16 Best Sandwich Shops in Evansville

“I hadnt had P.S. in quite awhile and im glad gf chose it because i dont think our dining experience would have been as good as was. Tim and Crystal were the only two working and they made quite a team. There were customers in front of us and behind us and they didn't missa beat. Highly recommend. If given the option Ida tapped 6 stars“

“I had such a wonderful lunch here recently. There are so many creative and delicious varieties of chicken salad to choose from, and everything tasted super fresh. The staff was incredibly friendly and made the whole experience even better. It is definitely my new go-to spot for a quick, healthy, and tasty meal.“

“The store was clean and well kept up. The food was good. The woman working there walked around with free cookies for Tuesday and handed me one in a mini ziplock bag. That was appreciated and different. Everyone working there was nice and helpful. I will go back when I'm in the area.“

“Placed an order for the drive thru window. We ordered 2 Croissants with Harvest Chicken Salad and Large glass of sweet tea. Ordering was easy and the food was ready when we arrived. We have eaten in at McAllisters many times and picked up food thru the drive thru. When we got home and opened the food, the Croissant sandwiches were smashed flat and the Croissants were definitely not fresh, they were stale. We were not going to drive all the way back to return them, but disappointed with our food.“

“Great food! Great staff who are friendly and professional. I frequent here for that reason!“

“Just came from the Diamond Ave. Store, the salads and sandwiches are all homemade with fresh baked breads. Excellent ! However the best part was having Becky and Jessica who work there fix the food correctly. They fixed everything as if it was there own. What more could someone ask for : great service , good food , and fair prices, five stars to this Lics crew.“

“The staff was super welcoming and knowledgeable for our first ever Jersey Mike's visit. The food was absolutely delicious. Definitely the best sub I've had in a long time!“

“There was 4 in our party and we had a few changes to our orders. Orders were 100% correct even with modifications. Two of us ordered gluten free bread, they asked if allergy or preference. Neither one of us had any symptoms of being glutened.
The staff was extremely friendly and accommodating. Our food was delicious and just as expected.“

“This subway was where I had my first official date with my ex (when we were together), and it was ok back then, but not 5 star worthy. I come back 4 years later after highschool finals, and it's completely flipped! The service was amazing, they were respectful and generous with the vision for my sandwich. They didn't rush me and had a smile every step of the way. Best Subway experience so far :)“

“I had a great experience and really enjoyed their service. The staff were very kind and welcoming to customers. Everything was clean, and the food was fresh. Since I’m a vegetarian, I usually only order veggie options, and this was the best Subway® I’ve ever visited. I also got freshly baked cookies, which were delicious.“

“This particular Subway restaurant is located right off of HWY 41 at what used to be the former entrance to the original Evansville Airport. They offer drive thru service and easy parking right at the front door. We were ordering sandwiches to go for our family. We left with four 12” sandwiches, a six inch sub, one foot long cookie, and one 20 oz soft drink for just under $40.00 totals we were using coupons received in the mail, but there is no way we could have got that much food to feed four at current fast food prices. All of the sandwiches were prepared fresh and they were delicious. We like this Subway location and will definitely be back in the future.“

“Clean, pleasant cashier, fast and didnt seem unhappy about making me a salad.🤣

Dietary restrictions: I had a salad by choice. It was good. Basically a sandwich without the bread

Wheelchair accessibility: Easy access“

“It’s back! Thank goodness! Not a ton of lunch options downtown that aren’t $$$. So, I’m not sure what happened to the one guy, but there’s a different guy working and the same lady. Both are very nice, very helpful, very responsive. (There was nothing wrong with the previous guy either, that I saw.) food is very standard subway. The employees are quick, efficient and nice.

You can get a sandwich for $5. Used to be a $5 footlong- now it’s a $5 six-inch, but downtown that’s the cheapest option and you can eat pretty healthily for that.“

“Ordered my sub through their website and picked it up it was fresh&ready. The staff were really nice & I didn’t mind that he forgot to put the ghost pepper on my sub because honestly it was perfect as is but he gave me a free sub coupon to make up for it! Will keep coming back!(:“

“Just what I needed after a hot day of moving to another town and unloading a huge truck into storage by myself. So much more refreshing than a hot meal at that time. Service was great, friendly employee. I had just dropped off the rental truck a few doors down and was having to wait on my ride to get off work. They were great about allowing me to hang out for a bit after I ate.“

“Thanks for your support of our hometown hockey team, the Evansville IceMen!“