13 Best Pizza Restaurants in Northbrook

“Good thin crust and good ingredients, cooked perfect“

““Barnaby’s of Northbrook delivers that Neighbor Proof–level consistency with real local trust that Northern Illinois families have counted on for decades.” The food comes out hot, the service is steady, and the atmosphere feels like a true community anchor. Their pizza has that classic, reliable flavor you expect every single time, and the team moves with the kind of confidence that only comes from years of doing things the right way. It’s the kind of place where you see real stories play out — families, regulars, and neighbors all sharing the same dependable experience. A Northbrook staple that continues to earn its reputation.“

“Best pizza in town.“

“Fantastic addition to Northbrook…dine in or carry out, food is consistently delicious!“

“One of many pizza joints that I made a list of wanting to try at least 2 years prior but I finally made it in this past March and was quite pleased with the quality of food here.

We just got done roaming around Northbrook Court and our typical outing when I'm off work is dinner away from the mall then dessert for the boys.

The food overall is pretty good here and obviously the pizza is the highlight, we went with NY style XL pizza and we liked it. The menu overall has some familiar Italian bites at reasonable prices.

Good food, clean dining area and friendly service in a cozy setting, would definitely return if ever in the area. We live pretty far north in Beach Park in northeastern Lake Co but a high number of wknds we usually end up somewhere in northern Cook Co.

I always strive to support local and hope for years of continued boomin' business for the owner(s).🍕“

“If I could give more than 5 stars, I absolutely would. This pizzeria is the definition of quality and care from the very first bite to the very last. You can immediately tell how fresh everything is — from the dough that’s clearly made fresh daily, to the vibrant, flavorful sauce that tastes like it’s crafted from the ripest tomatoes, to the cheese that’s so fresh it practically melts in your mouth. Every ingredient bursts with authenticity and flavor, and it all comes together in the most perfect pizza you could ask for.

On top of the amazing food, the staff here deserve just as much credit. They’re welcoming, attentive, and genuinely care about making sure you have the best experience possible. It feels like they treat every order, big or small, with the same level of pride and respect.

What really sets this place apart though is the convenience. Their late-night delivery is an absolute lifesaver, especially with no delivery charge and no minimum order — something you rarely see anymore. It’s thoughtful touches like that which make me not only a satisfied customer, but a loyal one.

This isn’t just another pizza spot — it’s a place that goes above and beyond. Freshness, flavor, great people, and unbeatable service. Easily my go-to for pizza, any day of the week.“

“3.99 pizza and soda lunch special is fire. For a reason their pizza tastes better than most locations.“

“amazing food and awesome staff!!“

“Ordered a couple of personal deep dish pizzas, and they were out of this world! Wonderful crust, sausage was perfect, lots of gooey cheese and the sauce was heaven. Super friendly staff that got us all the fixings we needed as we were taking it back to the hotel. Heavenly pizza!“

“Excellent service, amazing food. Gelato is incredible! :) Very nice people there, too! Will definitely return!“

“The service and food are amazing! CPK in Northbrook is a great location the service and management customer service is the best! Thank you CPK for participating and partnering with make a wish to make wishes celebration for the children and their families an unforgettable experience. It is to donors like you that we can celebrate 🎉 wishes with meals and making their wishing experience go to another level. Thank you from Make a Wish of Illinois. Yesenia Presley Wish Granter“

“Food and service were great. Got several appetizers, including sausage and peppers, which weren't even on the menu. The veal chop was delicious and huge; and the cannoli was the perfect way to end the meal.

My only complaint was the spacing of the tables. Because the dining room is so small, they stack the tables on top of each other. All night our chairs were banging against the people behind us, making trips to the restroom a difficult task. Even with this, I'd go back in a heartbeat.“

“I have gotten 3 pizzas in the last month from your store that you manage in northbrook on Waukegan and Dundee (I believe it’s store #2886).

Every time I’ve come in there’s been someone named Nadal working. I have a broken foot and he asks how I’m doing and is just generally really nice. He stands out in my life as someone who is kind and caring and I appreciate him a lot. I wanted to send you an email to let you know he’s an amazing worker and goes above and beyond every time I’m there. I really appreciate what he does and how kind he is. Plus he makes a dang good pizza!

Thanks Nadal!!!“