38 Best American Restaurants near Fairplay

“Just had a lovely brunch/lunch at Bistro 112. The food was excellent and the staff was wonderful. This restaurant hits all the marks!! Great dining experience!“

“Love the Broad Axe! The chefs and bartenders are great! And I really enjoy the live music nights. 🎶🎸🥁“

“Riks is a total star. When you're standing in front of the restaurant you're in a parking lot of a an old shopping center. Once inside you're in a contemporary bar and restaurant. I believe that much of the work in creating the space was performed by the then staff, many of whom worked together with owners at a prior restaurant. The food is wonderful, creative, fresh and satisfying. My favorites include a smoked salmon salmon carpoccio (sorry about the spelling). A great selection of salads with the ability to. add to them crab cake chicken etc. The sandwiches range from a Reuben to a grilled mahi mahi .My favorite when I want a substantial dinner is their short ribs and mashed potatoes. Writing this review has just made me hungry. Guess where I'm going for an early dinner. Prices are VERY reasonable“

“Undoubtedly one of the most delicious experiences we’ve ever enjoyed. Atmosphere, service, and quality is presented in a perfect way. Worth the trip, no matter how far your journey.“

“Such a wonderful place! Delicious food, inspired chef, creative ideas in different events...I would love to go there daily...“

“Wife and I came across this place after a long day. Great food and awesome outdoor dining and bar area. Karen was wonderful and attentive. She always checked on us and even laughed at my lame jokes and was fun about it. You get a well balance of great food, price and atmosphere. They have a fun menu too!

Thanks Karen for helping us end our day on a good note! 😀“

“Had me a burger over at Jenny’s Restaurant, and I’ll tell ya, it was mighty fine eatin. Patty was juicy, bun was soft, and they didn’t skimp on the fixin’s. Fries come out hot and crispy just like they oughta be. Service was friendly too, folks checked in to make sure I had what I needed. If you’re hungry for a good ol’ burger, Jenny’s is the place to stop.“

“We had dinner on the weekend. Great Food and service“

“I love this place, the food is all good, everything on the menu is so good, the omelets are one of the best omelets ove ever had before.
The service wasnt amazing the last time, but thats far from me taking it down a star.
If you have a chance stop by hear, the food is worth it, amazing price point too and you get so much.“

“One of my favorites! The food is fantastic and carefully prepared. If the weather is fine, definitely get a table outside. The trickling of the water and the shade of the trees is so charming and will bring an already great meal to perfection. The people who work here are wonderful and make everyone feel welcome. Simply, this place is a real gem.“

“Me and a group went there for karaoke. Beautiful place, prices seemed a little high but the food was phenomenal so we didnt mind. I had a prime rib sandwich with fries and 3 domestic beers was about $32. Waitress was very friendly and gorgeous. There are booths , tables and a bar also a nice couch lounge area in the back the seats were all padded and comfortable we were there for many hours singing so that was an important key takeaway for us. With it being downtown there is limited free parking we had to park in the parking garage around back I think that was about $8 for about 4hrs. Overall this place should succeed in the future I'm not a snob when drinking but the drink menu looked like it could accommodate anyone's tastes or preferences. Excellent place for dinner, date or on a night they have entertainment.“

“Great food. We get breakfast because thats what we like to eat. Club sandwiches and burgers are great also. Heather the waitress was the best“

“Visiting Antietam battle site on the way to Gettysburg. Great location with a fun brew pub, sports bar and Starbucks in the same shopping plaza. Clean and quiet room, comfortable bed, nice shower, helpful friendly staff. Wish all hotels offered window spray and paper towels available to clean car windshields.“

“Wonderful food. Great service.“

“Beautifully decorated for the holidays. The food was delicious, homemade, attention to detail, loved it!“

“I got the Pesto Panini and my wife got the Cabo Sandwich. My son got a 10in Pepperoni pizza and my other son got a Quesadilla. Everything was amazing! We have been customers for 15 years. We have never had a bad meal from Cafe del Sol. This where we take family when they visit from our of town!“

“Stopped in for dinner food was good but service was great thanks to Mary!!!“

“I got a to-go order & the Server/Bartender was on point. It was kind of hard to pull up a menu, so she helped me pick out the top flavors quick & easy for a wing order (my fav). Then upon arrival, I accidently had my card turned off and instead of her coming back telling me how it was denied - she knew what was up ... or atleast gave me the chance vs embarassing me. I just thought that was so sweet how she handled it... kudos. It seems hard to find decent customer service out here these days! She made it seem so easy ❤️“

“We traveled to Black Rock to meet up with family last evening. The food was delicious as usual, but what really stood out was our amazing server Erin. She went above and beyond. What a joy, you are blessed to have her as part of your staff. Highly recommend the food and the experience!“

“My husband and I came into Cracker Barrel for dinner. Seth was our server and waited on us the entire time. I just wanted to let you know how friendly and attentive he was to us. Dinner was an especially great time meeting with Seth and he provided outstanding service. The food is always good at Cracker Barrel and Seth was a pleasant surprise. Looking forward to coming back and we will be requesting Seth again as our server.“

“Love this place it’s my 3rd time to be here 🖤🫶🏻“

“Fantastic, scrumptious food! Def go here when in Shepherdstown.“

“Our “go-to” spot! Robert is a great bartender! Foods good, drinks are great, and the crowd is very welcoming!“

“Wings are smoked and nice and crispy, fresh cut fries, and onion rings are great. Definitely coming back. Paige was awesome!! She does it all and does it well!“

“Wings on Thursdays are the BEST!“

“Ben and Tay were fabulous and very prompt. Super friendly and informative about the menu. First time back in years and now we will definitely be back more often! Please make the boils a permanent menu option. That's literally the reason we come. Lol.“

“My wife and I had a delicious meal , as always. We were served by Allison , her service was excellent and very efficient. As an employee , I hope she is appreciated.“

“Just stopped in for lunch with my boys. The chicken cheese steak was on point. my youngest is picky with his Mac n cheese him and his brother devoured it. Great local spot for food.“

“Love the bar and the staff!“

“Our server Kyle was great! They were able to make me foods safe for me to eat due to my food allergies (THANK YOU!!). Others in my party loved the fresh, homemade rolls (I’m allergic, so couldn’t eat them, but they looked amazing!).
The only downside was the extra long wait. We were told 30-40 minutes, but the wait was over 50 minutes. It was the day after Valentine’s Day, so I’d guess this wasn’t normal. You can make reservations online, I’d highly suggest it!

Dietary restrictions: I let them know my allergies and they worked to make me a great meal!“

“Hear me out, this was the cleanest, most friendly Waffle House I’ve ever set foot in. Now I’m not above sticky floors and harried employees coming off their smoke break. I understand that’s just a part of the WH experience. But this was a nice change of pace. Great service, great food 10/10“

“Since Stephanie started working there...we WILL start coming back again AND I'm "upping" this rating to FIVE stars! ?????We stopped frequenting for about 3 years because the bartending staff was pretty glum and unwelcoming.Yay, Ms. Stephanie for bringing the uppity AND chill vibes back into Pete's! ??“

“Friendly service staff both bar and floor“

“I recently had the pleasure of dining at Rumsey Tavern for the first time, and it was an amazing experience! The food was absolutely delicious! I got the Smash Burger and the Brussel sprouts, Let me tell you, they were bursting with flavor. The atmosphere was warm and inviting, making it the perfect spot for a memorable meal. Christine, our server was friendly and attentive, ensuring we had everything we needed. I can't wait to go back and try more of their amazing menu. Highly recommend it to anyone looking for a fantastic dining experience! This place is a hiding Gem!!!!“

“Stoped here a few times over the years.Located in Hagerstown so it’s near a lot of shopping and off interstate. Plenty of parking. It’s a usual spot of us because we are traveling through Hagerstown Maryland a lot. Great food. Always served really fast and always cooked perfectly. The staff is friendly and helpful. The location is always clean and in good condition. There is plenty of parking and easily accessible to everyone. The waffles are great as always and the breakfast is the best in town.

Parking: Plenty of parking.

Kid-friendliness: Good for the whole family.

Wheelchair accessibility: Yes“

“I think it's weird how busy the Dennys across the street from this place is and how this place is like a ghost town. The food here is better, cheaper and you don't have to wait for a hour to actually get your food.
I think many people (like us) forget it's even here.
The food was great, service was great. We were able to be seated as soon as we got there on a Saturday morning. We will definitely be back.“

“We love visiting here and usually go every Sunday that we can! We like to ask for Keisha to be our server. The food is always amazing and Keisha is a wonderful waitress! Can’t wait to go back“