50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Winnetka

“Fresh and delicious attention to detail. Just had a deep dish pizza with red onion and yellow peppers. Perfect balance of flavors.“

“We stopped today as a family for pizza before hitting up all the Home Alone sites. The pizza was incredibly delicious! The staff were friendly and the building itself was small and cozy. Fast service too! The neighborhood is delightful as well! Would absolutely stop again when in the area.“

“Has to be the best pizza I have tried in awhile. Just tried yesterday and had the meat pizza. With garlic dip AMAZING!!! Will try all there other pizza, sides, and deserts.“

“Visited their new Lakeview location this past Thursday, and timed it right so my Pizza was ready right after the Cubs game ended. It was only a 15 minute walk to the restaurant. First time ever eating Milly's and I will definitely be back! Customized my own pizza with Pepperoni, Sausage and Ricotta cheese. Opening the box for the first time, this pie looked perfect. Generous amount of toppings, beautiful caramelized crust. First bite was nice and crispy and the entire pizza was full of flavor. I sat in one of their booths and ate half the pizza there! The staff was super friendly also, both guys were talking to me about the history of the company, and you could tell how passionate they were about making these pizzas. I will definitely be back again!“

“I tried the pizzas last night. We had 4 different kinds and they were honestly soooo delicious! Can’t wait for you to open! This is GREAT pizza!!!“

“Was excited to finally try this neighborhood gem. An excellent choice for my birthday dinner. The arancini were phenomenal! Can’t wait to come back.“

“We always look forward to takeout (during COVID) and look forward to seeing you in person. Pizza is always fantastic!!! Always!“

“We're from out of town and stopped in for dinner after visiting a nearby museum and our pizza was delicious. The staff is extremely friendly and took excellent care of us. Cannoli we're great as well. We're over an hour away, but we will be back!“

“Grew up on them. Still love them to this day. I just wish they would expand!“

“This place has the best veggie pizza ever! Crust is perfect, little firmer than New York style, sauce perfectly tangy, and a butt load of cheese and toppings. We are always helped by a super buff guy who is the nicest!! I hope this magic pizza makes me buff too.“

“Absolutely delicious! I would totally recommend. 🫶🏻“

“Amazing place and the staff are awesome“

“We ordered 2 of the Spuntino Family Meals for 6 for our holiday party and as always they were delicious! We went with the Chicken Limon and Chicken Parmesan with both penne marinara and penne vodka sauce. More than enough food for 15 people easily ! They give you an abundant amount of salad and both choices of chicken were super flavorful! And we absolutely love the bruschetta! Did I mention the 2 pizzas! My family definitely recommends Spuntinos not just for the value but the flavor and quality of the meals. Delicious, fresh, and always a crowd favorite.“

“This pizza is so good! I wish they were open more often“

“Delicious, sparkling, clean, very friendly owner and staff! This place is a gem.“

“this is the best place i have every got pizza from“

“Great food and top notch service. A must have when we are in the city.“

“Enjoyed food from this location for the first time today, and it was GREAT! I rarely eat a salad when I get pizza, but it was provided for our luncheon today, and even the salad was great - I would buy a jar of the balsamic vinaigrette - it's really really good. Thanks for the great food today, Rosati's!“

“Stopped in for a quick slice and was really impressed! I had the cheese and pepperoni, and both were delicious—crispy crust and great flavor. The staff were super friendly and welcoming, which made the whole experience even better. Definitely planning to come back soon!“

“All was amazing for our first visit.“

“Good thin crust and good ingredients, cooked perfect“

“We've loved Joe's for over a decade and decided to rent the party room at their new location for an event. It was fantastic! The food was great as always, and Kim and Eric took wonderful care of our party throughout the event. Thank you for making everything perfect for our friends and family!“

“amazing staff, incredible food, and prices are great. definitely better than your local pizza place, check them out“

“The best tasting pizza! Delicious and flavorful! Great customer service!“

“Great atmosphere and food!“

“Food is good. Fresh. Portions and prices are fair for the Marketplace. One star off for the horrible Tito's Pours. Either make that tiny pour $7 or fill that glass up for 12. You ll never cultivate regulars with pours like that..also not a good look when owner is vaping inside and allowing patrons to do so as well. You have a clean nice place. Keep it that way“

“We dined in tonight. The staff was friendly and helpful and the food was amazing. Will definitely stop in again next time we are in town.“

“5 star !!!!!“

“Great small place to get pizza! Bread was fresh and tasty!“

“delivery order alittle later but more importantly both pizzas were cold.Tasted ok but if hot would have been better. they should use pizza hot bags to keep food hot.“

“I come here a lot and their service is great but you know how good a place is when they things don’t happen your way. I ordered an XL pizza and they accidentally made L one but the cashier went above and beyond to make things right. I will be a forever customer“

“I am a 1st-timer who had their pizza brought to me so I can't talk about their place but I can talk about their great pizza! Good balance of cheese and sauce on a good crust - not too dry like some places.“

“Best Pizza in Evanston. The dough, the unique ingredients. I. Am.Hooked👌“

“Great italian food and good service.“

“I’m staying at the Renaissance across the street and needed a quick meal. Barnbay’s totally hit the mark, very reasonable pricing, fast take out, friendly staff and solid food. I had meatball sub and the handmade meatballs were delicious. The salad was fresh with lots of chicken and romaine. I would def eat from here again.“

“we have gone here 2x in the last 2 months - the 1st was for carry-out and it was fantastic - the 2nd was for dine-in lunch specials and it was fantastic.“

“Nice work by new owner now new look beautiful“

“I ordered a square pizza consisting of four pieces. It was a deep-dish pizza and the appearance is debatable. But the taste convinced me, because the pizza with extra jalapenos was really delicious! You even could refine the preparation of the crust in terms of flavor, so I decided to have garlic in the dough, which was very good. I made my order through a third-party app that had a promo, which means pay one, get two. All in all, I was very satisfied with the value for money of my order.“

“Very nice food fresh .must go“

“The Broccolini Crunch here is one of my favorite slices in either of Chicago and NYC. The slices I've gotten here are consistently cooked through and the crust crunches. The decor is nice. The reading material is thoughtful, the bar looks good, and the whole shop looks clean. The other patrons I've met were friendly. There's a $1 Beer, $1 Shot Night. I have received exceptional hospitality at this restaurant.“

“If you are looking for an incredible dining experience that perfectly balances amazing flavor with high-quality ingredients, HALAL PIZZA POINT is an absolute must-visit. They manage to deliver an outstanding variety of options that keep you coming back for more.
​The crust strikes the perfect balance of crispy on the outside and wonderfully chewy on the inside, serving as the ideal foundation for their fresh toppings and flavorful sauce. Beyond the classic favorites, their specialty pies feature beautifully seasoned meats that set them apart from standard pizza spots.
​The service is consistently warm, welcoming, and prompt, making you feel right at home whether you are picking up a quick takeout order or dining in with family. For anyone seeking delicious, premium halal options, this spot truly hits the mark!“

“My first time here and will not be my last. One of the best beef shawarma pizzas I’ve had. The people are great and the service is excellent.“

“Been coming here for years. Even though I moved out of neighborhood to Des Plaines, I still come here. Everything is awesome! 👍👍 two thumbs up!“

“best pizza ever!!!! always my 1st stop when I'm back in Chicago“

“The pizzas are absolutely delicious! The Detroit-style pizza is soft, buttery, and incredibly flavorful, with so many topping options to choose from. My kids love it and get so excited whenever it’s Jet’s Pizza for breakfast, lunch, or dinner.😆“

“Fantastic restaurant in the neighborhood serves excellent food and donuts and takes care of the neighborhood and the world. So grateful for their presence in Rogers Park. Also the peach spicy Sammy is to die for.“

“Goirdano’s left our area and I stumbled on to NPC. I ordered and was surprised they deliver to Skokie. I called an hour later and they informed me due to busyness our pizza was accidentally delivered to the wrong location. They quickly credited me the amount and still made a new order for us. The pizza was fantastic. Deep dish and margarita. They totally owned the situation and did their best. Pizza felt cleaner. Less additives or chemicals than Lou’s or Giordano’s. Will definitely return.“

“I've been a customer for 20 yrs. Their food, customer service and delivery are outstanding. Maria the owner is very friendly and accommodating to my food orders. The ribs are my favorite they are tasty and fall off the bone.
Their pizza both deep and thin crust are delicious. If you want delivious food, try them. They welcome you with a smile!“

“Friendly phone person to start out . Thank you, Katy . ( Some restaurants have lost sight of the importance of the first person to represent their business . No one wants to deal with a cocky and rude high school girl who can't get their order right. ) Excellent Pizza! Nice CRUNCH on their thin crust dough . Only very slightly thicker crust than most. And not burnt or charred . ( Not that I mind a good char taste ) The cheese is perfectly caramelized, so I wouldn't risk losing that by ordering a well done pizza . The crunchy dough stands up well to the slightly generous amount of sauce that is perfectly balanced . Extra thin sliced fresh veggies are also much appreciated .“

“I love this place I've been coming here since I was 17. I raised my sons here as I am 45 and still come here. fantastic.“