22 Best Pizza Restaurants in Valparaiso

“Always a great experience dining in or carrying out. Love how fresh and delicious the ingredients are. From starters, to salad, wraps, calzones, or pizza. We’re always happy with whatever we get and it’s such a fun place to bring our kids too. Love the beer options as well. Thanks for making us happy customers.“

“great food and service. Fire grilled mushrooms rocked“

“The pizza is literally the best pizza in the area!“

“Meatballs are the best I’ve ever had and desserts are amazing. Best servers in the area. Can’t wait to try the box lunch, my favorite from Dish.“

“Had wrote a review a few days ago regarding a coupon not being utilized for a 50% off. I just deleted the review on accident but wanted to update to anyone who had read that. A manager contacted me and apologized for the mistake that had been made. The young man that had taken the order was fairly new and has now been educated on how to process that particular type of coupon. Managment was extremely apologetic and quick to recover and make me feel much better about the situation. They offered a credit for the WHOLE pizza!!! We well absolutely order from Rosati‘s again as that is our favorite pizza and the closest to Chicago as we can get in pizza.“

“The pizza had a perfect crust—crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. The toppings were fresh and generous, making each bite delicious. The atmosphere was relaxed, and the staff were friendly and welcoming. If you're looking for a great pizza place in Valparaiso, Uncle Menny's is definitely worth checking out!“

“First time here. Great pizza. Had the 2 slice lunch combo, and shoe bites. More than enough. Will definitely be back!“

“fast service and cheap good food“

“I had an antipasta salad and brownie.
The antipasta was delicious with the raspberry vinegrette, it is also enough for me to eat again tomorrow. I also got one of their house brownies, which was unlike any brownie I've ever had before. Awesome presentation on the brownie too, it stayed in place on its way here.
Ice cold pop wrapped in foil. Refreshing and low priced.“

“Great wings, cold drinks, hot staff, what more could you want??“

“Went on Valentines Day, was told about an hour wait, gave them my phone number and was going to get a call when my table was ready. They had a cancellation and my table was ready in 15 minutes, not bad for 4PM on a Saturday during V-Day. Food was absolutely delicious, good portions, service was great. It was very busy but they were 100% on top of things, can't wait to go back.“

“Today, July 18th, we had my grandson's birthday party at Gelsosomo's Pizzeria Valparaiso, there was 15 of us there & our server Tabitha was awesome! She did an outstanding job! The pizzas were amazing! I highly recommend Gelsosemo’s Pizzeria Valparaiso!“

“I got the fried banana pepper rings and the Philly cheese steak sandwich. The banana peppers where the star of the show! So good I couldn't even eat much of my sandwich.
The waitress (Riley) did a great job! Very attentive and friendly.
Would definitely recommend everyone give it a try.“

“Tonight me, my fiance and little sister went to Zao Island and went on the GoKarts. We did all the laps and got called back in. While us three were stopped ready to get out, I heard a mom say “slow down” and her child drove into the back of my cart, didn’t brake at all and I hit my head so hard on the back of my seat. To the mom, you and your little boy are not at fault at all! The workers should’ve said slow down or show them how to brake beforehand. They didn’t even check if any of us were okay afterwards. I think there needs to be an age restriction on the GoKarts or at least a mandatory demonstration for the little ones before they drive. I absolutely love Zao and mean no harm but the workers for the GoKarts needed to handle the situation better for the future. 🫶🏻“

“There someone who works at this Casey’s named Zach. He was a very respectful young man and the other people working there were as well. I was hoping that this review could possibly get them in a better position than what he’s at right now or a raise. I’m not the type of person to write reviews, but Zach was such a respectful person so I had the need to write a review.“

“11/1/25. The pizza was awesome but the dining experience was not. We arrived about 45 minutes after they opened for the day and the dining area was a mess! Tables weren’t cleaned off and the floor was dirty. It almost looked like the mess was from the night before because the dining room lights weren’t even turned on yet when we walked in. During our stay not a single employee came out to cleaned anything up and there was at least 4 of them that I saw. The gentleman who took our order was very helpful & friendly but the manager on shift that we had a brief encounter with was not! She was unprofessional and rude.“

“Tonight me, my fiance and little sister went to Zao Island and went on the GoKarts. We did all the laps and got called back in. While us three were stopped ready to get out, I heard a mom say “slow down” and her child drove into the back of my cart, didn’t brake at all and I hit my head so hard on the back of my seat. To the mom, you and your little boy are not at fault at all! The workers should’ve said slow down or show them how to brake beforehand. They didn’t even check if any of us were okay afterwards. I think there needs to be an age restriction on the GoKarts or at least a mandatory demonstration for the little ones before they drive. I absolutely love Zao and mean no harm but the workers for the GoKarts needed to handle the situation better for the future. 🫶🏻“

“Went in today with my son and infant daughter. There was a miscommunication between myself and the cashier that resulted in not having a combo added to one of the sandwiches. The store was quick to solve the problem. A bit later we had another issue with the sausage being burnt. I hated to even say anything because I had already had the issue with the combo but my son wasn’t going to eat the sandwich because it was burnt. The manager didn’t even hesitate and made him a fresh sandwich. Once that was solved everything was amazing. The food was hot and delicious. The beef was tender and the bread perfection. The manager and her entire team were super friendly and took great care of us.

Highly recommend the Valpo Buona!“

“Chicago style that makes a great party dish.“

“Always fast and fresh, the one time we had an issue they more than fixed it. Great locally owned franchise that cares about serving Valparaiso.“

“Well everyone always tells me if you have bad service once you should always try again. Well I did and guess what service was still bad. With only 9 people in the bar area we asked for menus and drinks. We got the drinks but the bartender was too busy on her phone to come back and take our order. After waiting almost 30 minutes I walked out. I use to go there at least three times a week. Never again.“

“Great service from employees, pizza and wings are also delicious! Will come back.“