room. We had a couple of chicken dishes, a couple of vegetable dishes, a garden salad, potatoes, and cannoli for dessert. Our guests raved about the food, which was delicious and hot! We could not be more enthusiastic in our recommendation of Lino‘s!“

“We tried this pizza place last night and were not disappointed!! Delicious!!! We have always been a Lou Malnati’s fan but wanted to try a smaller business. WE WILL DEFINITELY BE BACK!!!“

“I absolutely love Pizza Bella! Hands down my favorite pizza in all of Chicagoland! (yes, I said it and it's true) Overjoyed with Tony's new restaurant!!.... Great service, atmosphere, friday night was packed so come early! Evey inch of the menu is fantastic, and huge portions! True Italian love!“

“Everything about this place is awesome. The service, the speed, and most importantly, the food. Everytime I've ordered from here, the pizza is hot and tastes amazing. While there's no indoor seating, the service is faster here than in other places in the area if you order pick up or delivery.

Plus, I love how for every pizza you get, you get a card. You collect 10 of those cards, and you get a pizza (ANY size or toppings) for half off! Northshore is seriously one of the best pizza places I've done business with. I highly recommend them if you're in the area!“

“This place is such an awesome vibe, Marc was serenading me with some singing and it was amazing.. the Panino was amazing I got a BBQ chicken one and for my first time walking into a new place this place was so welcoming and amazing.. keep up the great work guys.. definitely a spot to check out..“

“Best pizza, and a good price“

“I had a wonderful experience ordering from this pizza place! 🍕😊 The person who answered the phone was incredibly friendly, patient, and took the time to make sure my order was exactly right. He even let me know ahead of time that delivery might take a little longer, which I really appreciated. 👍 When I called back to add a few more items, he updated my order without any hassle and remained just as kind and professional. ❤️ Our food arrived hot, fresh, and absolutely delicious! The pizza was perfectly cooked, full of flavor, and worth the wait. Excellent customer service combined with great food makes this a place I'll definitely order from again. Highly recommended! 👏✨“

“My previous review was accidentally deleted by me, but let me just say that this is by far the best bar around the Chicagoland area. Firstly, let me start by raving about Colleen, the GOAT of bartenders! She is an absolute sweetheart! From the first day she made me feel at home! If you are new, she goes up to you, introduces herself and hands you a napkin. She has the most awesome and proper etiquette for the hospitality industry. Colleen is an absolute godsend! I do not know a single person who badmouths her. She also makes the best margaritas and rums/cokes! She remembers your name as wel and starts calling you by your name on the second day. The other bartenders are amazing as well. On Tuesdays and Thursdays when I go in, Lisa remembers my drink and food order. She is also a gem as well! As far as the food goes, the chicken bacon ranch wrap is one of the best I have ever eaten. The Cheddar Cheese burger is amazing as well. Seriously this place is a great find. As far as the reviews calling this place racist are concerned, to each their own: I have never had any issues and I am disabled and asian that is like a double negative. It is the most inclusive place around town!“

“We’ve had the pleasure of eating at Pappi’s for many years. The food is always fresh and delicious abd the owners are truly wonderful people. Can’t say enough good things!“

“When I tell you I love pizza but when we tasted the food. We had fried mushrooms, sweet chili wings, and a pizza talking about delicious omg hands down the best, when we visit again, we will be back. From st.louis/ cahokia keep up the good work, service was great as well“

“i love this place. i’ve been going since i was a little kid with my grandparents. very good pizza!!! everyone is so friendly. my grandparents knew the owners :)“

“Good variety of food and beverages. Classic deep dish pizza. Love the cookie skillet for desert. Wow.“