13 Best Seafood Restaurants in Edgartown

The Covington Restaurant American • $$$
52 Main St, Edgartown

Customers` Favorites

Sweet Potato Rolls with Herb Butter
Walnut Pesto Ricotta Gnocchi
Island Farmstand Salad
Cannellini Bean Hummus
Three Sisters Salad
Pickled Cucumbers
Halibut Aguachile
Spicy Cucumbers
Mushroom Ragu
Smoked Beets

“Beautiful restaurant with amazing food and great staff. The vegan options are superb and absolutely delicious. Everything is presented beautifully and is super tasty. Special shout out to the sweet & spicy cucumbers which were incredible, and the home made bread is divine! This was a great choice for dining whilst in Marthas Vineyard!“

4.5 Superb55 Reviews
Square Rigger Restaurant Seafood • $$
225 Edgartown-Vineyard Haven Rd, Edgartown

Customers` Favorites

New England Clam Chowder
Grilled Stuffed Lobster
Pan Seared Scallops
Baked Clam Casino
Grilled Swordfish
Hot Lobster Roll
Grilled Lobster
Lobster Bisque
Seafood Paella
Grilled Salmon

“Just had a delicious dinner, if you have never been or haven't visited in a while, you should definitely stop in!!!“

4.4 Superb118 Reviews
Bettini Restaurant Seafood
Harbor View Hotel, 131 N Water St, Edgartown

Customers` Favorites

Pan Roasted Organic Half Chicken
Prime Beef Ribeye Carpaccio
Pan Roasted Vineyard Fluke
Whipped Mashed Potatoes
Yellowfin Tuna Tartare
Porterhouse Pork Chop
Mushroom Pappardelle
Belgian Endive Salad
Prime NY Strip 16oz
Casarecce Bolognese

“Food is so good. And the ambience is perfect. Love this resto.“

4.2 Good215 Reviews
19 Raw Oyster Bar Seafood • $$$
19 Church St, Edgartown

Customers` Favorites

Lobster and Caviar Slider
Oysters on the Half Shell
Shrimp Fried Rice
Lobster Bolognese
Shrimp and Grits
Charred Octopus
Tuna Carpaccio
Mac and Cheese
Oyster Platter
Oyster Shooter

“The oysters were delicious…all local…and the presentation was fantastic! Definitely recommend if in Edgartown! We even took the shells (asked of course) because the were so pretty!“

4.2 Good126 Reviews
Edgartown Yacht Club Seafood
1 Dock St #1309, Edgartown
5 Superb1 Reviews
Quarterdeck Restaurant Seafood • $$
29 Dock St, Edgartown

Customers` Favorites

Clam Strip Platter
Fish Sandwich
Fish and Chips
Clam Chowder
Cheeseburger
Lobster Roll
Clam Strips
Onion Rings
Burger

“No tables, no cash. Takeout only.But this seafood shack represents the best value in the island and it is very conveniently located in the heart of Edgartown.Lobster roll is pretty solid. New England clam chowder is tasty. Clam strips and other fried foods are beyond edible. Tastes like all ingredients are from the frozen section of Restaurant Depot, but there is absolutely nothing wrong with that as long as the line cook knows how to prepare those frozen foods. And they do more than an adequate job at it.I was getting a little bit tired of overpriced and under-portioned meals at the island. And I discovered this place and it was a treat.“

3.4 Good8 Reviews
The Seafood Shanty Seafood • $$
31 Dock St, Edgartown

Customers` Favorites

Hot Buttered Lobster Roll with French Fries
Fish Tacos with Pineapple Mango Salsa
Island's Best & Biggest Lobster Roll
New England Clam Chowder
Mussels Shanty Style
Lobster Quesadilla
California Roll
Served w Fries
Fried Calamari
Fish Sandwich

“Great views and staff! This is a place you want to drink a beer with friends on the weekend!“

4 Good156 Reviews
The Fish House Seafood Markets • $$
Martha's Vineyard, 17 Airport Rd, Edgartown

“The fried clams here are absolutely elite - a delicate crispy batter and the freshest clams. The lobster roll is a league of its own - has celery and is slightly more mayo-y than others but I think it’s absolutely delicious, one of my absolute favorites and I’m very picky about my lobster rolls. The lobster roll and clams may be a little smaller than the gigantic options available elsewhere, but to me quality is more important than quantity. Top notch, I wouldn’t leave the Vineyard without these two of my favorites!“

4.7 Superb27 Reviews
The Wharf Seafood • $$
3 Main St, Edgartown

Customers` Favorites

Friday Special Prime Rib and a Burger
New England Clam Chowder
Fried Shrimp & Chips
Fishermans Platter
Fried Shrimp
Chowder Fries
Fish & Chips
Lobster Roll
Salad
Steak

“Great bar staff, food and service! More of a year-round Vineyarder’s destination.“

3.5 Good54 Reviews
Among the Flowers Cafe American • $
17 Mayhew Ln, Edgartown

Customers` Favorites

Quiche with Fresh Fruit
Breakfast Sandwich
Acai Bowl
Toast
Salad

“I love this place! We came everyday this week and ordered a variety of delicious meals. WOW!“

4.3 Superb65 Reviews
The Airport Marketplace Seafood • $$
17 Airport Rd, Edgartown

“Great selection of beers.“

4.8 Superb6 Reviews
The Dunes New American • $$$
31 Dunes Rd, Edgartown

Customers` Favorites

Croissant

“My Empress Gin martini (Aka: The Dunes) was delightful. Thank you Billy & Shane for all the attention.“

3.7 Good42 Reviews
Atlantic fish & Chop House Steak House • $$$
2 Main St, Edgartown

Customers` Favorites

Street Style Shawarma Tacos
Char-Broiled Oysters
Lobster Arugula Salad
Lobster Croissant
Atlantic Burger
Chocolate Cake
Lobster Salad
Osso Bucco
Burrata
Steak

“Crystal was amazing. Our table was not ready and she personally assured it was cleaned ( did it herself ) and the sat us. Made us feel very comfortable for a great Sunday afternoon party with DJ Rockwell. Great time and great food. Thanks“

3.6 Good109 Reviews

You May Also Like