15 Best Pizza Restaurants in Jeffersonville

“Had a great time watching the games and service by Joe C. was the best we’ve had anywhere in a long time. He takes pride in his work and it shows.“

“We have a special order, and they almost always get it correct.

Parking: This location needs designated parking because the Star Sushi customers fill the parking lot and stay much longer than someone who is just walking in to pick up a pizza and leave.“

“On Saturday night ( May 31st, 2025), I dined inside with my granddaughter and son-in-law. Nice, relaxing atmosphere. Attentive staff. The 3 of us had different calzones and shared an order of ( huge!) breadsticks. All agreed that everything was delicious!! Reasonably priced, too! Definitely will be going back!“

“went there this weekend. Was great, and will definitely be back.“

“UPDATE 12/16: Paul was fired and GM Jeff 1000% made it right with me. He's a great manager that understands how to treat customers. He leads by example and has a great staff here. 12/10: Paul is rude and unprofessional. I ate here often until my encounter with him today.“

“Sorry I lost the ladies number that schedules pizza tent. We met her at the river stage in Jeffersonville and would like you all to come set up and sell pizza at our events . You can call me at 813-987-1798 David Rainwater Thank You and have a great evening“

“This location consistently makes the pizzas to expectation. Delivery has always been under 30 minutes and received hot. Delivery drivers are pleasant and courteous. Although I would favor other brands at times, these reasons are why I decide to order from this Dominoes location.
I am not a fan of delayed and inaccurate delivery times from other brands knowing the temperature and quality are always at risk.“

“A little pricey but the food and atmosphere were good. I'm not sure if a reservation is required but we made one since it was our first time.“

“I was told to come at a certain time to pick up pizza. They completely screwed up the order. Then told me I had to wait on the new pizza to cook. I really should one star you, but I’m giving you the chance to make it right. The time away from my family is valuable. I shouldn’t have to wait twice for one pizza so make it right the first time.“

“A Mr. Matthew Brown turned an almost disasterous night for myself and I'm sure others,, but what was almost the loss of a loyal customer for the business on 4-18-24 into a teaching and learning experience,, I feel every employee and manager should have his compassion but even if not his training, his customer service was absolutely superb,, the world needs more people like him but the person he is,, will without a doubt be a huge improvement to this location and the people of Jeffersonville

Kid-friendliness: It's a huge thing in customer service

Wheelchair accessibility: It's a huge necessity“

“These little puffs have had the community shambles to get these. Tried them. We both ordered the pepperoni one but unfortunately one was just cheese. He woofed his down in 2.2 seconds. Said they were better than their pizza. For me, the veridict is still out. They were really affordable though.“

“Love love this place. Karaoke is awesome, food is great. Great atmosphere.“

“First time ordering Marcos and it was a good experience overall. I got a medium Hawaiian pizza which I might say, was very nicely loaded. Large chicken pieces as well. The ham could be cut in smaller pieces. I got a pizzoli but don't think I will get that again. The picture makes it appear more like a pretzel crust. It's anything but a pretzel crust. Also it was very flimsy and too cheesy. I still can't tell what flavor I got. I got a spicy cheese bread. It's very doughy and less cheesy. Maybe they can get it to be the other way around. Last, I got the cinnamon bread and it was good. Delivery was great with 15min quicker than initially quoted.“