50 Best Pizza Restaurants in Lexington

“am very pocky with my Pizza & cheese. the thickness was good for me. the sauce is delicious & variation of pizzas is very good. you can order bigger pizzas for catering. i will be visiting more often! the staff is making a lot of effort to make people happy!“

“First time to eat here. Simply put, the food was delicious! Loved the wings, pizza, Greek salad, and the Brussels & Taters. I highly recommend PieTana.“

“Thank you Kevin for bringing our town Chicago to KY. Missed our food so much.“

“We're from Ohio.. Here in Lexington for Andre Bocelli.. Decided to stop in and have some pizza and what I term as loaded nachos.. Absolutely delicious and the hospitality that Emily and Rachel gave was wonderful!! Thank you so much for everything!!!“

“Tried this place for the first time today. The best pizza in Lexington! Definitely recommend the NY-Hand tossed crust!“

“We love their calzones! Highly Recommend“

“excellent food. one of the best pizzas we've had in Kentucky hands down. freshly made, super quick and always delicious. staff are amazing with kids and friendly and entire place is super clean and relaxed and comfortable. highly recommend“

“Pizza is nothing short of fantastic- great service as well!“

“My personal experience was fantastic, people were telling me how good the food and the customer service was, so I wanted to experience it myself and when I got there I was greeted by a young man name Andrew I saw him working his tail off to make sure my pizza was made right and oh boy can I tell you that pizza was the best pizza I have ever had, I will be coming back here take my money🤑💰💰“

“My three daughters and I ate at Smashing Tomato last night and as usual the food was absolutely amazing and the service was outstanding. We’re so lucky to have real Neapolitan pizza restaurant in Lex.“

“The Posh Masterpiece is not just a pizza, it’s a full-blown aristocratic experience for your face. The moment I took a bite, my credit score went up, my vocabulary became 17% more sophisticated, and I spontaneously developed a British accent that scared my coworkers.

And the staff at Mod Pizza? Angels in aprons. These culinary artisans lovingly crafted my pie with the care of a grandmother stitching a quilt... if your grandma was also a badass with a pizza oven.

This pizza didn’t just feed me. It elevated me. I walked in hungry and left emotionally fulfilled, spiritually awakened, and possibly knighted.

10/10 Would sell my left sock to eat again.“

“Some of the best food that Lexington, Ky has to offer!“

“Have been here 3 times already. Very nice friendly staff, food is great , reasonably priced. Love the fact I can order on line and schedule pick up for a later date. Will defiantly be ordering again.“

“Great service and good first time there melissa was great help ordering“

“steak and cheesy to please me🔥🤷🏿‍♂️“

“Kid friendly atmosphere and tasty pizza!“

“Never ate here before but the review left in LoL group had me really proud of this place! Picture in comments“

“Love the pizza. Sorely disappointed that they stopped their curbside service. With a bad knee it’s difficult to walk in there to get our pizza

Vegetarian options: Make your own pizza so plenty of options

Parking: No curbside service

Kid-friendliness: Kids should love this place

Wheelchair accessibility: Not very accessible. Used to provide curbside service, but they don’t any more“

“I have been a customer of the Richmond Rd. Donato's for many years. Kim is a treasure. Always friendly, professional and provides excellent service. The food is always fresh and delicious.
Thank you Donato's for bringing back the Chicken Vegy Medley!“

“My family has frequented this Donato’s location for probably two decades now, and I can say we’ve always had great service and amazing food every time. We love the Founder’s Favorite and Mariachi Chicken pizzas, and we always order them whenever we get together. David L was friendly and efficient, and we even got our order earlier than expected. Can’t recommend this place enough!!“

“I had the most amazing service by an employee named Kemya, she was funny and sweet. She was fast with my food, everything was perfect, the food was 10/10 as well and Ms. Kemya. One of my best experiences at a restaurant. Would definitely go again!!“

“While the old man can be grouchy he puts a great spin on it that wil give you that home town pizza vibe which honestly is fantastic. The price may seem a few dollars more than the main stream pizza places but they are far more filling better details to the dough and sauce you will find that it fills you up about twice as much as if you went else where. Always satisfied with the service and pizza and it taste even better the next day when reheated too.

Vegetarian options: Depends on if you can eat cheese they have veggie pizza heck will even make them without cheese as long as your polite they will make it anyway you specify right then and there but be clear and simple on the instructions.“

“Food was great, and the service was fantastic! Server came by several times to be sure we had everything we needed. Great place to eat.“

“Great new York style pizza! crumbled sausage was fantastic. Will be back for sure.“

“Some of the best pizza 🍕 ever. Everyone must try the BBQ chicken it really is to die for.“

“Great pizza and great service… Diffidently be returning..Maybe this week..super close to The home 2 suites hotel..“

“We have been ordering Big City Pizza for months now. I keep forgetting to add a review. It seriously is the best pizza and cheese sticks in town. Delivery is fast! If you love pizza, give them a try. You won’t be sorry! Delicious!!!🍕“

“While visiting Lexington we wanted to try something new So this was our First time trying Jets Pizza The Store was clean Employees were friendly and helpful Pizza was delicious Highly recommend“

“We have eaten here several times and have enjoyed our meals very much. Unfortunately, last night did not go as well. We sat in a booth where I had a clear view of the food prep area as the swinging door into the area did not close when a staff member entered. As we were waiting for our food, I watched and an employee sitting inside the door was on his phone and vaping the entire time, until he finally got up and moved out of sight. The service was slower than we have experienced in the past, seemed very disorganized. Not to mention that the metal wall next to our booth was filthy.“

“I keep trying to give you all a chance because the food is actually delicious but every single time I have ordered the order has been wrong. This time, the staff (including the red headed manager) were rude and the food took multiple hours when we were told 40 minutes. Do better! Or don't, I won't be back again and I'd say the 20 other customers who complained while I was there waiting, won't be back either! It's a darn shame, so much potential.“

“whomever is putting out the pizzas tonight is killing it ! Just got a large meat lovers that was absolutely LOADED!! Great Job !“

“We had a fantastic experience at the Nicholasville Rd. Fazoli's. 4 of us stopped in for lunch and we were so glad we did. Jessica took great care of us down to every extra cup of sauce and just gave us great service and smiles. The stuffed shells were cheese heaven. I've never been an alfredo girly but I was converted for today! Better than the jarred stuff from the grocery store imo. All in all the food was just as great as the home cooked Italian food I grew up with up north.
Dez hooked us up with extra breadsticks to take home. We will be coming back to try the Italian donuts!“

“Let me start by saying the food is FANTASTIC! West Coast is one of the best pizza places in town. Every order is freshly made, toppings are top notch and their sauces are perfect for dipping.
However buyer beware (and this pains me to tell you this). The last 3 times we have ordered carryout when the card reader is turned towards me the employee added a tip without my consent! This is shady and it needs to stop immediately. I don't mind tipping for great food but this should be left to the patron and not the employees“

“10/25/25 Today I hosted a Car Show for the Lexington Firefighters Toy Program at Frederick Douglass HS. During set up our Food Truck had to cancel and it left me scrambling on what to do to feed the people. I called a few places in hopes to get someone out with no luck. On a whim I called Jets and explained what happened to the Manager who immediately agreed to help! They donated pizza for us without hesitation. I can’t tell you how grateful I am for that! THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR HELPING MAKE TODAY SUCCESSFUL!

(Photo credit not mine)“

“Always the best, fast delivery, pizza cooked to perfection, can’t say enough great things about this location. Delivery drivers are always polite and courteous. I’ve lived near here for 8 years now, order pizza about 1X a month, may have had one order wrong (online order so who knows what happened) but 99% of the time, it’s perfect.“

“Me and my friend walked here after shopping at the mall. We had gotten a 8 inch pepperoni pizza and it was alright, the pizza was just slap full of pepperonis lol! The worker there gave us free refills on our drinks was so nice and it was very chill and wonderful there! amazing service!“

“We are from NYC and this is the best pizza just like from NYC. Excellent sauce cheese pepperoni and good oil on top. The best!!! You have to go there . hugh slices too. Good and hot too mouth watering pizza“

“Hunt Brothers Pizza is a great pizza for anybody searching for really good tasting food the employees are always very respectful their Pizza is also never undercooked or overcooked it is always just right with a perfect amount of toppings“

“this review is for the new Rexburg location in Mother hibbards have stopped in there four times within the last week to try the food and they never have anything in the warmer. no pizzas nothing. I went in there tonight. no food in the warmer. the kids that work there are sitting on the floor up against the wall doing absolutely nothing. Do they only serve Pizza at lunch and zero food for dinner? there's nothing anywhere that says what times they have food what time? they don't have food so tonight I went from hangar 54 right over to Valley wide and got me a personal pizza and now I'm headed to work.“

“We asked for extra seasoning on our Italian cheese bread and they exceeded our expectation. We did have to wait for it due to us ordering so 30 minutes before closing. So when the lady brought it to us she asked us to check to make sure it was enough. She was also very kind and greeted us with a smile.“

“This pizza is incredible. Cannot believe that I got it from a gas station“

“Hunt Brothers Pizza is a great pizza for anybody searching for really good tasting food the employees are always very respectful their Pizza is also never undercooked or overcooked it is always just right with a perfect amount of toppings“

“Hunt Brothers Pizza is a great pizza for anybody searching for really good tasting food the employees are always very respectful their Pizza is also never undercooked or overcooked it is always just right with a perfect amount of toppings“

“My boyfriend and I are from Youngstown Ohio and we're looking for a nice place to eat dinner..
. We found Sutton's and were very happy with our discovery! The food was delicious, our waitress, Michelle, was was excellent, and the atmosphere was warm and friendly.“

“Great environment and the shrimp and grits are to die for!“

“Service was excellent best spaghetti sauce blue cheese is like my moms reasonable price delicious“

“Pretty good location for parties! The best part of this place is the price, where you can get access to the arcade and unlimited access to the buffet. First off, the arcade is pretty nice, it has a pretty substantial amount of games to play, with my favorite probably being the one where you punch this bag super hard and you get a score based on how hard you hit it. For the buffet, it’s honestly pretty lackluster. There is an okay amount of options to choose from, but most of it isn’t very good and isn’t super warm or anything. The tea (sweet and unsweet) isn’t cold so you’re just drinking this lukewarm tea and eating this lukewarm pizza and it overall just isn't a super great experience. Just due to its nature, the whole environment is pretty gross, being an arcade for children and all, but bumper cards were fun and the staff is pretty nice. Overall worth a shot, especially if you have little ones.“

“The food and staff are amazing!! The food is fresh and well worth the price. Highly recommended!“