50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Long Island

“Great food, great service! The best fish & fries!!!“

“Amazing food! My incredibly picky husband LOVED his pizza. We enjoyed the outside dining by the water, friendly and knowledgeable staff, and that kids’ drawings were the cover of their menus. All local food and drink too. 100% recommend!!“

“Great pizza, gourmet foods, and fabulous customer experience!“

“Wow! Calafia was a perfect venue for our birthday celebration. Six of us were very comfortable in their cozy banquet corner which was just right for our gathering. The restaurant is beautiful with an alluring glow and a casually sophisticated vibe. Every cocktail and dish was delicious, prepared perfectly with really fresh ingredients and outstanding flavors. Generous portions and great service. Calafia is a gem in Portland’s West End!“

“I got your pizza for a party and everyone loved it! Best pizza around and great staff. Im also a fan of the cheese cake ❤️“

“Very friendly Pizzaria and pub. The pizza was very good and arrived pretty swiftly. The server was efficient and pleasant. We arrived there early for dinner, and by the time we left the parking lot was almost full. This indicates it’s a popular place, as it was a Thursday. We will return!“

“Great all around.love the Philly steak n cheese pizza add banana peppers. My favorite 👍❤️“

“I ordered a large pizza yesterday, and it was delivered on time@it was a great pizza. ❤️“

“Bittersweet to be writing this review as I will not be able to go here again due to them closing. Glad I was able to make one more stop here once we saw they announced the closure. Fond memories of slab from great beer events held during Maine Beer Week years ago. Along those lines, you could always count on a great taplist with beers from Maine and further. This was a favorite spot of my wife and I to grab some slab style pizza with a brew. Their thin crust pizzas were solid as well, but my favorite food option here has always been the meatball sandwich. It seems to be tough times for many Portland restaurants so if you have favorites spots go out and support them! Thanks for all the memories slab!“

“beautiful and comfortable place to drink a locally brewed beer and some good food! love this place I would highly recommend this to anyone!!“

“Fire pizza service everything about this place is awesome if you haven’t tried not tried it your losing out amazing food get some“

“Good food, good service, lovely“

“Very nice market. Fairly small in the winter months, but definitely worth the visit. There was a good variety of vendors. We especially liked the honey and jam. There were also plenty of vegetables and meats to choose from. No parking fee. Definitely recommend.“

“Great local pizza place! You should go. Laid back but genuinely nice, bar and outside dining available too. Very cozy, delicious 🍕, fast and friendly. My family and I are up here visiting, we talked with Mike and Richie all night. They hooked us up with food and drinks, gave us local recommendations for Portland. Thnx. Felt like home, we felt welcomed and enjoyed our meal, sat for a long time.“

“OTTO offers a clean, trendy eating experience with local beers on tap. The staff during my visit was incredibly friendly and the service was quick. I decided to go with the Margherita pie - which turned out to be a great decision. The pie featured an ultra-thin base that was browned nicely by the oven. The fresh, juicy tomatoes were well distributed and did not slide when eating slices. The crisp exterior on the thin crust added a great crunch. The fresh basil ribbons and the spicy herb blend added to the cheese carried a ton of flavor. There are many other pizza options available at OTTO, including gluten-free and vegan options. I will definitely be returning so that I can work my way through the rest of the pizza menu.

Vegetarian options: They have many veggie options, including vegan options.

Dietary restrictions: They offer gluten-free and vegan options!“

“We got this as a snack to go. They don't offer single slices, pies only. Counter man was friendly. Atmosphere had some shady folks hanging around but they look like they meant well. Pizza was amazing, I wish we could've had 3 pies hehe but I'm trying to watch my figure. I'd come back here but next time I'm getting more food!“

“Absolute comfort food. I've been a fan of these folks since they opened at this location years ago and I lived a few blocks away. Since I now live out of the state, I now enjoy bringing friends here when I return.I know they have a great, broad menu of items and you could pick a winner with any of them, but man - I've always been in love with The Old Port - a simple pepperoni pizza. Everything about it has been consistently "just right" over the years (ratio of ingredients to one another, doughiness, overall flavor). It even reheats like a champ when I've had to do that.Absence does make the heart grow fonder. Sure, that's the case with people... but when it comes to pizza like this? Doubly, if not more, so. I'm already waiting for my next trip back to get a pie one evening.“

“The young people who work here give stellar customer service. They are appropriately friendly and engaging. Bravo to ownership and managers for this!!!“

“Friendly atmosphere, great food and very fairly priced. Great place to get a holiday gift card.“

“The food was actually really good! We were trying to save money and there wasn't any good food in the portion of Boston we were at for a concert so on the way back we ordered some pizza and some brownies. The pizza was really good and it actually tasted better than dominos, I was really surprised! Definitely will order again sometime“

“SO GOOD! Great service and some of the best croissants I’ve ever had. Perfectly flaky �“

“we had a very nice dinner“

“Glad I took the back way out of portland, great food, friendly people, will definitely be back for sure, maybe bring some people with me. keep up the great work and don't change a thing.“

“Very tasty and large pizzas!
If you're traveling in Portland and either don't like seafood or are simply looking for an inexpensive alternative, this is the place for you.
The price/performance ratio is great.
The service was excellent and always attentive.
Only the interior is a bit spartan - there is still room for improvement.
Basically, highly recommended!

Vegetarian options: There are enough vegetarian pizzas.

Parking: There is no parking space, but there is certainly parking in the area on the street.

Kid-friendliness: Also suitable for children.

Wheelchair accessibility: Possible.“

“As I lifelong fan of Amato’s Italian Sandwiches. I love their food. My only minor issue is the accuracy in filling the order. The last two times I have used the Falmouth location the sandwiches have either had a peppers that I didn’t order or left off the tomatoes that I ordered. The orders were placed on the kiosk and the correct order was on the receipt. I will still keep eating their sandwiches but will continue to be annoyed at the errors.“

“The food is great, the service is great, the bands are always good. Great for all sports, especially watching football games! The locals and are very welcoming and great at recommending things from the menu. The owners are wonderful for the community with all the events and groups they have donated for. We are there frequently, recommend to everyone, and use for all our work events and catering needs. 100/100!“

“Amazing place, amazing food, and friendly service!!! Casual dining experience, we had the Italian wedding soup which was amazing! Cannolis better than anywhere. I’m definitely going back!“

“Great atmosphere and great food.❤️“

“Five diners in our party--aged six to sixty-five--all left stuffed and happy! Fantastic pizza, playful and delicious garlic bread, wonderful pasta, fabulous service. Highly recommend!

Kid-friendliness: A pizza option and a spaghetti option... what more could a kiddo want?“

“We stayed at the Westin Hotel in Portland, ME. The pizza was amazing and the service was great! It was cooked perfectly and had a nice crunch to it! No fork/knife needed.“

“Just happened to stop here yesterday for a late lunch! So glad we did! My husband has had their pizza before I hadn't. The pizza was soo delicious! I ordered a Pineapple, Bacon & Hot Honey small pizza. It was one of the BEST pizza's I've ever eaten! I didn't take my receipt so I can't remember our waiters name & I wish I could because he deserves a shout out! He was amazing!! Would definitely recommend! & will definitely be back!“

“Give this place a shot! There are a lot of good spots for pizza in Portland... these guys make a great pie! I had the "Old World Pepperoni." It was awesome! Exactly what I was hoping for. Delivery was fast and friendly. Will definitely order from them again.

Update...
Just had delivery again. Fast & friendly! The food? Only the best calzone I've ever had! ("Meatza" + jalapeños)
Seriously... blown away!“

“Absolute Best Homemade Gluten Free Rolls imaginable 👍👍👍 The BEST!“

“Solid Neapolitan pizza with both traditional and more creative toppings. The location is a bit bland with no distinct feeling or character. Food is great though perhaps a bit over-hyped to say it's the best in Portland as some claim. Overall a worthy addition to Portland's pizza scene.“

“karaoke Wednesday and Thursday nights. Very chill people to hang around with, my favorite place in town to have some beers!“

“The staff at Hilltop Superette have turned the little neighborhood convenience store at the top of Munjoy Hill into a destination spot for incredible food, beverages, and a personable experience. For lunch today, I ordered their grilled chicken pesto sandwich and I have to say, I haven't had better anywhere else in this city. The bread was warm, soft, and fresh, the meat was whole chunks of white meat, and the sandwich was stuffed full with onions, tomatoes and pesto. I ordered a large and now have half the sandwich left over for lunch tomorrow as well. Basically two meals for $10. You can't get that deal anywhere else. They have food ready to go (pizza slices, chicken and burger baskets with fries), and tons of local sweets. And that's just the lunch selection. The breakfast offerings are equally impressive. They also have an incredible wine, spirits, and beer selection too.

I highly recommend Hilltop Superette for anyone on the go and wanting to grab some amazing food at a price that will not break the bank. Sam Patel and his crew truly have a gem at the top of Munjoy Hill.“

“Best market around! 🎉🍕🍺🍷🎉“

“Walking thru and stopped for a drink. Very cool hole in the wall place. We even came back after dinner for another one of my wife's new favorite beer seadog blueberry Corey I belive gave us some solid advice on places to visit and eat on our england trip!“

“Best sandwich in town , always always fresh rolls not from the day before or two days before like the other stores , filled with great and fresh ingredients, try a gabbagol and provolone Italian , forgetaboutit five stars every time. I don’t usually write reviews but I took the time to for this family You need to get your a** over there now , no really !“

“Normally I'd recommend the place but between the inconsistent quality and pricing as of late it's difficult to. It started off on high note when the store reopened as FVM, but has since started to fall back to what it had formerly been. Still my favorite place for italians but I'll unfortunately be ordering from elsewhere until things fall back in line. Update-2022: Expecting any level of quality from this place is still a joke. I still enjoy getting their food on occasion but I can't help but laugh at what I get. They're lucky for their location and lack of competition. This order will definitely be the last chunk of change I spend there. Burned food, scarce toppings, and little to no filler in a calzone described to have a generous portion of chicken in it. Speaking of the calzone, it was a chicken parmesan and it didn't even have any cheese! It's laughable really. I'd usually say they're a fair priced store but when they continue to cut back it's hard to even give them that much credit. Go in with low expectations and they might just exceed them if you're lucky enough.“

“Just happened to stop here yesterday for a late lunch! So glad we did! My husband has had their pizza before I hadn't. The pizza was soo delicious! I ordered a Pineapple, Bacon & Hot Honey small pizza. It was one of the BEST pizza's I've ever eaten! I didn't take my receipt so I can't remember our waiters name & I wish I could because he deserves a shout out! He was amazing!! Would definitely recommend! & will definitely be back!“

“I LOVE THIS PLACE. The Salad bar is awesome and inexpensive and the sandwiches are amazing. I go all the time.“

“The food is awesome and for those that are not willing to wait if they are making it fresh you are going to miss out The best Italians ever“

“My family loves this place…food is delicious …tried Many menu options.. host always warm, Welcoming and fun, and prices Family friendly!!!“

“I ordered a large pizza yesterday, and it was delivered on time@it was a great pizza. ❤️“

“Thank you for providing pizzas for King Middle School’s Winter Dance last Friday! The students appreciated it so much!“

“chicken baskets, and always the Buffalo chicken wrap, always made so great.!!!“

“We order frequently! Great service.“

“Some of the best pizza in Portland. Flavors and options are always great. The inside has a nice ambiance if you’re going on a date. The only confusing thing, and maybe I’ve just gotten bad luck, but the service is sometimes sub-par. I wolnt let it take a star away, however, this is an area they could be more consistent on. I think it’s because they don’t have a dedicated server so the cashier/pizza maker ends up taking orders and they maybe are not trained in customer service. And they are busy with their other tasks so not always on top of checking when people come in.

Parking: No dedicated parking.“