21 Best American Restaurants near Garrett

C J's Canteena Bar & Grill • $
701 E Quincy St #1616, Garrett

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Chicken Breaded Chicken
Cajun Grilled Chicken Salad
Deep Fried Pickle Chips
Texas Cheese Fries
Breaded Mushrooms
Pretzel Bites
Cheese Curds
French Fries
Bread Sticks
Chef Salad

“We were 1st time visitors to Garrett IN and saw the parking lot jammed at this nice place. Always a good sign! Their Friday night fish was fantastic! Honestly, the best I've ever had, and at 75, that's saying something I asked where they sourced their breading and tartar sauce. It's all homemade by the owner. Great prices, too. This is a cozy neighborhood bar and grille with lots of charm.“

4.7 Superb19 Reviews
Blue Moon Ice Cream Shop • $
4504 IN-327, Garrett

Customers` Favorites

Hot Fudge Sundae

“The strawberry shortcake Sundae is good, but the entire CHUNK of shortcake was surprisingly unexpected. Fries are great, chicken was good but the oil needed changed. Kid taking orders was super polite! This was our first time here, and we'll come back next season!“

4.6 Superb48 Reviews
North Main Street Diner American • $
1310 N Main St, Auburn - 4.64 miles

Customers` Favorites

Hash Browns Sausage Patties Corned Beef Hash
Eggs & Country Fried Steak & Potatoes
dbl Cheeseburger with Waffle Fries
Grilled Cheese and Tomato Soup
Reuben Sandwich with Fries
Pancake or French Toast
Biscuits and Gravy
Breakfast Burrito
Sloppy Joe
dbl Burger

“Our server Natasha was great! She is very friendly and took our orders correctly. She even asked about hot sauce which I loved because I always have to ask for hot sauce anywhere else. She initiated it. The food was amazing. It came out pretty quickly. I always love their pancakes because they taste buttery and are gigantic. Everyone there seems to know each other which is a pleasant atmosphere. We go there whenever we come off the train at waterloo station.“

4.8 Superb83 Reviews
Classic City Creamery Ice Cream Shop • $
119 E 9th St, Auburn - 4.32 miles

“I love the product! Probably some of the best ice cream I have ever had . My only critique is on the take home pint of ice cream. My experience it doesn't actually weigh a pint. And I feel it's a lot of money and you should get what you pay for. However as far as the product goes it is superb and hope everyone gets a chance to try it. You will thoroughly enjoy it.“

4.6 Superb33 Reviews
Joanna's Family Restaurant American • $
280 N Grandstaff Dr, Auburn - 3.58 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Lovers Crepes
Stuffed French Toast
Meat Lovers Omelette
Biscuits and Gravy
Meat Lovers Skillet
Hash Brown Skillet
Corned Beef Hash
Belgian Waffle
Mexican Salad
Eggs Benedict

“I met up with a large group (20+) people here. They did a great job of having space for us and taking care of us. The food was excellent. It's rare for me to ask for a take home container, but I was unable to finish the monster omelette, potatoes, and pancakes that were all included in my meal. The portions were massive, especially for the price. This seems like the type of place that I should bring my teenage kids ?“

4.4 Superb84 Reviews
Hangar 9 Bar & Grille Bar & Grill • $
1714 S, 1714 Wayne St, Auburn - 4 miles

Customers` Favorites

Birria Tacos Tuesday Only
Pulled Pork Quesadilla
6pc Chicken Wings
Fried Pickles
Club Grinder
blt

“We love this place. The staff and bartenders are amazing. All walks of life here and always a good atmosphere. Love Karaoke on Friday and Saturday when they don't have a band. They have updated the place and it's so nice and clean. No smoking inside which I love but a really nice smoking patio. Also during the warmer months they have like garage door type windows that lift so you can talk to people outside.“

4.6 Superb32 Reviews
St James Restaurant American • $
204 E Albion St, Avilla - 5.39 miles

Customers` Favorites

Smothered Chicken with Green Beans
Broasted Chicken Dinner
Chicken Noodle Soup
Maryland Crab Cakes
Mashed Potatoes
Stuffed Shrimp
American Fries
Grilled Cheese
Caesar Salad
Hamburger

“Only went for lunch. Had a BLT. it was very good. It's a grey hair place, so this a real review but more of an overview of a place that everyone there knows multiple people there. I don't think anything would floor me but ivv be also think nothing will disappoint either. Nice bar but little to no bar vibes. I'd go again knowing I'll get a decent experience.“

4.4 Superb83 Reviews
Auburn City Steakhouse Steak House • $$$
203 Main St, Auburn - 4.28 miles

Customers` Favorites

Wedge Salad with Bleu Cheese Dressing
Slow Roasted Prime Rib Served Au Jus
French Onion Soup and Wedge Salad
Waygu Stuffed Mushroom Caps
Brussel Sprouts and Bacon
Bread Served with Meal
Chop Chop Salad
Delmonico Steak
Prime Rib Tacos
Chopped Salad

“It was a very nice dining experience with primarily and attentive waitress, although there was some confusion at the end with the bill since we were given the wrong one. However she was able to straighten it out although it took a few minutes to get her attention and there was some concern that another patron might walk out with our credit card.“

4.3 Superb224 Reviews
Avilla Country Kitchen Breakfast • $
108 W Albion St, Avilla - 5.51 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Tender Basket
Macaroni Salad Chili
Blueberry Pancake
Mashed Potatoes
W Garlic Bread
Potato Soup
Eggs W

“Great food, very friendly and efficient wait staff. Make you feel like family. Just a small town diner with amazing home cooked meals.On Friday evenings they open up for dinner, (normally close at 2) and serve some awesome specials. Had the prime rib, best that I have had in a long time.“

4.9 Superb13 Reviews
The Brown House Ice Cream Shop • $
100 E Ensley Ave, Auburn - 4.24 miles

Customers` Favorites

Double Cheeseburger
Chocolate Cherry
Turtle Sundae
Onion Rings
Coney Dog
Sandwich

“I’ve been going here for years and i’ve never had a complaint for the brown house. staff is always great and food is always fresh. I understand every other fast food is doing the tip thing now, it’s nice to get tips. But i feel peer pressured to tip when you go from handing me a device and asking versus a teenager looking me in the face and asking me if i’d like to tip today. It’s not that i don’t have the money and or appreciate the service. It’s that many people like me have high anxiety and won’t be able to say no to that. I did end up tipping, that i did not want to do. I feel like the device is a much better option to ask for a tip.“

4.4 Superb50 Reviews
The Deli at Sixth & Main Deli • $
115 N Main St fl 2, Auburn - 4.3 miles

Customers` Favorites

Club Sandwich
Veggie Wrap

“Interesting location on upper level. There is an elevator which is handy for those challenged by stairs. I had the Ruben which was loaded with all the right stuff. However, I thought it lacked some the "tang" you expect in that sandwich.“

4.5 Superb27 Reviews
Leo Cafe Family • $
15024 IN-1, Leo - 10.79 miles

Customers` Favorites

Breakfast Bowl with Extra Side of Bacon
Melting Pot Scramble
Sliced Potatoes
Sausage Gravy
Chicken Salad
Chicken Wrap
Hash Browns

“Sorry there's no picture. Whenever I come here I'm so excited to eat that I forget to snap a pic. We've been eating here almost weekly since moving to the area. We've watch this restaurant go through tough times and frequent staff changes and The ownership is changing as we speak. However, the chef has not and she's awesome! The food here is fresh, well prepared and plentiful. I've had almost everything on the menu and haven't been disappointed yet. This best coffee in the area combined with a real neighborhood feel make this restaurant a regular staple for many of the locals. My favorite item ? The breakfast potatoes. Whether they're sliced or hashed, this chef puts pure magic into those spuds, I could eat them all day. The new owner is lovely and after speaking to him a few times I can tell that he's devoted to making this restaurant a long term representation of the stereotypical Midwest food and friendliness that we've come to love. If I had to suggest anything it would be to update the decor a little bit. A little paint and some modern lighting would really make this place cozy and cute. But PLEASE keep the melting pot on the menu“

4.4 Superb35 Reviews
Mimi's Retreat Bar • $
125 E 9th St, Auburn - 4.32 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chef Salad with Spring Mix Chicken and Ranch
Prime Rib Baked Potato and Coleslaw
Rueben Sandwich and Onion Rings
Cheeseburger and Fries
It Was Grilled Salmon
Chicken Caesar Salad
Prime Rib Sandwich
Chicken Sandwich
Famous Coleslaw
Waffle Fries

“Facebook reviews was right, food here was good . Had the boneless pork ribeye and sweet potato fries. The pork was very flavorful and tender and the fries came with a sweet cream cheese dipping sauce.Wife had the prime rib and was very well prepared and a nice generous cut as well. Our server was on top of everything and took good care of us. Very freindly place , plan on visiting again.“

4.3 Superb48 Reviews
The Kitchen Table American • $
15315 Lima Rd, Huntertown - 8.81 miles

Customers` Favorites

Country Fried Steak and Cheesy Hashbrowns
Chicken and Noodles over Mashed Potatoes
Biscuits and Gravy with a Side of Bacon
Fried Bologna Sandwich
Macaroni and Cheese
Breakfast Sandwich
Hamburger Steak
Fried Potatoes
Scrambled Eggs
Broccoli Soup

“I just loved the old diner! It just brought me back to childhood. The service was great. The food was amazing! My bacon was cooked perfectly then with my potatoes and gravy, you have 3 different options of potatoes ? ? it was a great place to sit and chat with a friend.“

4.3 Superb40 Reviews
Sit 'n Bull Pub 'n Patio Bar & Grill • $
101 Main St, Laotto - 5.23 miles

Customers` Favorites

Butterflied Shrimp Basket
Garlic Toast with Cheese
Chicken Strip Basket
Fish Sandwich
Chicken Club
Sausage Rolls
House Salad
Wings
Fries

“Best Bar in LaOtto!Vegetarian options: There are vegetarian options available. Salads and rolls and pizza all without meat.Parking: There is parking in front and a few spots in the back. It's appreciated to try to use the front parking if possible.Kid-friendliness: Bar atmosphere. 21+.Wheelchair accessibility: Yes, in the back of the bar there is a ramp, and a ramp inside.“

4.3 Superb31 Reviews
Cricket's 7th St. Bar & Grille Bar & Grill • $
120 W Seventh St, Auburn - 4.27 miles

Customers` Favorites

The Cricket Burger
Soup of the Day
Grilled Cheese
French Fries
Cheeseburger
Pub Chips
Hog Wings

“We stopped in here for lunch and were immediately greeted when we walked through the door. The service was good, the food was great. Their special for the day was a homemade chicken salad sandwich. It was just like my grandma used to make, like traveling back in time! Can't wait to explore more items from the menu!“

4.1 Good44 Reviews
Mad Anthony's Auburn Tap Room Brewpubs • $
114 N Main St, Auburn - 4.32 miles

Customers` Favorites

Side Waffle Fries
Jambalaya Unwrap
Fish and Chips
Jambalaya Pasta
Shrimp & Grits
Pulled Pork
Beer Cheese
Cheese Curds
Scotch Eggs
Beer Flight

“A nice local brewery with a nice food menu. The three of us who dined had no problem finding something to eat. I tried the Raspberry Beer and it was okay. Needed a bit more of the fruit flavor to shine, but overall okay. I got the fish and chips and the fish was perfectly fried. The waffle fries have a delicious seasoning that tastes great alone. I am a dipper of ketchup and still did enjoy dipping, but whatever seasoning they use is perfect!“

4.1 Good87 Reviews
Auburn's Town Tavern Bar • $
1343 Main St, Auburn - 4.19 miles

Customers` Favorites

Town Tavern Tenderloin Sandwich
Breaded Tenderloin Sandwich
Pork Tenderloin Sandwich
Chicken Strip Basket
American Fries
Tartar Sauce
Onion Rings
Fish Dinner
Fish Basket
Hamburger

“We looked for a place to eat at the other end of town. Most were national chain type restaurants. The wait to be seated was horrendous. We went to the Town Tavern and got seated immediately. We try to honor local places anyway. We will be back.“

4 Good89 Reviews
Culver’s American • $
121 Touring Dr, Auburn - 3.11 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fish Basket and Chicken Tender Basket
Bacon Butter Bacon Cheeseburger
Fish Sandwich with Fries
Ice Cream Sundaes
Chicken Sandwich
Cod Fish Dinner
Shrimp Basket
Turtle Sundae
Chili Cheese
Hamburger

“This Culver’s has THE BEST manager. We stopped by to treat our sports team to ice cream and he made our visit fast and efficient. The staff even took the time to ask our athletes questions and congratulate them on their success. I know it’s just fast food but thank you for the great experience!“

4 Good101 Reviews
The Willows Family • $$
1601 W Gump Rd, Huntertown - 8.8 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cod Basket with Cottage Cheese
Chicken Tenders and Frys
Chicken Sandwiches
Pulled Pork Nachos
Seafood Alfredo
Chef Salad

“This review was written by my wife. Wing Quest - Week 8: This week's wing adventure took place in The Willows on Gump Rd, Huntertown. The Willows is kind of a Richards-looking place with one exception---there's a bar at one end! The restaurant itself is clean and efficient with a server who is very friendly and knows most of her clientele. The bartender does what one would expect. She tends to the bar patrons. Willows' wings come 6 to an order for $7.15. Hardier appetites can be satiated with 12 for $14.30, 18 for $21.45, or 50 for $51.99. Wings can be dressed in Mild, Medium, Hot, Suicide, Butter Garlic, Butter Cajun, Butter Garlic Cajun, The Willows Special, BBQ, Honey Mustard, Teriyaki, or Buffalo sauce. Willows' wings are large, but not the jumbo wings that sometimes come to the table less than done. These wings are crisp, tender, and juicy. They are not rubbed in spices or rolled in breading. They are just pure chicken with sauce on, the way wings are intended to be enjoyed. The Honey Mustard is a basic no-frills needed sauce. It's mild mustard and slight honey sweetness is a nice enhancement to the chicken. The Willows Special is a secret house-made sauce that is garlic heavy with a hint of sweetness, almost a finer version of Teriyaki. If you like a bit of heat the Hot sauce is for you. It's a very flavorful condiment that soaks through the crispy skin to marinate the meat and dance pleasantly on the tongue. If you like more that just a bit of heat, we suggest the Suicide sauce. It's got a beautifully unique flavor, almost like that of the musky-smoky Scorpion Pepper, but I have no clue what's really in it. I just know it's pretty darned good! This sauce has enough heat to bring a mist of sweat to the brow without lingering on the palate so long as to be with you for hours after. Overall, this trip on our quest was a true success. If wings aren't your thing The Willows offers daily specials and a wide variety of breakfast items, munchies, salads, sandwiches, burgers, wraps, baskets, ala carte servings, dinners, pastas, and flatbread pizza. In fact, I've got my eye on the Seafood Combo Plate (10 grilled shrimp, 2 butterfly shrimp, clam strips, and 2 homemade crab cakes). Keep on wingin' everyone! FYI: Full bar service is available. Fresh pies, cakes, and cheesecakes are served daily. The Willows is the 2nd eatery in 8 weeks of reviewing wings that provided wet naps and bone receptacles“

3.7 Good64 Reviews
Applebee's Grill + Bar American • $
602 Fairview Blvd, Kendallville - 9.05 miles

Customers` Favorites

The Four Mac and Cheese with Chicken Tenders
Brew Pub Pretzels & Beer Cheese Dip
Sizzlin' Butter Pecan Blondie
Brew Pub Loaded Waffle Fries
Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad
Chicken Shrimp Alfredo Pasta
Pretzels with Beer Cheese
The Four Cheese Mac Dish
Cheeseburger Egg Rolls
White Queso Dip & Chips

“I would drive out of my way to eat at THIS Applebees! My husband and I frequently eat at Applebee's and have the New Orleans chicken and shrimp often. Their appetizer was top-notch and their entree came out flaming and tender the best one we've had in all of our travels and eating at Applebee's. Hats off to the chef who was cooking on Saturday afternoon the 17th of August!“

3.6 Good72 Reviews