24 Best Sandwich Shops near Sugar Grove

“A really well run chain restaurant. It is one of the best run Subways that I've been to lately.

Vegetarian options: They have a lot of vegetarian options

Parking: Plenty of parking

Kid-friendliness: Good place for kids

Wheelchair accessibility: Wheelchair accessible “

“Been going for YEARS!! I'm 14 now, and it seems like I've been going since I was 5-6. The employees are always so fast and friendly. The food is always fresh and delicious!
(A lot of other reviews seem off to me since I've never seen anything like that in my 9 years of going here.)

Kid-friendliness: They are so kind there!“

“Ate here for the first time and to say it was delicious is understatement ❤️. I highly recommend!!“

“This Subway location truly stands out! From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with a friendly smile and excellent customer service. The staff was patient and attentive, ensuring my order was made just the way I wanted it. The ingredients were incredibly fresh, and the bread was perfectly baked, making for a delicious and satisfying meal. The restaurant itself was spotless, with a clean and welcoming atmosphere that made my experience even better. Whether you’re in a rush or want to sit and enjoy a meal, this Subway offers the perfect balance of quality, speed, and comfort. I highly recommend it and will definitely be returning for more!“

“From Our FAVORITE Place ...The Food is SOOO good from the Friendly Family Owners & Staff are # 1 in Our Book!!!! Never Fails to keep Us Coming Back! Thank You from Rosie & Dave“

“Always have a fabulous sub. I’m gluten free so they have a fabulous GF bun. I love most of the staff. They remember you and are funny ......It’s my one treat that I enjoy so much ....always get #2 extra meat and dressing. Thank you Jersey mike for keeping it real“

“My workplace used this location twice for large orders of boxed lunches for our employees. The manager and team are always professional, accommodating, help with suggestions, and are just easy to work with from start to finish. Food is tasty and they're accurate with their orders! 5 stars. ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐“

“5 STARS AND 2 THUMBS UP!!!

Absolutely loved this location. ❤️

The staff was extremely friendly and nice. So patient and helpful. It was our first time here. It's probably family operated because everything had the same wonderful personality and smile.

The food...LOVED IT!! Delicious! I recommend the sweet and smoky chicken. The bread was fresh and soft. Ample chicken in the sandwich.

The dining area was modern and clean. The staff clears your table for you.

Make sure you down load the app for potential reward freebies or coupons.

Will definitely come again. I enjoyed the friendly staff, warm food, and nice environment.“

“I wish I could articulate what brain processes led to the “FAJITAS” category screaming out at me while I was looking over the extensive Baba’s menu but I really can’t say. What I can tell you is that I ordered the steak and chicken mixed option fully prepared for it to be a let down but I am so happy I gave them a chance because they were not half bad.

As you can see from photos there’s nice sized servings of beef and chicken tossed with much more onions, peppers, tomatoes and seasoning than I expected. It also comes with plenty of nicely cooked tortillas for scooping up all the goodness into a couple of tacos as well as shredded lettuce, sour cream, and some of Baba’s mild sauce. I like the mild sauce on other menu items like the chicken but don’t feel it works very well with the fajitas. I ended up adding some leftover salsa of my own that I had in the fridge.

I have to admit that one thing that drew me to this order was a picture I saw on the menu showing that the fajitas came with pita bread as opposed to tortillas. It just seemed like a very intriguing combo to me. I was still happy with the tortillas but have to admit that not being able to satisfy my curiosity did bother me. Would be kind of cool if they gave the option to choose pita or tortillas.

I ordered using the Baba’s app and the food was ready at the quoted pickup time of 20 mins. The woman cleaning up for closing and working the counter was an absolute sweetheart. Gave the perfect amount of lemon pepper when I said just a little and was just so friendly.“

“Nathan made me #13 that was out of this world! Great service! Highly recommend!“

“I have been to so many subways this is the best subway ever! The staff is always so nice, they are not stingy with the ingredients. I literally drive thirty minutes just to come to this specific location. Thank you to all the stab members for making the best sandwiches“

“This day I stopped to get sandwiches from my favorite sandwich shop! I had know intentions of stopping.As I drove by I remembered the wonderful staff that works at this location. So… I’m getting sandwiches for dinner!As I told the crew and directed it at Rea the new hire. People will stop at a store and buy things because of the people.Kudos to the crew at JJ’s Oswego Route 71!“

“Jimmy was a beast. His sandwich artistry skills are unparalleled. The jalapenos were pretty hot though. But I would attribute that to the fact that they are jalapeños. So I will not hold that against my man Jimmy. I don’t know for sure if Jimmy is his real name. He seemed a little sheepish when we asked. But now that we are giving him this review, I hope that he will be a little more forthcoming. Overall, 5 stars all the way. This will be a regular stop for me and mullet boy when sustenance is required.“

“I’m honestly surprised by Lorraine’s awful review because my experiences here have been nothing but great! The team has always been friendly, quick, and attentive day and especially night. My orders are always fire and exactly what I ask for. Mistakes happen anywhere, but this crew consistently goes out of their way to make things right and keep customers happy. It’s clear they work hard and care about their service. Don’t listen to grumpy customers who have their undies in a twist.“

“I can only review based off the numerous lunch sandies that have left me wanting a cigarette and a nap afterwards. Consistent crowd pleasing sandwiches being pumped out by the lunch crew of this JJs. Whoever made my last 12 w/ bacon -tom,-cuc deserves a f'n raise.“

“I recommend Ya'll taste Ech & Everyone of them Sandwiches Mmmmm😋Let me know whenever you do😊😇😊“

“Umair and Kush were the kind of duo who moved through the subway with an effortless grace that felt almost mythic, their connection so natural it seemed the trains themselves danced to their rhythm. Umair, calm and calculating, had an uncanny knack for predicting the perfect route, while Kush, with his sharp wit and impeccable timing, brought a flair that turned every sandwich into something extraordinary. They didn’t just navigate the subway, they owned it, their movements so fluid and synchronized that strangers would glance twice, convinced they were witnessing something extraordinary. Like Spongebob and Patrick or Kobe and Shaq, Umair and Kush weren’t just partners; they were a force of nature, perfectly balanced and unforgettable.“

“I love to visit here when ever I want a Really Good Lunch ❤️❤️❤️“

“I had to speak to the manager, Yvone, due to thinking both sandwiches being made incorrectly. Turns out only 1 sandwich was missing the bacon n I ordered the other incorrectly. My own mistake. She did hear me say I don't eat pork, so she offered to remake both sandwiches for me, keep the sandwich missing bacon, n give back the ham, n get the sandwich I intended to pick up! She so didn't have to remake my sandwich since it was totally my mistake, but was so considerate n did. Thank you Yvonne, I will definitely be returning!!“

“I came in last week 10/4/25 at 1:48pm with my girlfriend and Desi & Kimberly helped me and their customer service was amazing! Desi made my sandwich soooooo good and she had a bubbly personality great for food service! Kimberly helped me at the register and she explained the rewards program to me which was helpful! I tried to tell the Hispanic woman manager on shift about my wonderful experience but she seemed to ignore me as if she didn’t want to hear about her wonderful staff and had a stale demeanor but I ensured she received the great compliment because without employees there is no successful company. Desi and Kimberly made my experience wonderful! Management should be a little more friendly.“

“I really love subway! I really do! The sandwiches are amazing and my mouth is watering just thinking about it. But I don't give it a five because I think that online, they should have a build your own sandwich option. Because when you walk into the restaurant, you can build your own sandwich or you can get a sandwich that they already have. But online, they only have the option to buy a sandwich they already have. You can edit the sandwiches but you can only do so much to them.“

“I go to a lot of Jimmy John’s, but this one is by far the best. I go here pretty often and they have never gotten my order wrong. They are always quick with the service and the food always taste delicious. When you ask for extra, they truly put extra on your sandwich and everything always taste fresh. I’ll never stop coming here.“

“we have always great experience with this restaurant. they always make sandwich what ever customer requested with smile. when i stand in line for sandwich and i notice about they make some customers sandwiches even they don't say anything because they know what regular customer like it.“