21 Best American Restaurants near Elmira

Railside | Bar & Grill Bar & Grill • $
8805 M-32, Elmira

Customers` Favorites

Stacked Club Sandwich with Green Beans
World Famous Potato Burger
Potato Burger Deep Fried
Potato Burger Grilled
Whitefish Sandwich
Chili Dog Special
Beef Wet Burrito
Fish and Chips
Cabbage Rolls
Polish Nachos

“The only Gravy I’ll eat is on their MEATLOAF 😏 the menu is great but the specials are a MUST-TRY! Great staff too!“

4.8 Superb262 Reviews
Bennethum's Northern Inn American • $$
3917 Old US Hwy 27 South, Gaylord - 9.71 miles

Customers` Favorites

St Elmo's Style Shrimp Cocktail
Asian Glazed Boneless Wings
French Onion Soup Au Gratin
Parmesan Encrusted Walleye
Asian Glazed Cashew Salmon
18oz Bone-In Wagyu Ribeye
Parmesan Brussels Sprouts
Fresh East Coast Oysters
Alaskan King Crab Legs
Homemade Crab Rangoon

“We enjoyed a marvelous dinner and experience sitting at the bar and having Danielle as our bartender. It is so enjoyable to have a great night out with good food, good cocktails, and good service! Thank you for a memorable night out!“

4.6 Superb384 Reviews
Culver’s American • $
1397 West Main Street, Gaylord - 6.32 miles

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Chicken Sandwich with Grilled Onions
Concrete Mixer Reese's Peanut Butter
Butterburger Deluxe Cheeseburger
Cod Dinner Fries and Cole Slaw
French Fries and Cheese Curds
Chicken Sandwich Deluxe Combo
Butter Burger and Fries
Sourdough Butter Burger
Mushroom Swiss Burger
Grilled Cheese Basket

“Great place! Good food great service“

4.4 Superb221 Reviews
Mooney's Ice Cream Parlor American • $
601 South Otsego Avenue, Gaylord - 7.51 miles

Customers` Favorites

Blackberry Dark Chocolate Chunk

“This is a sweet hidden treasure right here in Gaylord. They offered many selections of icecream. We were having a hard time getting my grandson to pick a flavor and they were quick to offer him a tiny taste to help him decide. The service was quick, the place was clean and pricing great.“

4.5 Superb66 Reviews
The Summit Grill part of The Loon Golf Resort American • $$
4815 Old US Hwy 27 S, Gaylord - 10.31 miles

“Love eating there“

4.3 Superb16 Reviews
KARMA TAPROOM Bar • $
138 W Main St Suite A, Gaylord - 7.31 miles

“Great owners, great drinks and great customers. Always have a great time at Karma Taproom.“

4.8 Superb52 Reviews
Applebee's Grill + Bar American • $
1379 W Main St, Gaylord - 6.44 miles

Customers` Favorites

6 Oz Steak Mashed Potatoes and Broccoli Dine in: Yes Outdoor seating: No Takeout: Yes Curbside pickup: Yes
Clubhouse Grill and Redskin Mashed Potatoes
Bourbon Chicken and Shrimp
Triple Chocolate Meltdown
Crunchy Onion Rings Sides
White Queso Dip & Chips
Spinach Artichoke Dip
Chocolate Lava Cake
Chicken Wonton Tacos
Mozzarella Sticks

“Service was great! Our server, Rob H., was exceptional. Always on the ball with getting things we needed, and when my order appeared to lack something it was suppose to have, he was quick to accommodate and get me something to make up for it. I ordered the California chicken salad which was on the 2 for 25 menu. Wasn't that great. Mostly romaine, and the avocado cucumber salsa seemed to lack avocado. It wasn't terrible, but probably wouldn't order again. The rest of my family's food seemed good tho, So food: 4 ⭐. Service by Rob: 5 ⭐!“

4 Good186 Reviews
Clock Tower Lodge @ Boyne Mountain Resort American • $$
2800 Boyne Mountain Rd, Boyne Falls - 8.32 miles

Customers` Favorites

Bowtie Pasta

“We had such a great experience at Stein Eriksen's that we ate there two nights in a row. To start, the decor is Alpine, a perfect fit overlooking the slopes. Scott, the host, greeted us so warmly and checked in to make sure everything was going well. Its team members like this that create an experience that is memorable! They were absolutely booked on the holiday weekend, but service was seamless. Mark and Tim were both attentive servers and knew the menu well. The Alpine inspired menu was delicious and fitting for the setting.“

3.7 Good31 Reviews
Porter Haus Bar & Grill • $$
3885 Old US Hwy 27 South, Gaylord - 9.65 miles

Customers` Favorites

Ooey Gooey Hot Fudge Brownie Ala Mode
Mary's Kielbasa Dip
Sweet Potato Fries
French Dip Sandwich
Porter Haus Nachos
Smoke Haus Burger
Prime Rib Dinner
Haus Made Fries
Prime Rib Tacos
Boneless Wings

“My mom and I were just in to eat dinner on the 4th around 6:30pm we had the prime rib which was absolutely delicious. The appetizer was delicious and the drinks were ice cold. The highlight of it all was our server Sarah, she was very nice and her customer service was impeccable. we will definitely be back just from her service alone.“

4.3 Superb251 Reviews
Cops & Doughnuts Jay's Precinct Coffee & Tea • $
1151 South Otsego Avenue, Gaylord - 7.83 miles

Customers` Favorites

Apple Filled Cherry Bearclaw Cherry Cake Donut Blueberry Muffin Peanut Butter Cream Filled
Raspberry Pie Blueberry Muffin and a Pumpkin Spice Frosted Cookie
Blueberry Muffin and Pumpkin Spice Cookie on the Go
Bacon and Maple Frosted Cinnamon Roll
Chocolate Peanut Butter Long John
Cinnamon Roll with Maple Frosting
Pineapple Upside Down Cake
Cake Doughnuts Lemon Bars
Coconut Cream Long John
Cookies Hand Apple Pies

“Always stop when up north. Either at Clare or Gaylord. Excellent product and choices.“

4.3 Superb162 Reviews
Snowbelt Brewing Co. Brewery • $$
132 West Main Street, Gaylord - 7.32 miles

“Yo! That Sunnyside is the nectar of the Gods! Great food, great folks, delicious beverages.“

4.3 Superb151 Reviews
Forty Acres Tavern Bar & Grill • $$
1 Boyne Mountain Road, Boyne Falls - 8.34 miles

Customers` Favorites

Honey Glaze Wings and Fries
Honey Glazed Chicken Wings
Morning After Bloody Mary
Loaded Grilled Cheese
Grilled Artichoke Dip
Veggie Flat Bread
Mozzarella Sticks
Chicken Sandwich
Tavern Burger
House Salad

“We dropped in after spending the day swimming at Avalanche Bay with the family, and I couldn’t have been happier with our experience. We got a great quiet spot in the corner with a beautiful view, which was exactly what we needed after the chaos of the water park. It was such a nice, relaxing change of pace.

The hostess was delightful, and our server was awesome. The food was a little pricey, but honestly, for hotel food, it was amazing and well worth it. Everyone was incredibly welcoming to our family, even though we looked a little bedraggled after an adventurous day at the water park.“

4.3 Superb137 Reviews
ALPINE TAVERN & EATERY Bar & Grill • $
216 S Otsego Ave, Gaylord - 7.3 miles

Customers` Favorites

Smothered Brisket Dip & Swiss
Brick of Fries with Cheese
Crispy Whitefish Sandwich
Brisket Grilled Cheese
Crab Stuffed Whitefish
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Beer Battered Perch
Sweet Potato Fries
Pulled Pork Nachos
Firecracker Burger

“Great good & great service!“

4.2 Good264 Reviews
The Whi-Ski Inn Barbeque • $$
2670 US-131, Boyne Falls - 7.91 miles

Customers` Favorites

Brisket and Mac N Cheese
Chicken Wings
Baked Beans
Pulled Pork
Ribs

“Food was amazing. I got a pork taco and loved it. Service was awesome. I will definitely make this a go to spot. Thank you for great service and Excellent food.“

4.2 Good169 Reviews
Timothy's Pub Pubs • $
110 S Otsego Ave, Gaylord - 7.26 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Sandwich Hand Breaded
Classic Club Sandwich
Cheddar Cream Sauce
Prime Rib Sandwich
Smothered Chicken
Prime Steak Hash
Rueben Sandwich
Chicken Alfredo
Fish and Chips
Potato Skins

“I visit this place every time my family comes to Gaylord. We always get great food and fantastic service. I wish they would open a place in middle Tennessee.“

4.2 Good136 Reviews
Everett's American • $$
1 Boyne Mountain Road, Boyne Falls - 8.28 miles

Customers` Favorites

Beef Brisket Sliders
Chicken Cherry Brie
Crispy Goat Cheese
Shrimp Linguini
Pulled Pork
White Fish
Burger
Sushi

“Food was good. We started with the wings, which were hotter than I was expecting, 4/10 spicy in my book but white people beware. I had a normal cheeseburger, which was a bit dry but that's my fault for getting it well done - it seems the cooks traded moistness for form, and the burger certainly had good form. The fish and chips I'm told was tender. Finished the meal with the brownie sundae, which was good.

Service was quick, not too long of a wait on the food. Our server, Ben, had consistently good timing when checking on our table and even gave me an extra water when he noticed I was drinking a lot.

Atmosphere is good, calm, no need for reservation.

P.S. Lake Street Pub has better burgers and if you want to make moist burger, I suggest adding Worcestershire to the recipe and pouring beer on during the cooking process(soon after you flip).“

3.4 Good63 Reviews
Eagle's Nest Snack bar • $
3109 Mountain Run Road, Boyne Falls - 7.97 miles

“It was expensive and we had our little tea cup yorkie with us that the young kid wouldn't let us bring in even if we held it the whole time. So one had to go in for the food and we had to eat outside. The food truck on the other side of the sky bridge had a good selection, reasonable prices, and plenty of picnic tables to eat at“

3.9 Good45 Reviews
Bob Evans Family • $
210 Dickerson Road, Gaylord - 6.84 miles

Customers` Favorites

Introducing Bob Evans Dinner Bell Plates Eight Great Plates Under 8
Honey Butter Chicken & Biscuit Breakfast Family Meal to Go
Legendary Turkey Sandwich
Sausage Gravy & Biscuits
Ham Macaroni and Cheese
Family Size Onion Rings
Little Piggy Pancakes
Brioche French Toast
Two Sausage Patties
Chicken Fried Steak

“my family stopped at this store on the way home from vacationing. the food was amazing but we loved our server,Sarah.she was so warm and friendly and radiates joy. my grandson said he wished we lived near here not just for the great food but because Sarah was so nice.“

3.8 Good171 Reviews
The Iron Pig Smokehouse Barbecue • $
4029 Old US Hwy 27 South, Gaylord - 7.32 miles

Customers` Favorites

Ribs Pulled Pork Brusque
Pulled Pork Sandwiches
Brisket Platter GF dd
Jalapeño Cornbread
Tater Tots Basket
Brisket Tacos dd
Iron Pig Burger
Sampler Platter
Smokehouse Tacos
Brisket Platter

“This place exceeded our expectations! The food was delicious and the portion sizes were huge. You definitely get plenty for your money. Caden was a fantastic server, friendly, attentive, and made sure we had everything we needed. We’re so glad we decided to stop here and would absolutely come back next time we’re in Gaylord. Highly recommend!“

3.8 Good231 Reviews
20

BIG BOY

BIG BOY American • $
1359 W Main St, Gaylord - 6.54 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cinnamon Apple Covered Pancakes Hashbrowns Scrambled Eggs and Fruit
Farmer's Omelette and Hash Browns
Breakfast Buffet Mixture
Big Boy Burgers and Fries
Hot Fudge Ice Cream Cake
Super Big Boy with Fries
Fries Dine in: Yes
Soup and Salad Bar
Loaded Mac & Cheese
Coconut Cream Pie

“What a wonderful Big Boy experience!! We loved everything about it!!“

3.3 Good187 Reviews
Buffalo Wild Wings Chicken Wings • $
2305 Snowdrift Drive, Gaylord - 5.63 miles

Customers` Favorites

Ultimate Nachos with Chicken
Garlic Parmesan Wings
Cheddar Cheese Curds
Traditional Wings
Cauliflower Wings
Chicken Sandwich
Parmesan Garlic
Chips and Salsa
Chicken Wings
Chicken Wrap

“My husband and I visited the Gaylord location on Friday February 28th 2025 and had a great experience. Our server was extremely busy and still managed to reach all our needs. Brooke did an amazing job!“

3.5 Good221 Reviews

You May Also Like