12 Best American Restaurants in Garden City

“My new go/to spot for home delivery. I am a homebound senior and get food delivered often. This is the first time I was thoroughly satisfied with my order. I ordered both lunch and dinner. It was perfect and for about $42 I have enough food for at least four meals, probably five. I am delighted to know there is a place near/by that won’t disappoint me. Good job, GJs.“

“Terri was my server and she was so kind. I came in by myself and she made me feel welcome I had the Lumberjack stuffed Potato Pancakes and a side of fruit. The food was super yummy. Terri and the rest of the team were on the ball making sure coffee was filled and hot.“

“Everything was so tasty. I will definitely be back. & the give you enough food ! 😋 10/10“

“fantastic food and great people“

“This place has great food, better then some pricier restaurants I've been too.

Parking: The parking here can be tricky the parking lot is really small so you either have to fight for a spot or park at one of the trip malls nearby and walk over which isn't too far.

Kid-friendliness: Kids like it here, and I've seen kids sports teams go here.

Wheelchair accessibility: Difficult if you are in a wheelchair. I've seen people in the electric wheel chairs struggle to get through. The furniture is large and not easy to push out of the way for someone whose mobility is different.“

“Awesome food, great portions. Was sad to go to get food and seen it closed down“

“Great staff! ❤️ I love the atmosphere, coffee & donuts!“

“Been going to Menka’s for as long as I can remember. Everything is so good! I guess you could say it’s like the tv show Cheers. Where everybody knows your name. Love the family, love the food, love it all! They do not disappoint!“

“I recently visited a fast-food restaurant and had a surprisingly pleasant experience, largely thanks to the excellent service provided by Saif. From the moment I walked in, he greeted me with a smile and made me feel welcome. Despite the busy lunch rush, Saif remained attentive and patient, taking the time to ensure my order was correct and answering all my questions.

The food itself was exactly what you’d expect from a fast-food joint—quick, fresh, and satisfying. I ordered a burger and fries, and both were served hot and well-prepared. While the menu doesn’t offer anything out of the ordinary, the overall quality was good for a fast-casual spot.

What really stood out, though, was Saif’s commitment to customer service. He checked in after I got my meal to make sure everything was to my liking, which you don’t often see in fast food. His friendly demeanor and attention to detail truly elevated the experience.

If you’re looking for a quick bite with great service, I’d recommend stopping by—and hopefully, you’ll get the chance to be served by Saif!“

“Our 1st time there! It was absolutely amazing! The pizza was like the old fashion pizza, we loved it! The service was spectacular!! We will definitely be back!!“

“The food you guys make is immaculate! ESPECIALLY the carne asada tacos. I will continue too put the word out for this place and also keep on bringing my friends and family. Thank you for great food always!“

“Savvy Sliders in Garden City is a hidden gem that totally delivers on flavor and quality. From the moment you walk in, the welcoming atmosphere and clean, modern setup make a great first impression. The sliders are packed with bold, delicious flavors, and the portions are just right — super satisfying without being too heavy. The fries are crisp perfection, and the dipping sauces take everything up a notch. It’s clear the staff take pride in what they do, because the service is quick, kind, and consistent. Whether it’s your first visit or your tenth, this place never disappoints.“