50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Cumberland

“Moved to Gray recently , was asking around about pizza, as I grew up in NY and we eat it 3 days a week down there . Anyway , I ordered a plain cheese pizza the first time I went, and that was so good I just did the same tonight. Very close to NY style pizza, more specifically long island pizza where I grew up.. They definitely put some good stuff in their dough as it is seriously on another level of anywhere else I been in 13 years in Maine . And it being a HOP, looking forward to getting the Gyro next!!“

“I have been going here since I was very young. Maria has always been the hardest dedicated worker I've ever met. She always made the pizza perfect. Always recommended. I watched Maria's kids grow up into young adults and work there as well. Be in soon Maria“

“We wandered in today and sat at the bar. We were so impressed with both the service and the food. The bartender was cordial, friendly, and extremely attentive. We had a flatbread that was absolutely delicious and chicken, bacon ranch salad with house made ranch that was exceptional. Closer than any. We don’t have a flatbread company near our home sure wish we did.“

“Just the best 🥰 I recommend they’re made to order cannolis and raspberry linzers 😍 and the best types of people work here too, just so freaking kind!!“

“Went for a lupper date with my husband on the referral of a friend. Had the Natalie house drink which was well balanced and bright for us gin lovers. Enjoyed thier spin on Poutine with a tater tots base. Lots of goo goodness with bacon and sausage. Sausage pizza with Vodka sauce had real Greek olives and was delicious. Will be back again!“

“Fantastic beer. The owner and her Husband are wonderful to be around. I’ll definitely be back.“

“Some of the best beer in Southern Maine, always a ton on tap“

“Love Sev’s!!! Great beer selection, and amazing pizzas! Staff is always friendly and check out is always quick!! I tell all my friends to grab an authentic Italian from Sev’s in Westbrook!“

“A hidden gem for when you don’t want to head into the old port. :)“

“Over the weekend we had our wedding reception at the Ogunquit location, and it was absolutely perfect! Everything turned out better than we could have imagined. The service was exceptional, and every staff member we interacted with was so kind, professional, and attentive. The entire day ran seamlessly thanks to their incredible team — they truly went above and beyond to make our day so special. We couldn’t have been happier and can’t wait to come back for dinner soon to relive a little of the magic!“

“Good food, good service, lovely“

“Best pizza around. Try the hamburger with pepperoni onion and mushroom! Meatballs are great too! Cold beers next door too!“

“Found this great restaurant while on vacation. The Acadia Apple /Turkey sandwich is on my top five best ever sandwiches. Absolute perfection. My hubby fell in love with his salad and not knowing how large the wrap was he tried to eat that too. Oh my this place is on my must return list. I have to work my way through the rest of the menu“

“Fire pizza service everything about this place is awesome if you haven’t tried not tried it your losing out amazing food get some“

“My oh my… can you say taste bud explosion! Have been exclusively patronizing George's Foreside House of Pizza for ten years now. And no plans to stop :)
Tried ‘em all, but when you find the best… well, you know the rest of the story.“

“Always a great lunch! These guys are on point with their food. But also their community. These guys are always helping folks in the Yarmouth community! Fundraisers ect. Staff always friendly & efficient. Hearty portions!! Always nice to stop in & see other friends!“

“…Yesterday-finally-my ladyfriend & I got our 1st 2 large Chicken Parm “bucket list” subs with melty Provolone: They have now since taken the pole position of bein our newest local favorites !!! D says the counter lady was super nice & hopes she got herself one made for din din 🇮🇹“

“Brought my family here for lunch this afternoon! Wonderful food and friendly! Was great place to come sit with the family, also has take out! We will for sure be back! 💚“

“I got the Greek Pizza last night. 10 in size which is the only size. Had it to go and once I got to it for eating it was delicious. Cost about $17 which at first I thought was a lot. But it is worth the money for me. When you park there please don't park behind the building, that is for employees. I found out by having a unpleasant talk with the manager/owner. No hard feelings sir“

“Great service, lovely atmosphere and the food was delicious. Pizza was the star of the show, but the rye cavatelli was a nice, bright dish.

Pasta serving was too small for the rather high price, but supporting quality neighborhood places like this outweighs the slight wincing at the final bill.“

“Great atmosphere and great food.❤️“

“Always good energy when I step in the establishment, and that is because each and every employee provides a rare kind of comfortability that you can't find most places that involve customer service. I appreciate their food and energy keep up the good work.“

“karaoke Wednesday and Thursday nights. Very chill people to hang around with, my favorite place in town to have some beers!“

“I’ve been searching for a bbq chicken pizza that compared to the first bbq chicken pizza I fell in love with up in Greenville when I was a kid. Jess n’ Nicks has delivered ! Best bbq chicken pizza I’ve had in so long!“

“we had a very nice dinner“

“Food was awesome and the bartender was awesome!!! My wife and I came on Monday night and it was pretty busy. Adrienne made my wife a wonderful Ol fashioned and I enjoyed a glass of wine. Although she was very busy, she was quite attentive. Lovely experience, we will be back to see her again.“

“I LOVE THIS PLACE. The Salad bar is awesome and inexpensive and the sandwiches are amazing. I go all the time.“

“My first stop when I get off the ferry! Gotta have a cold one & some garlic parm fries! No matter what you order, you won’t be disappointed!“

“Our family had a great meal tonight. We had a large pizza, small pizza, gluten free pizza, and a Caesar salad. They were quite busy when we arrived but our food came out quickly and everything was great! The sodas were nice and cold and bathroom was well kept. Their team in the kitchen seemed to be working well together.“

“Our server was Sal and Sal was great. For clarity, we went on a week night with very few people in the restaurant - just before close, so wasn’t sure what to expect. We were a table of 6 with 6 different pizzas. Food was good and all of it came out at the same time. Sal had a nice balance of helpful but not overbearing.“

“My wife and I are in town from Augusta, GA. Happened to see this place when we were coming up with dinner plans. Brandon gave us a great experience. Food was delicious. Atmosphere was good. Will definitely come back next time we're in Maine.“

“Never a bad experience here.“

“Fresh, hot pizza (and other assorted goodies)! The employees are always friendly, sometimes they look a little frazzled but don't we all at times. There is no dine- in so the atmosphere is merely the sweet smell of pizza in the oven, a cash register and a cooler full of soda. lol“

“I enjoy the people that work very hard and the interactions with consumers. The food is great.“

“My family loves this place…food is delicious …tried Many menu options.. host always warm, Welcoming and fun, and prices Family friendly!!!“

“Over the weekend we had our wedding reception at the Ogunquit location, and it was absolutely perfect! Everything turned out better than we could have imagined. The service was exceptional, and every staff member we interacted with was so kind, professional, and attentive. The entire day ran seamlessly thanks to their incredible team — they truly went above and beyond to make our day so special. We couldn’t have been happier and can’t wait to come back for dinner soon to relive a little of the magic!“

“I love Hilltop as a resident on the Eastern prom. Great selection of items for a small corner store. I order the Meat Lovers pizza all the time and it always comes out perfectly. I tried their new SPICY addition to the Meat Lovers the other night and loved it. Perfect combination of spices in the sauce and seasoning on the crust. 20/10“

“We stayed at the Westin Hotel in Portland, ME. The pizza was amazing and the service was great! It was cooked perfectly and had a nice crunch to it! No fork/knife needed.“

“The food is awesome and for those that are not willing to wait if they are making it fresh you are going to miss out The best Italians ever“

“Our new favorite bar in Portland. We Went in with the family for a few drinks. The staff were extremely helpful, came right over to make sure we had a table and took our order. The atmosphere was great and they had some cool drinks. We will definitely be back, thanks again 👍

We didn't have food so I can't review that.“

“The food is great, the service is great, the bands are always good. Great for all sports, especially watching football games! The locals and are very welcoming and great at recommending things from the menu. The owners are wonderful for the community with all the events and groups they have donated for. We are there frequently, recommend to everyone, and use for all our work events and catering needs. 100/100!“

“really good food here and professional staff“

“Thank you for providing pizzas for King Middle School’s Winter Dance last Friday! The students appreciated it so much!“

“As I lifelong fan of Amato’s Italian Sandwiches. I love their food. My only minor issue is the accuracy in filling the order. The last two times I have used the Falmouth location the sandwiches have either had a peppers that I didn’t order or left off the tomatoes that I ordered. The orders were placed on the kiosk and the correct order was on the receipt. I will still keep eating their sandwiches but will continue to be annoyed at the errors.“

“Loved the loaded steak pizza!“

“If we’re being honest, moving to a new city comes with one very important question: where’s the go-to pizza spot? After one visit to OTTO Pizza in downtown Portland, I can confidently say, we’ve already found ours.

This may genuinely be some of the best pizza we’ve ever had. The seasonal pie right now is absolutely phenomenal. You can tell they don’t just make pizza here, they craft it.

What truly made the experience memorable though was the service. Cat, our waitress, was incredible. Warm, attentive, and thoughtful. She offered great recommendations and made us feel so genuinely welcomed to OTTO and Portland. That kind of hospitality makes a lasting impression.

Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice (which is a great deal, by the way) or sitting down to share a full pie, OTTO strikes that rare balance. It feels like an elevated version of your favorite childhood pizzeria, comforting, nostalgic, but undeniably high quality.

Safe to say, we’re completely spoiled now. This will absolutely be a regular spot for us, and I can’t recommend it highly enough.“

“Just happened to stop here yesterday for a late lunch! So glad we did! My husband has had their pizza before I hadn't. The pizza was soo delicious! I ordered a Pineapple, Bacon & Hot Honey small pizza. It was one of the BEST pizza's I've ever eaten! I didn't take my receipt so I can't remember our waiters name & I wish I could because he deserves a shout out! He was amazing!! Would definitely recommend! & will definitely be back!“

“They are always busy but they are quick at making the orders for how busy they get the workers are so sweet but the only complaint I have is they don't to deliver two gorham which makes no sense since it's really close 🤔 but nonetheless keep up the good work“

“My roommate stopped and picked up pizzas for dinner. We live in Biddeford soo. Back in the late 70s I was a cook at a Pizza Hut in Portland. The pizzas have changed very little and the taste is just as awesome! Thank you to the workers at the Pizza Hut in Westbrook Maine for a phenomenal dinner with attached memories!“

“The Moose has buy far the best smash burger 🍔 I’ve ever had. The salads are awesome and the staff is just great!“