16 Best Pizza Restaurants in Rochester

“We tried the pizza for the first time today. It was so good! The owners are so friendly also. Definitely our new favorite pizza. If you haven't tried it yet we highly recommend doing so!“

“We ordered the Big Peppi with New York style crust and it was very good! Cheesy and a bit spicy. We loved it! When we were leaving we saw the dessert case and decided to try the cheesecake and a couple of the bars. They were very sweet but delicious!!“

“Pasquale’s pizza is one of the best pizzas in Rochester and their calzones were tasty. As a foodie that travels all over the place to try new restaurants, this place had great quality food and even better an amazing staff! Rochester is blessed to have Pasquale’s!“

“Godfathers is our go-to when we want a phenomenal pizza! Yes, their prices are higher than other chains, but it is definitely worth it! Just tried their bone-in wings yesterday and they are delicious as well.
Their loyalty program allows you to earn points towards free items and the amount you get is more than other places so it doesnt take long to earn enough to get something for free.“

“1st time there, rented a couple screens for my daughters birthday and had family come. Staff were on point and friendly. The multi sports simulators were pretty dang fun, and the food was great. Great place to celebrate a kids birthday in town. Will def be going back for random nights of fun.“

“Great tasting pizza! They are a family owned business in Rochester. Zadeos has two types of crusts: a hand-tossed original New York style crust and thin crust. They have a variety of specialty pizzas such as a Premiere, Meat Supreme, and Taco pizza. You definitely exact portions/toppings for what you pay for. They also have a lunch buffet from 11:00am to 1:30pm Tuesday through Saturday, which includes single topping pizza, meatballs, garlic bread, and a salad bar.“

“Chicago style pizza was great! Sauce was tasty. Crust was light and flavorful. Italian sausage has a deep star anice flavor. All good things in my book.“

“Thank you Linda for adding the Pi Salad to the Tilda's Menu like we had requested. It is one of our 3 favorite salads in Rochester and we happily ordered it tonight with our pizza. We just love your two pizza joints! We got to see Bella in action too. She is very sweet. Your pizzas are amazing!“

“Brought our kids/grandkids out for pizza. two extra large and one gluten free. The pizzas had generous toppings and cheese and quality tasting ingredients. The GF pizza was wonderful...rare for GF. Really nice waitress as well!“

“Shout out to Adam at papa murphys north. Today was a busy day so we got pizza for dinner. I popped in the store and found Adam cleaning he kindly greeted me and stoped what he was doing to take my order. I have been eating papa murphys for almost 10 years but today was different. It started with great service from Adam and ended with even better pizza. Papa murphys please give this man a raise!“

“Always great pizza at this location. Order online and they are usually ready within a half hour for pickup, which is really easy. Just walk in, look for it in the pickup rack, and you’re out and on your way home to a great pizza that also makes excellent leftovers when reheated. The Tuesday deals are the best!“

“I ordered a few items and two fountain drinks to go. Way more than I could carry out to my vehicle myself. I waited a little longer than usual for the food to be done, so for the longer wait I was given an extra item and apologized to - very kind! On top of that, the men realized I wouldn’t be able to carry all of my stuff so they offered to help. I didn’t catch the guy’s name that helped me carry my items to my vehicle, but I am very grateful! It was so unbelievably generous! Excellent pizza and beyond excellent service! Well done and THANK YOU!!!“

“Went on Friday with a couple 9-year-olds. They were busy and the pizza took awhile to come out. The server offered us free dessert as a “sorry.” Wasn’t necessary (we were fine waiting) but an astute move. The girls took home a piece of Oreo cheesecake which was amazing!“

“Just visiting Rochester, tired, hungry. We decided to order and have delivery. Best choice ever. What a great pizza (meat) hand tossed crust ( delicious). Quick friendly delivery. I highly recommend!“

“Delicious!!! Always friendly and wonderful service!“

“Fantastic customer service at this location. Currently they don't have drivers of their own and are outsourcing to a third-party; this works fine most of the time. Just had a Doordasher pick up my order and go AWOL without even registering in the system that he had my food. This team not only apologized but remade my order for free (I decided to go get it myself to save time) for an inconvenience that I understand was out of their control. Cool experience from a humble location.“