14 Best Ice Cream Shops in Fishers

Handel's Homemade Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
8760 E 116th St, Fishers

Customers` Favorites

Homemade Ice Cream Cakes & Pies
Chocolate Raspberry Truffle
Handel's Banana Split
Strawberry Cheesecake
Coffee Chocolate Chip
Peanut Butter Parfait
Oreo Cookies N Cream
Coconut Ice Cream
Banana Cream Pie
4 Scoop Sampler

“Hansel’s is The. Ice Cream. Place. There is no better place to get a dish, cone, waffle bowl, or a point to take home- the flavors are unparalleled. Seating is all outdoor, so that’s my only minus- if it’s raining, you’re sitting in the car. Still worth it!“

4.5 Superb98 Reviews
Graeter's Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
9367 Ambleside Dr, Fishers

Customers` Favorites

Double Scoop Waffle Cone
Chocolate Chocolate Chip
Brownie Sundae
Gelato

“Great ice cream and customer service!“

4.6 Superb40 Reviews
Crumbl - Fishers Bakery • $$
8395 E 116th St, Fishers

Customers` Favorites

Cookies and Creme Cookies and Buckeye Brownie Cookies
Cornbread Cookies and Iced Sugar Cookies
Cookies and Cookies and Cookies
Red Velvet Chocolate Chip
Churro and Animal Cracker
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Strawberry Cheesecake
Birthday Cake Cookie
Milk Chocolate Chip
Gingerbread Cookie

“Love Crumbl! This was the first time our order was messed up. Got two of the same cookie and one was left out of the 12 pack. Also, we initially were only handed 6 cookies (half our order) and almost left before the employee realized and stopped us the for the rest. We didn’t notice the messed up order until we got to the car. Normally they open the box and show us the order, but not this time. We still love you Crumbl!“

4.7 Superb423 Reviews
Nicey Treat Ice Cream Shop • $
11547 Yard St Ste 840, Fishers

“Nicey is a modern, trendy ice cream shop that specializes in popsicles, offering a unique twist on traditional ice cream. The flavors are creative and full of unexpected combinations, setting it apart from typical ice cream spots. I especially love the option to dip popsicles in chocolate, with plenty of topping choices to customize your treat.

The branding, color scheme, and decor are all on point, giving the place a fresh, inviting vibe. The only reason I’m giving it four stars is that on my last three visits, they hadn’t restocked their chocolate dips in time, which feels like something that should be easy to keep up with. Still, it’s a fun and delicious spot that’s definitely worth checking out!“

4.7 Superb21 Reviews
Melt N Dip Dessert • $
9840 E 116th St SUITE 100, Fishers

Customers` Favorites

Waffle with Chocolate and Fruit
Gelato Party Size 16 Scoops
Triple Chocolate Crepe 1
Pistachio Milkshake 46
Dubai Chocolate Crepe
Red Velvet Cookies 25
Kunafa Waffle Cup 22
Pistachio Milkshake
Chocolate Ice Cream
Pistachio Crepe 15

“Melt n Dip has a nice atmosphere, and the presentation was great. The crepe, however, was overwhelmingly chocolatey and way too sweet for my taste. The hot chocolate was good but still overly sweet, making it hard to enjoy. Overall, the desserts were too rich, and I couldn’t even finish. It’s a nice spot if you love intense sweetness, but not for me.“

4.7 Superb109 Reviews
Bruster's Real Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
12350 Olio Rd, Fishers

Customers` Favorites

Oreo Cookies and Cream Dairy Free
Peanut Butter Cup Sundae
Hot Fudge Brownie
Reg Waffle Bowl
Turtle Sundae
PB Cup Sundae
Banana Split
Half Gallon
Small Blast
Quart

“This is our goto spot for ice cream cravings... I don't know what else to say? They are superior to all other shops... go and try it, tell me I'm wrong, I'll wait! :)“

4 Good49 Reviews
Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard Ice Cream Shop • $
8789 North St SUITE 120, Fishers

Customers` Favorites

Cherry Gelati and Vanilla Custard

“Rita's is a Philadelphia institution. So as a displaced Philadelphian, I was thrilled to find one in Fishers. However, in Philly, they call it Water Ice, not Italian Ice. All of the ices are great, but my favorite is mango. Try a Gelati, which is water ice and vanilla custard mixed together. That's my all-time favorite. Rita's is just down the street from that one famous Fishers ice cream place. So if you don't want to wait in line there, try going a block north to Rita's.“

3.9 Good37 Reviews
Dairy Queen (Treat) Ice Cream Shop • $
10560 E 96th St, Fishers

Customers` Favorites

Oreo Cookies Blizzard Treat
Chili Cheese Dog Combo
Classic Dog Combo
6 Pack Buster Bar
10 Blizzard Cake
8 Blizzard Cake
Birthday Cake
Banana Split
Hot Fudge
Hot Dog

“I always enjoy the Heath DQ Blizzard. I ordered a pupcup as well for our dog. I was eating my blizzard outside with our dog enjoying her pupcup. The manager saw how much the dog loved her pupcup and he comped second one to feed her himself!“

3.7 Good75 Reviews
Ohanalulu Donut Shops • $
11640 Brooks School Rd Suite 100, Fishers

Customers` Favorites

Peanutbutter Cup Donuts Chocolate Lovers and Kaitys Cinnamon Roll
Maple Bacon Donut
Cake Donut
Doughnut
Sandwich
Sundae

“Have driven by this little ice cream and donut shop several times and decided to stop by on a Sunday morning. Small but quaint dining and service area. Ordered an 6 pack assortment of their speciality donuts. Oreo, sprinkles, maple bacon, peanut butter cup and a couple of iced. Had a small bite of each and they were delicious!!! All were made to order, fresh and each had a special twist. Give it a try!“

4.3 Superb74 Reviews
Dairy Queen Grill & Chill Fast Food • $
11976 Allisonville Rd, Fishers

Customers` Favorites

Double Deluxe Cheeseburger
Oreo Blizzard Treat
Chicken Fingers
Chicken Strips
Banana Split
French Fries

“My wife and I drive from Greenfield to this D.Q. because there hamburgers literally look even better in real life than there pictures do and tastes as good as they look!!“

3.8 Good66 Reviews
Culver’s American • $
13691 Olio Rd, Fishers

Customers` Favorites

Double Butterburger Cheese Curds with Cheese Sauce
Double Butterburger with Cheese and Extra Onions
Butterfinger Concrete Mixer
Carmel Peanut Butter Cup
Fries and Cheese Curds
One Scoop of Ice Cream
Cheese Burger Single
Double Cheeseburger
Fried Cheese Curds
Peanut Butter Cups

“We did not care for the cheese curds since some of them had nothing in them - no cheese to be seen! Too expensive for that problem.

Kid-friendliness: Culver's workers are pretty much always nice to the kiddos. Thank you.

Wheelchair accessibility: You can get in and out with a wheelchair easily and it fits at the tables also. Thank you Culver's.“

3.8 Good134 Reviews
Shake Shack Fishers Hamburger • $
9701 E 116th St, Fishers

Customers` Favorites

Shackburger Cheese Fries and Cookies and Cream Shack
Korean Style Fried Chicken Sandwich
Double Cheeseburger and Fries
Buffalo Seasoning Fries
Avocado Bacon Burger
Bacon Cheese Fries
Avocado Burger
Chicken Bites
Crinkle Fries
French Fries

“I recommend ordering on your phone and picking up in drive through then proceed to eat in your car. This location is ridiculous on the inside, too busy and congested. And forget about the kiosks inside, just use your phone.

I ordered the Avocado bacon chicken, it was hot and cooked just right, with a generous amount of fresh avocado.

Fries were perfectly crisp and hot.

A great fast food option when in the area.“

3.8 Good184 Reviews
Dairyqueen Fast Food • $
13647 Olivia Way, Fishers

Customers` Favorites

4-PC Chicken Strip Basket with Beverage
Brownie Extreme Blizzard Small
Peanut Buster Parfait
Chocolate Ice Cream
Chili Cheese Dog
Chicken Fingers
Side of Fries
Cheeseburger
Cheese Curds
Onion Rings

“We stopped here after a doctor's apt, and they weren't busy at all, but yet the food and the blizzards we got were the best we've ever gotten from any dairy queen ever! I was very shocked at how great every item was! If we didn't live so far away from it, it'd be the only 1 I'd go to!“

3.7 Good110 Reviews
Kung Fu Tea Bubble Tea • $
8395 E 116th St ste 121, Fishers

Customers` Favorites

Sunshine Pineapple Tea Cap
Cocoa Cream Wow Milk Cap
Oolong Tea Wow Milk Cap
Black Tea Wow Milk Cap
Honey Oolong Milk Tea
Pikmin Tropical Slush
Winter Melon Tea Cap
Coffee Wow Milk Cap
Passion Grape Slush
KF Milk Tea

“Their boba tea is AMAZING!!! Best boba place in zionsville!

Dietary restrictions: They ask you if you want boba in your tea or just the milk tea.

Parking: The parking is RIGHT in front of the shop, so very accessible. It took us less than 10 seconds to find a parking spot!“

3.4 Good55 Reviews

You May Also Like