14 Best Pizza Restaurants in New Albany

“We went and got our Recbar Reader cookies today, and the lady who helped us was extremely friendly and kind. We had actually never heard of Legacy Pizza before this, and already had lunch plans for today, but we will definitely be returning. Top tier customer service… not to mention the cookies were DELICIOUS!!“

“If you've been looking for pizza that tasted like it was from the heart of NYC this is the one. Best pizza I ever ate!“

“We recently ate here for the first time. Never knew this place even existed lol. The upside down pizza was absolutely fantastic. We have been back twice and plan to return again soon.“

“That pizza place really knows what they're doing when it comes to the pie. The crust is always cooked to perfection and has the perfect amount of crispiness. Also, the sauce has a great balance of sweet and tangy flavors. You can't go wrong with any of their toppings.“

“UPDATE:I normally go here or the one in jeff but this place here literally went out of there way to make my order right.about 3 months ago I had a bad encounter with an employee then this week I placed an order and the pizza's weren't made right.the store owner made it right and fixed both my pizza's.its nice knowing that a huge company like dominos actually reads there reviews and actully dose care about there customers who come there alot.like not over exaggerating i eat at dominos atleast once sometimes twice a week so when they actually made this right it made me feel like my complaint not onky didnt go unheard but was promptly fixed.thank you Sammy and everyone else at the 811 store.means alot to me as a customer and as always the ancestors ar dominos is hands down the best you wont find a better pan crust pizza around here.“

“This place deserves more good reviews!This was a favorite family hangout spot a while ago and I’m always very excited to visit again. The waits can be long at times since they share a kitchen with the neighboring restaurant, but as long as you have good company, you’ll never notice!“

“Best Papa Murphys in the area. We love the service and quality we receive. Our family has been long time customers We will continue to come every Tuesday. Amazing staff. I appreciate the recognition we receive each week

Kid-friendliness: Anytime I bring my kids in they are offered cute stickers. This makes them so happy. They love coming in just for the stickers“

“I love both Pizza King locations, but I do prefer the Jeffersonville location. It's smaller, usually less crowded since it doesn't have a train side, and the staff is very friendly. I love their pizza, it's my favorite place to eat! The only downside is the fact they are closed on Mondays.“

“havent been here in 13 years...only came here today because pizza king closes on mondays..great pizza!“

“Food was great like always ! Service from front counter girl was alright but could been better . Service from the young blonde hair man that was cooking is who delivered our food to us and he was very friendly . I had to go up and try to get dranks girl got snappy with me said we are making them we will bring them to you . I sat back down couple minutes later dranks was brought to us . I had to go back up again and get plates and napkins from same girl . Which this time she was talking on the phone . I spoke up and asked for plates and napkins she rolled her eyes and then grabbed some and handed me some . I went set down and ate . The cook that delivered pizza to our table came checked on us asked how was the pizza and seen if we needed anything . We thanked him and told him pizza was great and we was gonna need a box he grabbed us one and thanked us for coming in . Lot of memories going here over my younger years . I live 2 hours away now so I dint get to visit aa much as I would like . It was nice to enjoy a great pizza with my mother while I was in town .“

“outstanding dining experience great pizza with superb service from bartender Megs“

“My girlfriend and I love this location! We drive from Louisville, not caring there could be tolls, for this pizza and customer service has been great. We’re actually getting this for our anniversary November 13th!“

“The five cheese macaroni is overpriced at over eight dollars for the amount you receive. Let's put it this way I cleaned the tin. The cheese is fabulous, but the price is about two dollars more than it's worth. If I had five more heaping tablespoons then it would be worth the eight dollars. I bought two of those and two salads for 32 bucks. I will tell you if you are a cheese aficionado then you will really enjoy this. also purchased the garden salad for my partner and the chicken Caesar for myself. The croutons are nice and garlicky, but too crunchy for me. I rarely enjoy croutons. I was going to pick up a pizza for later, but I try to keep my cost for two people on Easy food below $35. I like to give a little tip because they do have to run it out to the car if they're not delivering it to the home! With a 10% tip it was a little over 35 bucks. The only criticism is not enough macaroni and cheese for the cost. The plus is that the cheese is a premium blend, not cheap cheese at all!“

“People pick on Little Caesars all the time but we're lucky to have a good one here in New Albany. Store is clean, service is quick and polite, food is always fresh and hot and tastes pretty good for how affordable it is. What more could you want?“