6 Best Sandwich Shops near Newburgh

“Just came from the Diamond Ave. Store, the salads and sandwiches are all homemade with fresh baked breads. Excellent ! However the best part was having Becky and Jessica who work there fix the food correctly. They fixed everything as if it was there own. What more could someone ask for : great service , good food , and fair prices, five stars to this Lics crew.“

“We ordered online and picked the order up at the window. The staff member was extremely nice and let me know it would be just a minute on our fries, due to them being fresh! A minute later and I had our order in hand. We ordered the chicken teriyaki sub with extra meat, Italian sub wrap with extra meats, fries with cheese, and chocolate chunk cookies. We were impressed with everything we tried! We will definitely be back to try more!“

“I had an excellent experience at Jimmy John’s in Newburgh. From the moment I walked in, the employees were welcoming, polite, and attentive. They greeted us with a smile and worked efficiently while still making sure every order was accurate. It was clear that the staff takes pride in providing great customer service.

The restaurant itself was spotless and very well maintained. The dining area was clean, organized, and had a comfortable atmosphere that made it enjoyable to sit and eat. You could tell cleanliness is a priority here.

The food was fresh, flavorful, and prepared exactly the way I ordered it. My sandwich was made quickly with quality ingredients, and everything tasted great. It’s not always easy to find a place that combines fast service, friendly employees, a clean environment, and consistently good food, but this Jimmy John’s definitely does. I highly recommend this location and will absolutely be coming back.“

“Honestly, this is better than other sandwich shops! I got myself a number 5 club, it was so delicious. I like how the olive oil brings out the flavor, the meat was very delicious. I ended up getting a footlong. Im definitely coming back. Im making Jersey Mike's my number one sandwich 'go - to'!“

“I absolutely love your food, BUT your tea is not good! I know Newburgh water is terrible. I was told you paid several thousand dollars for a filter system! It is NOT working. I’ll get my tea from the N Greenriver store. You should check with Primetime. I know they use filtered water & they’re the only place in town that has good tea!! The cloudy pic is your store. The clear one is from N Greenriver. Big difference! It tastes so much better!“

“I drive past the subway on stacer road to come here. Seems like the same girls always working. Always friendly. Good food.“