10 Best Pizza Restaurants in South Portland

“Just happened to stop here yesterday for a late lunch! So glad we did! My husband has had their pizza before I hadn't. The pizza was soo delicious! I ordered a Pineapple, Bacon & Hot Honey small pizza. It was one of the BEST pizza's I've ever eaten! I didn't take my receipt so I can't remember our waiters name & I wish I could because he deserves a shout out! He was amazing!! Would definitely recommend! & will definitely be back!“

“We were pleasantly surprised at how great the pizza was here. Had just got in from driving up to portland and didn’t really want to go out somewhere for dinner, so we stopped here. The pizza was fantastic. We got two smalls, the squash ricotta and cranberry, and a mashed potato bacon and scallion.

On paper, these do not sound like they would work on a pizza, but wow. Crust was still crunchy, and the flavors really worked together.

I didn’t realize they were a chain, and was thoroughly impressed.“

“The young people who work here give stellar customer service. They are appropriately friendly and engaging. Bravo to ownership and managers for this!!!“

“Best market around! 🎉🍕🍺🍷🎉“

“Normally I'd recommend the place but between the inconsistent quality and pricing as of late it's difficult to. It started off on high note when the store reopened as FVM, but has since started to fall back to what it had formerly been. Still my favorite place for italians but I'll unfortunately be ordering from elsewhere until things fall back in line. Update-2022: Expecting any level of quality from this place is still a joke. I still enjoy getting their food on occasion but I can't help but laugh at what I get. They're lucky for their location and lack of competition. This order will definitely be the last chunk of change I spend there. Burned food, scarce toppings, and little to no filler in a calzone described to have a generous portion of chicken in it. Speaking of the calzone, it was a chicken parmesan and it didn't even have any cheese! It's laughable really. I'd usually say they're a fair priced store but when they continue to cut back it's hard to even give them that much credit. Go in with low expectations and they might just exceed them if you're lucky enough.“

“Best pizza we have EVER had. Fries great too“

“2nd Day of my return trip to Maine and my first visit to the South Portland Amato's this trip. Once again the ham Italian was out of this world , the bread was very soft and fresh and the vegetables were fresh and crispy and so delicious, Their blend of sandwich oil is the best I have ever had. I have eaten almost every sandwich on the menu and have never been disappointed“

“We order frequently! Great service.“

“Happy to say tonight was a great night to go out to dinner. Upon arrival, the bartender was acting as host, server and over all cheer squad for the restaurant. We were greeted promptly as she was busy assisting a person picking up an order and seating another couple. We sat in the bar at a hightop. She followed us over with menus and asked us about drinks. Throughout our visit she was a checking in with a bubbly personality and vibrancy that was refreshing. Our food came out as ordered, which can be tricky with my dietary changes, and it was hot and delicious! She was Johnny on the spot with refills and smiling every time she came by. I couldn't remember her name but the receipt said Blake. If that's correct I give you props! Thanks for making a rainy night enjoyable 😉“