17 Best Sandwich Shops near New Haven

“Brooke and Jay were the nicest people. They were very through when explaining what was on what and the difference between italian bread and italian and herb; turns out it’s just cheese!
The food was amazing, by far the best subway i’ve been to in awhile.
Very kind and very much will return!“

“Five stars for SAM!!!

Listen… corporate, if you’re reading this: if I walk in next time and find out Sam did NOT get a raise, I will be forced to dramatically flip a table (respectfully, of course).

This woman could sell a sandwich to someone who just finished Thanksgiving dinner. Absolute pro. The place was spotless—like “mom’s coming over in 10 minutes” clean - she was already wiping things down when I walked in. She matched my energy instantly: calm, cool, collected… meanwhile I’m two minutes away from eating the napkins out of hunger.

We had a quick, wholesome life chat while she crafted (yes, crafted) the most elite 6” sandwich I’ve ever consumed. I’m talking Michelin-star energy in sub form. I went in broke and starving, and if I had an extra $20 on me, I would’ve thrown it at her like she just performed a magic trick.

Sam, thank you for your service. Promote her. Protect her. Possibly build a statue.“

“The best subs! Ingredients are so fresh and delicious-especially the buns! Super friendly staff! 10/10“

“Lisa is awesome! Sweetest person and very tentative! Food is great and we will be back!“

“very good yum yum 😋😋😋😋😋😋😋😋😋😋😋😋“

“My first job and still my favorite sub... ever!“

“Love your sandwiches and I get them at least once a week! But so disappointed today :(. Drive to my normal location on hall and Hayes and found out they were closed for remodeling. So drove to Macomb location. I normally pay close attention while subs are made to correct issues but today I was getting pushed into paying before my subs were made. Sadly I got home and it was wrong :(. Ordered three subs total. 2 of three were not what was requested. ie wrong bread, missing mikes way dressing etc. one of the kids subs was completely smashed. it was obvious new employees were working and I’m not totally blaming them. Moving forward I will make sure I watch my sandwiches being made and wont get rushed to the register. I paid a lot for these sandwiches and expect to get what I ordered.“

“Tubby’s is hands down one of our favorite places to go! First of all, the staff is so sweet, welcoming, and always makes us feel right at home. You can tell they truly care about their customers and creating a friendly atmosphere. The food is always great, and my son absolutely loves going there every time. It’s become one of our favorite spots because of the kindness, great service, and warm environment. Highly recommend Tubby’s!“

“The best tubby’s around, crazy thing is it’s not just a basic hello sir. It’s a hey how you doing buddy? Followed by fantastic foods that can’t be replicated by others ??? definitely recommend the steak and cheese and onion rings ??“

“I usually go to Penn Station for their great Italian sub sandwich (on white bread), and of course for their fabulous freshly made fries. This time I has a coupon for a free Hot Honey Chicken sub. Not very colorful (see photo), but still quite tasty. I’d do it again. Also, I have signed up for Penn Station rewards, and today I received a free small fry. Deandre was the server, and helped ensure I got them both for free. Great service, great deal, nice sandwich!!“

“My favorite sub is the Italian and Jersey Mike's is the BEST I've ever eaten. The meat is really high quality and the ham is especially very flavorful. The first time I ever got one, I was astonished at the amount of meat they put on them...I couldn't hardly bite into it, lol. I especially like that they cook their own roast beef right there and slice it as needed, as well as bake their own sub rolls...you can't get fresher than that!!!“

“To the elder lady I encountered yesterday , I hope your night got better and your smile got a little brighter 🥹… you are one of a kind the company Is beyond blessed to have you.. we seen how over whelmed you were and stressed out and I just couldn’t help but try to make it a little easier on you… not only do you deserve a raise but you deserve for the company to pay out your retirement!!!!!!!! 😭💕 much love to her kind soul“

“The employee named Alexis really went above and beyond to serve me and make sure I understood what I was ordering and answered every question I had. She was so friendly and smiled the entire time; it was refreshing. Ill be honest as I was hesitant due to my last encounter with a man named Allen. Very condescending when I asked any type of questions. I haven't been back since, but I'm glad i gave it another shot! My only issue was all of the fly's.....“

“The server did exactly as I asked, I'm very funny about certain things being on my sandwich! I noticed an onion on it and he made a whole new one for me! I have an allergy to onions! Will definitely come here again!

Wheelchair accessibility: Wheelchair access is on the end of the parking not in the middle like some places!“

“I order online today for the same sub that I haven’t gotten my whole entire life. And it may have been the BEST sub I have ever gotten in my entire life. 10/10 sub and I was greeted with smiling faces. I got the same sub the other day from the capac subway and it didnt even come close to the armada subway sub. Will definitely be back. Highly recommend.“

“I had an amazing time at this restaurant, especially Ryan, he made me and my little brothers day amazing. If the manager is reading this, you better give Ryan a raise or promotion of some kind because he made our day amazing. Thanks to Ryan.“

“When AWS was down, we had tried to order off the Subway website but had issues with the payment. Even though we were charged, the restaurant didn't receive the order. This Subway location made things right by not only providing a refund, but by also allowing us to receive a free footlong sub! Thank you Subway on 21 Mile & Card for the great service on making things right!“