22 Best Ice Cream Shops near Sellersburg

“Great ice cream and service!! Much better tasting food than that place in Borden that pretends to be an ice cream shop !!“

“The staff was very friendly, and the food was amazing.

Parking: Parking all the way around and offers the blue lighting which is better for security purposes if ever there is an issue but that I've ever had one.

Kid-friendliness: All the kids get a treat whether during visit or for a later date. Plus my kids love the high sets available. Makes them feel like giants!“

“Love. Love. Love! This place. Get the banana pudding ice cream and thank me later. Me and my wife love coming here an even my little boy. Great place to enjoy a snack and then walk next door for some smell good stuff. 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼“

“This is the best ice cream I've had in years. The butter pecan was amazing! Has the nostalgic real ice cream taste from when I was kid.“

“The scoop chicken dumplings are by far the best go check them out also there desserts are great 10/10 service and great people!!!!“

“This is our family’s “go to” ice cream shop. They always have amazing flavors to try! The owners are so friendly and the atmosphere is so inviting. If you’re looking for a local ice cream shop, look no further! Once you go, you will keep going back.“

“Strawberry Shortcake 🍰 Banana Chocolate Milkshake Yum“

“Tried their strawberry chocolate dipped ice cream sandwich and it was so good! Plus the atmosphere and decor is amazing and the owner is super sweet!“

“Best ice cream in the area.“

“Prepare to be amazed by the sheer magic that is The Comfy Cow ice cream haven! My heart is still fluttering from the extraordinary experience I had with the incredibly fabulous Carrie, the maestro behind my sons ice cream cake creation. Picture this: I was in a cake crisis, left high and dry by a completely different establishment that failed to deliver the pre-ordered masterpiece I had been eagerly anticipating for over a week. Desperation set in as I reached out to several places, only to be met with helpless shrugs and apologies. But then, as if guided by a force of fate itself, I was connected with the enchanting Chantel from The Comfy Cow. With their usual grace and charm, they turned the impossible into reality. Brace yourselves, because this ice cream haven usually crafts their delightful creations with a 3-day lead time. Yet, armed with a dash of determination and a sprinkle of fairy dust, Carrie Ramirez from The Comfy Cow's Middletown location emerged as the hero to create a breathtaking ice cream cake for my son in under 24 hours. Yes, you read that right - UNDER 24 hours! Let's talk dedication, folks. Carrie not only stayed late into the night but also emerged from her dreams to ensure that my son's ice cream cake would be an unforgettable masterpiece. My gratitude knows no bounds, and my joy is so immense it could power a thousand birthday parties. And now, dear readers, I must hang my head in shame as I admit that this review comes a tad fashionably late. You see, I was so wrapped up in the delight of this ice cream cake that the days simply slipped through my fingers like sand. The cake was triumphantly unveiled on July 8th, and here we are on the glorious August 9th, penning these words with heartfelt apologies for my tardiness. In conclusion, if you're looking to be transported to a world where ice cream cakes are created by fairy godmothers and dreams come true, look no further than The Comfy Cow. Every bite is a taste of the extraordinary, every moment spent with this wonder-worker, Carrie, is a memory to cherish. If her bosses are reading this, take heed: Carrie is the embodiment of ice cream enchantment, and if anyone deserves a raise, it's this magnificent soul. So, dear reader, don't just walk, run to The Comfy Cow and let their frozen wonders cast a spell on your taste buds. Trust me, it's an experience you'll be recounting for years to come.“

“I just want to shout out Olivia at the Saint Matthews location. I have never received better customer service in my entire life and I have worked in food service and customer service For 22 years. Last night at about 6 o’clock I ordered a six pack of the regular size Dubai chocolate cookies from the Saint Matthews location. I live in Fairdale and every other location you know relatively not all of them, but most of them were sold out and I was like well I’ll just go to Saint Matthews so I ordered them. I need the store didn’t close till 10 so I decided not to leave the house until eight thirtyish and I don’t drive. I took an Uber. So we get all the way there after paying you know nearly $60 for an Uber and almost 40 for cookies. We’re coming up to $100 just for these cookies at this point we get to Saint Matthews, my youngest daughter and I, and when we get there, the Baker tells us that they do not have any of the regular size Dubai chocolate cookies they only have four minis and I was like OK well can I get a refund and she said we can’t do it without my manager here and I was like some options are cookies I don’t want or no money back and I’ve already spent $100 like I was pretty bummed I wasn’t rude or anything and but I was just really bummed I felt super letdown so that I called my other children and had them pick out what they wanted and they weren’t too excited but you know she could hear their voice is like I guess I’ll take this now. I guess I’ll take that. Well. I alternate between all three of my kids Crumbl points so that they each can accumulate them and get little rewards and things so yesterday was my middle child’s Crumbl point day and my youngest daughter and I leave Crumbl with the cookies. We weren’t really excited about because we didn’t get the one so we wanted and go to target across the street and before we finish at target my middle child calls to tell me that the manager Olivia called and said that she understood where we were really disappointed by not getting the Dubai chocolate cookies and that she wanted to make it up to us especially because we pre-ordered them and came all the way from across town in an Uber to make it up to us and she was going to drop some off to us personally and I was like well that’s great thank you… And I was thinking she meant 10:30 in the morning because you know nobody wants to go across town after work you know after they’ve worked there their little buns off all day so we get home and 🦋💙👩‍👧My Daughter’s like oh well Miss Olivia’s gonna be here the manager and I was like when is she coming? She said oh she’s on her way. Olivia went above and beyond in every Single possible way. Not only did she come with cookies she got all of them to buy chocolate cookies and she made us a gorgeous little cute little box and she also brought a little goodie bag with two chocolate milks, and two white milks and then another little goodie bag she brought two Crumbl Tumblr cups two Crumbl pop socket sands two Crumbl sunglasses Crumbl tattoos and Crumbl stickers I mean she literally just went above and beyond oh and Crumbl keychains and not only that but she drove them all the way from Saint Matthews To Fairdale at 11 something at night she didn’t get to my house till 1130 so I know she didn’t get home until after midnight after working all day long and I I’ve just never had somebody go above and beyond that way in all of my entire life and she really just deserves a shout out. Not only should she get a shout out like she gave the kind of service that I will gladly pay an Uber to take me all the way across town to Saint Matthews. If it means going to Olivia‘s Crumbl.“

“This place is very tasty. They sell canned big reds for $1.25 but do not offer ice. The owner is always a big ball of sunshine. She’s so friendly. You better hurry up and get some ice cream before for it melts.

This ice cream shop was featured in a movie.
(Keep Your Distance)
Check out the Trailer out on You Tube!
Gill Bellows (Shawshank Redemption)
Kim Raver (Grey’s Anatomy)
Stacy Keach and many more talented people!
Really a good stalker flick!

Get a Big Red float they are the bomb!!!!“

“Stopped to grab a coffee and sign a contract with my realtor because it was close by and it was the perfect stop for a delicious lemonade, a pumpkin spice latte, and free wifi. I’ll definitely be back when I’m in the area again.“

“The maple square was amazing, and the service was fast but no one acknowledged me until they were handing me the food. Not a big deal but a simple wave would've made me feel more comfortable as it was my very first time in a Crumbl store.
That and how busy they were didn't help the atmosphere. I mean yay. You're busy. But it was a small area with 2 other people waiting and workers working their butt's off. Not a great atmosphere.“

“They were kind enough to do a blended peach chai tea latte. Something they had not done before. It was delicious!!“

“Nice atmosphere! Great steak burgers, chocolate milkshake, & fries ! Friendly staff !“

“Edit, 2025: left the original review up, because I admit when I'm wrong. This place is AMAZING. Good food, good beer at decent prices. I applaud them for doing an EXCELLENT job changing up their sides (they have a rotating side that is INVARIABLY good) and their beers. Kudos y'all, you've gained a lifelong customer.

Good food, menu is small but .. It's a burger place so... Don't be surprised. Line can be slow, but service is fast. Could be growing pains; I'll advise further after a few months.“

“you want home cooking this is the place! food is always hot and delicious 😋“

“The best of service in the local area's. Debbie is the best manage hands down and very compassionate about her customer's but yet very professional.“

“We Eat Culver's All the time but today was the first time we went inside. And Oh My Gosh. It was Amazing! So Hot and Perfect! Juicy Burger, Fries Crispy! But I have NEVER had a better Root Beer in my life!! I love this Jeffersonville Location!“

“Brittany at Fern Creek store was amazing. She was very helpful and professional and got us together for last minute treats for our son’s birthday!“

“Stopped by Culver’s for dinner and it was a really solid experience. The ButterBurger was hot and juicy, and you can tell it’s made fresh to order. The cheese curds were crispy and flavorful, and the frozen custard was the perfect way to end the meal. The place was clean and the staff were super friendly.

Only thing I’d say is the food took a little longer than typical fast food, but that’s probably because they make it fresh. Overall, definitely worth the wait and I’ll be coming back.“