7 Best Italian Restaurants near Union Pier

Mario’s Pizza Union pier Italian • $
Red Arrow Highway Suite 16170, Union Pier

Customers` Favorites

Combo - Italian Beef & Italian Sausage
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Chicken Alfredo Pizza
House Special Pizza
Philly Cheese Steak
Large House Salad
Sausage Calzone
Pepperoni Pizza
Garlic Bread
Antipasto

“Really good food, super nice people“

4.7 Superb194 Reviews
Brewster's New Buffalo Italian • $$
11 West Merchant Street, New Buffalo - 3.55 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pizza with Any Two Toppings Thin Crust Only
Spinach Artichoke Dip
House Salad & Soup
Charcuterie Board
House Salad Soup
Chicken Parmesan
Ice Cream Sundae
Shrimp Alfredo
Dinner for Two
Creme Brulee

“Excellent atmosphere inside and out! Excellent salads, with tender generous steak chunks and one with tender generous chicken, both with wonderful dressings! Bruschetta- amazing! Kristen and bar tender teammate were perfect! Highly recommend!“

4.5 Superb682 Reviews
Terrace Room Italian
111 West Water Street, New Buffalo - 3.59 miles

Customers` Favorites

Ravioles in White Sauce
Pappardelle Bolognese
Spaghetti & Meatballs
Rigatoni Arrabbiata
Seafood Cioppino
Brussels Sprouts
Scampi Al Forno
Ravioli Bandera
Chicken Bandera
Creamy Tiramisu

“Long time patron of the Terrace Room here. I’m a local and have loved the evolution this space has travelled from years ago. Recently ate here again with my husband (use to eat here 1x a month, now less frequent) and was a bit disappointed. The ambience and setting is stellar and basically the best in the region. First point, the price point is hard not to notice. That being said, I get it. It is a tough business and margins are slim. However, this brings me to the second point: If you need to price things where it costs literally hundreds of dollars for a meal for two, the service must be impeccable. Here is where service detracted from the experience. Our server was very nice and well meaning. However, he recited the day’s specials highlighting what he DIDN’T know about each item. For example “I haven’t seen it” or “Not sure what peppers the chef is using in that entree”….etc. This detracted from the experience. Also, steak didn’t come with a steak knife; had to ask for one. Again, not a big deal, but when you’re already feeling the price pinch, you want everything to be stellar to make up for that. Additionally, they use to serve lovely warm bread with olive oil - that is gone! We really missed that special touch. I’d also like them to add to the wine list so there is more than Italian wines. Finally, they serve complimentary small cookies for an after dinner sweet (if you don’t order dessert). Of course, this is lovely. However, they have been serving the same, literally, after dinner cookies for 15 years. Would like to see some variety. How about biscotti, or some chocolates? It is hard not feel like you are paying for more (which is literally true and not their fault) and receiving less - which is also true (no bread!). I love this place, but a bit disappointed and less likely to frequent as often.“

4.7 Superb150 Reviews
Farina's Supper Club Italian • $$$
3311 Pottawattomie Trail, Michigan City - 8.68 miles

Customers` Favorites

Nana's Gravy Save Some for Me
Italian Wedge Salad

“The food was delicious and the atmosphere was so unique. It was beautiful all decked out for the holidays.“

4.1 Good321 Reviews
Villa Nova Pizzeria - New Buffalo Italian • $
134 East Buffalo Street, New Buffalo - 3.42 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cheesy Italian Beef Sandwich
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Breadsticks with Cheese
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Spinach Artichoke Dip
Pizza by the Slice
Buffalo Chicken
Marinara Sauce
Slice of Pizza

“the pizza is outstanding! I would eat it everyday if I lived closer. the staff is always wonderful. it's always on the list of places to go when I'm in town“

4.1 Good267 Reviews
D’Agostinos Navajo Bar and Grille | Italian Bar • $$
8970 Red Arrow Highway, Bridgman - 11.4 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicago Style Italian Beef Sandwich
Mushroom Grilled Onion Swiss Burger
D’Agostino’S Baked Lasagna
Perch Dinner Pan Sautéed
Baked Shrimp Tortellini
Mushroom Swiss Burger
Salmon & Green Beans
Fisherman's Platter
Lamb & Green Beans
Fettuccine Alfredo

“This is an awesome place to eat and the food is cooked perfectly. Highly recommend anything on the menu.“

4.5 Superb178 Reviews
Roma Pizza Pizza • $
9673 Red Arrow Highway, Bridgman - 10.4 miles

Customers` Favorites

16 Sausage Pepperoni N Mushroom Pizza
Sausage Ham Canadian Bacon and Onions
Sausage Mushroom Onion Green Pepper
Large Sausage and Ham Pizza
Small Combination Pizza
Sausage Jalapeño Pizza
Garlic Cheese Bread
Small Cheese Pizza
Meat Lovers Pizza
Poor Boy Sandwich

“I don't understand the negative reviews for this place. My husband and I decided to try it out on our personal time after our work place, Cook Nuclear, got pizza for the night shift and after a co worker suggested some meals for us. We went at 9:00 pm and ordered a 12 inch pizza, 2 half philly cheesesteaks and an order of mozz sticks. The price came out to around $50, which is a tad pricey, but given that this is a family-owned small business, I'll take that any day over Pizza Hut or Domino's. The pizza was fresh and so aesthetically pleasing to look at. The mozz sticks were so fresh and the cheese pull was insane and the amount of sauce they give you is so amazing compared to what other pizza places give you. The sandwiches were amazing and the amount of meat in it was satisfying. The service was amazing as well, the miss who took our order was sweet and offered us menus to look at to order and the wait time was around 30 minutes which isn't bad at all given that everything is made when you order. 10/10, definitely will eat here again.“

3.7 Good87 Reviews

You May Also Like