Ice Cream Shops near Sellersburg

“We really like coming here and will continue however I have noticed that the tables are not wipe down from employees regularly just watch everyone’s reaction when it’s sticky on there tables i seriously got a large amount of a sticky arm I did not see it there and asked if they could wet a napkin for me the water fountain is turned off the manager had a short get together with the girls shaking his head no , they offered a cup of water, thank you I love my wife she wiped the other tables also I’m sure this was a health risk to ask for a wet towel and I apologized“

“The staff was very friendly, and the food was amazing.

Parking: Parking all the way around and offers the blue lighting which is better for security purposes if ever there is an issue but that I've ever had one.

Kid-friendliness: All the kids get a treat whether during visit or for a later date. Plus my kids love the high sets available. Makes them feel like giants!“

“Great service. Great ice cream. Great atmosphere for kids. Great prices!! Our first time there and we will be back.“

“This is our family’s “go to” ice cream shop. They always have amazing flavors to try! The owners are so friendly and the atmosphere is so inviting. If you’re looking for a local ice cream shop, look no further! Once you go, you will keep going back.“

“This is the best ice cream I've had in years. The butter pecan was amazing! Has the nostalgic real ice cream taste from when I was kid.“

“Yummy! Good service! Great environment!“

“Best ice cream shop in the area!“

“Tried their strawberry chocolate dipped ice cream sandwich and it was so good! Plus the atmosphere and decor is amazing and the owner is super sweet!“

“Im a slushie snob......when I tell you that their watermelon slushie is the best, I ain't no lie! Sooooo good!!“

“I love crumble! Its always clean and the cookies are great. Sometimes i wish they didnt change weekly tho

Parking: I always find parking close to the building

Wheelchair accessibility: Not a lot of wheelchair accessibility“

“I went to the Blak Koffee restaurant on April 28, 2025 and I was impressed! I’ve been knowing the owner for years and he is a great person. I highly recommend this a establishment to everyone.“

“Superman ice cream & chocolate covered cherry cyclones“

“My husband and I got the Let's Go Bananas Boom Shake, and it is a masterpiece! It has a banana Moonpie in it, with banana slices, vanilla wafers, and whipped cream. The shake itself has chunks of banana and vanilla wafers in it. Their ice cream is so fresh!“

“Best ice cream in the area.“

“This is response to the lady, I believe Jackie is the name, that had the horrible experience at the Widow's Walk Ice Creamery. You mentioned the owner is responsible for the, let's be honest...very few one star reviews for the business. Have you noticed the number of 5 star reviews that she is also responsible for? This business has endured several staff shortages over the years because it is just a mom and pop set up. They serve hundreds of people and she is always there to help. That is not just a business, but it is also her home. Nobody is coming to your place to tell you not to feed cats or anything else. What she does on the privacy of her own porch is none of your business. 692 reviews with an average of 4.5 is about as solid as you will find for an ice cream shop. You obviously took a misunderstanding and decided to attack on social media. This was not the best way to handle your poor experience. I truly think you should go back and talk to Jill and see about having a new experience that will mirror what the majority of patrons say about this small business in Indiana. This is a business that is not a chain or large scale business. It is family run and continues to please most people. Give them another shot and think about what you are saying within your posts. I understand focusing on the specific experience, but then you got personal with the cats and appears you exaggerated much of what you observed on that day. Great ice cream shop and super service, even on days when somebody calls in. Give them another try please!“

“The maple square was amazing, and the service was fast but no one acknowledged me until they were handing me the food. Not a big deal but a simple wave would've made me feel more comfortable as it was my very first time in a Crumbl store.
That and how busy they were didn't help the atmosphere. I mean yay. You're busy. But it was a small area with 2 other people waiting and workers working their butt's off. Not a great atmosphere.“

“Prepare to be amazed by the sheer magic that is The Comfy Cow ice cream haven! My heart is still fluttering from the extraordinary experience I had with the incredibly fabulous Carrie, the maestro behind my sons ice cream cake creation. Picture this: I was in a cake crisis, left high and dry by a completely different establishment that failed to deliver the pre-ordered masterpiece I had been eagerly anticipating for over a week. Desperation set in as I reached out to several places, only to be met with helpless shrugs and apologies. But then, as if guided by a force of fate itself, I was connected with the enchanting Chantel from The Comfy Cow. With their usual grace and charm, they turned the impossible into reality. Brace yourselves, because this ice cream haven usually crafts their delightful creations with a 3-day lead time. Yet, armed with a dash of determination and a sprinkle of fairy dust, Carrie Ramirez from The Comfy Cow's Middletown location emerged as the hero to create a breathtaking ice cream cake for my son in under 24 hours. Yes, you read that right - UNDER 24 hours! Let's talk dedication, folks. Carrie not only stayed late into the night but also emerged from her dreams to ensure that my son's ice cream cake would be an unforgettable masterpiece. My gratitude knows no bounds, and my joy is so immense it could power a thousand birthday parties. And now, dear readers, I must hang my head in shame as I admit that this review comes a tad fashionably late. You see, I was so wrapped up in the delight of this ice cream cake that the days simply slipped through my fingers like sand. The cake was triumphantly unveiled on July 8th, and here we are on the glorious August 9th, penning these words with heartfelt apologies for my tardiness. In conclusion, if you're looking to be transported to a world where ice cream cakes are created by fairy godmothers and dreams come true, look no further than The Comfy Cow. Every bite is a taste of the extraordinary, every moment spent with this wonder-worker, Carrie, is a memory to cherish. If her bosses are reading this, take heed: Carrie is the embodiment of ice cream enchantment, and if anyone deserves a raise, it's this magnificent soul. So, dear reader, don't just walk, run to The Comfy Cow and let their frozen wonders cast a spell on your taste buds. Trust me, it's an experience you'll be recounting for years to come.“

“They were kind enough to do a blended peach chai tea latte. Something they had not done before. It was delicious!!“

“Nice little hidden gem. Drove past this place plenty of times and then my wife suggested that we stop and try their ice cream. Now I try to get by there once a week or so. Good food and the price is reasonable. Give it a try I'm sure you'll like it!“

“Nice atmosphere! Great steak burgers, chocolate milkshake, & fries ! Friendly staff !“

“We Eat Culver's All the time but today was the first time we went inside. And Oh My Gosh. It was Amazing! So Hot and Perfect! Juicy Burger, Fries Crispy! But I have NEVER had a better Root Beer in my life!! I love this Jeffersonville Location!“

“Have not been here for a long time dt poor experience. Decided to give it another try w my cousin while she was in town from Canada. Really simple today- guy took oder at counter, we sat down, guy brought our food. We both had the lettuce wrap burgers. They were good, please know to be prepared for a super mess. In my opinion they should wrap w way more lettuce than they actually do to help w this messiness. We enjoyed our meal. It's not a super comfy place but it's not meant for you to stay long I don't think.“

“The best of service in the local area's. Debbie is the best manage hands down and very compassionate about her customer's but yet very professional.“

“Brittany at Fern Creek store was amazing. She was very helpful and professional and got us together for last minute treats for our son’s birthday!“

“ABSOLUTELY THE BEST CHEESEBURGER IVE EATEN! I got the double bacon cheeseburger, onion rings, and cheese curds. Everything was SCRUMPTIOUS!!! I recently moved to Indiana, and I've never heard of Culver's, decided to try them out, and was PLEASANTLY surprised.“

“The cashier has always been friendly and the food has always been good, they were very accommodating to my disability when ordering inside like filling up my drink when asked and offering to open up sauce packets, shout-out Levi for that service!

Parking: There's enough spots

Wheelchair accessibility: They have 2 handicap spots out front, the ramp is maintained and there's room to drive the chair in the restaurant“

“First time here. Late afternoon, so it wasn't very busy. TONS of options. The variety of options is almost endless when you start combining toppings. We decided on a flight of two cobblers and two banana puddings. They were all tasty. The flight of 4 comes with two cups of ice cream as well. The register person was pleasant and helpful. We had peach cobbler (of ccourse), caramel apple cobbler, pecan bourbon pudding and cheesecake pudding. The location is tucked in a corner in front of Walmart, kind of behind Cheddar's. Not the easiest place to navigate with the gauntlet of Veteran's Parkway and Walmart, but not too bad. For the combination of treats, we thought it was reasonably priced.“